Berlin Bans Mohels From Performing Ritual Circumcisions

September 5, 2012 10:32 am 7 comments

Hospital in Berlin-Köpenick. Photo: wiki commons.

Germany’s capital city of Berlin has announced new rules on circumcision procedures, banning Jewish mohels from performing the ritual and requiring that both parents of a child who is scheduled to be circumcised, provide written confirmation that they have been made aware of the health risks involved.

“We explicitly welcome Muslim and Jewish life in Berlin,” said Thomas Heilmann, Berlin’s top justice official. “That is only possible if freedom to practice religion is possible.”

When the parents of a child who is set to be circumcised provide a written expression of their consent, they must also provide proof of “religious motivation and religious necessity of the circumcision”.

The new rules set forth by Berlin require circumcision procedures to be performed by doctors, in a “medically professional standard”.  According to Heilmann, circumcisions do not need to take place in hospitals and Jewish mohels are not currently trained to perform the procedures under Berlin’s new law.

Heilmann says the new law comes out of requests from German doctors for clarity on the issue of circumcision, after a court in Cologne banned ritual circumcision procedures in June.

Germany’s parliament is expected to draft new legislation on the issue, and Berlin’s new law will stand until that time.

Similar attempts to ban ritual circumcisions in Norway, Switzerland, and Austria have prompted a response from Muslim and Jewish groups in Europe, stating their opposition to what they call “attacks against our religious practices”.

7 Comments

  • Ari Rubenstein

    Yes brothers, it is time to leave! Gather your families and move to Israel now! The right is rising VERY fast and if we do not leave as soon as possible for the chosen land the slaughter will be worse than that suffered during WWII! Be warned now because the speed with which these things happen can be at the snap of a finger when anger is running as high as it is right now. The only safe place for God’s chosen is Israel – let us all go there and support OUR state against the heathen! Do not think you can fight this because the nationalists care not for our laws and will burn down everything to get to us! Let us be safe, let us take pro-active action and go to our place of strength in Israel now!!!

  • Ilbert Phillips

    Germans do not change. This is outrageous. We are talking about a ritual that is over three thousand years old. We have recently learned that circumcision is has health benefits (it inhibits HIV and other sexual diseases).

  • Right. Get out of Germany and get out of Europe. We cannot say that we have not been warned this time. Circumstances are the worse they have been in decades. And, as always, we Jews are the scapegoats.

    Get out! Get out! Get out! Israel needs you and wants you. Europe is our graveyard.

    German medical standards? What medical standards has a county that gives a medical degree to Josef Mengele?

    • Jews must leave Europe now before its too late and come to America and or Israel. LANCE

      • What makes you so certain that US is safe? San Francisco attempted to ban circumcism too and probably will since it is so liberal, it will do anything to dis Jewish religion.

  • The die is cast. Germany has made its intentions crystal clear. Today they ban the Brit tomorrow they make us wear the yellow star. Leave as fast as you can and don’t look back.

Leave a Reply

Please note: comments may be published in the Algemeiner print edition.


More...

  • Personalities Sports NBA Finals a Time to Remember Legendary Jewish Coach Red Auerbach

    NBA Finals a Time to Remember Legendary Jewish Coach Red Auerbach

    JNS.org - At the start of each nationally televised game of the 2013 NBA Finals between the San Antonio Spurs and the Miami Heat, ABChas aired a film-clip montage of basketball’s great players and coaches—a montage that includes Jewish coach Arnold “Red” Auerbach, the mastermind behind nine championship teams for the Boston Celtics. Red was one of four children of Marie and Hyman Auerbach. Hyman was a Russian-Jewish immigrant who left Belarus when he was 13. The couple owned a deli and [...]

    Read more →
  • Arts and Culture Jewish History The Marx Brothers and Jewish Identity

    The Marx Brothers and Jewish Identity

    JNS.org - The sons of Jewish immigrants from Germany and France, the Marx Brothers became zany masters of stage and screen who continue to captivate audiences. But in addition to providing comic relief, their films captured the drama of the entry of their marginalized religion into the U.S. Wayne Koestenbaum, author of the 2012 book The Anatomy of Harpo Marx, explains that the Marx Brothers’ Jewishness as a family “was evident, marked, thoroughly legible.” “Within a family already marked as Jewish within [...]

    Read more →
  • Arts and Culture Jewish Identity SuperJew

    SuperJew

    For my shekels, the question of whether the comic book character Superman, is Jewish or not shouldn’t even be questioned. Born and named Kal-El by his father Jor-El, “El” is one of the ancient names for God used throughout the bible and found in great prophets such as Samue-el, Dani-el and angels Micha-el and Gavri-el and of course, Isra-el. As Simcha Weinstein in his entertaining book, “Up, Up And Oy Vey” points out, “Kal” is the root of several Hebrew [...]

    Read more →
  • Israel Sports Formula 1 Road Show Thrills Jerusalem

    Formula 1 Road Show Thrills Jerusalem

    JNS.org – Some 100,000 people attended Israel’s first-ever Formula 1 Road Show in Jerusalem on Thursday and Friday. For several hours, the controversies that normally characterize Jerusalem were put aside, and a diverse mosaic of Israelis watched up close as the motor-sport stars temporarily conquered the city. “It was an amazing experience, the most fast and furious thing I have seen,” spectator Masada Porat told Israel Hayom. “It was a rare, extreme event that explodes in your face.” Spectator Irena [...]

    Read more →
  • Book Reviews Jewish Identity Klara’s Journey Casts Jews in Fast-Paced Adventure Through Russian History

    Klara’s Journey Casts Jews in Fast-Paced Adventure Through Russian History

    JNS.org – “If you’re sick, move away. Have some consideration for others,” a red army soldier scolds a slow-moving old man selling train tickets. “No, fires back the old man, proud, haughty, not realizing it’s a new country, a Bolshevik country where force heads the list instead of civility,” reads the following line in Ben G. Frank’s new novel, Klara’s Journey, released June 1. Reminiscent of Boris Pasternak’s Dr. Zhivago—whose backdrop is also a train ride across the Russian frontier during the [...]

    Read more →
  • Personalities Theater Nora Ephron, Famed Jewish Screenwriter, Remembered Through Tribeca Film Festival Prize

    Nora Ephron, Famed Jewish Screenwriter, Remembered Through Tribeca Film Festival Prize

    JNS.org – For filmmaker Meera Menon, no honor could have been more fitting than winning the inaugural award named after famed Jewish screenwriter and novelist Nora Ephron, the woman whose work inspired her. At the recent 2013 Tribeca Film Festival, Menon was named the first recipient of the $25,000 Nora Ephron Prize, given to a writer or director whose work embodies that of the late Ephron, who wrote the scripts for a number of hit films, including “When Harry Met [...]

    Read more →
  • Book Reviews Personalities Book Review: ‘Jewish Jordan’ Memoir an Important Guide for Players and Coaches

    Book Review: ‘Jewish Jordan’ Memoir an Important Guide for Players and Coaches

    JNS.org – Despite his friends’ and family’s doubts that a young Orthodox Jewish athlete could ever play college or professional basketball without compromising his religious values, between 1999 and 2009 the “Jewish Jordan” defied conventional wisdom and found his place on the court. In his new memoir, Jewish Jordan’s Triple Threat, Tamir Goodman describes his triumphs and disappointments in life, crediting his practice of Judaism for shaping his identity as an athlete and his understanding of basketball as a team sport. [...]

    Read more →
  • Blogs Sports Omri Casspi, ‘Jewish Jordan’ Partner on Basketball Camps to Inspire Youths On and Off the Court

    Omri Casspi, ‘Jewish Jordan’ Partner on Basketball Camps to Inspire Youths On and Off the Court

    Tamir Goodman (left) and NBA forward Omri Casspi—pictured on the court of the United Center, home of the Chicago Bulls—together run basketball camps that seek to inspire youths on and off the court. Photo: Courtesy Tamir Goodman. JNS.org – Before last year, basketball camps for Jewish youths never had an instructor quite like Omri Casspi, a forward for the National Basketball Association’s (NBA) Cleveland Cavaliers and the first Israeli-born player in NBA history. Casspi is a de facto ambassador for [...]

    Read more →
Sign up now to receive our regular news briefs.