Annexation and Withdrawal: A Modest Proposal

December 4, 2012 10:26 am 25 comments

Map of Ancient Israel

When is enough really enough? For the State of Israel, apparently, still not yet.

Israeli military occupation over the “West Bank” is a 45-year-old mistake and must now end with Israel’s official annexation of the Jewish heartland. There should also be a withdrawal, not from any land but from the United Nations.

For the sake of Jewish identity, heritage, and history – and of Israeli security and survivability – Israel should immediately assert sovereignty over Judea and Samaria (Judah, Benjamin, Ephraim, and west Menasheh), granting Palestinian Arabs the dignified options of permanent residency status or emigration with compensation.

Those Arabs who wish to remain should be allowed to do so and enjoy the rights of permanent residents while fulfilling the attendant responsibilities. Those who wish to leave should be paid fair market value for their property, plus a reasonable sum to cover moving expenses to Jordan (Palestine) or elsewhere. Those who insist on violence should be dealt with accordingly.

Israel should also withdraw immediately from the United Nations (whose full name seems more accurately to be UNAI, the United Nations Against Israel) and help found a robust league of democracies, a new body where human rights violators don’t preside over human rights councils and where blocs of Islamists and communists don’t dictate to progressive republics. The UN might have arguably been the greatest endeavor man ever embarked upon; instead, it is a tiresome farce run by malevolent circus clowns. This is one club to which the Jew, and the Jewish State, should not belong and not wish to belong.

These are no extreme measures; rather, they are reasonable and moderate propositions representing nothing more than common sense. Such steps ought to have been taken long ago.

Whatever Israel does or does not do, it will face global condemnation. Therefore, it only stands to reason that it should do what is necessary and proper for its fundamental needs as the Jewish national home, and act both domestically and internationally with self-respect and determination on behalf of all its citizens and residents, Jewish or otherwise. Acting with halfheartedness and trepidation invites the world’s contempt like nothing else.

Israel, you are not the world’s piñata; end the masochism. It’s enough already.

25 Comments

  • I can’t tell if you’re being satirical or not . . .

  • Miriam, BE”H, the much, if not all, of the Sinai will be ours again. What will we do with the Arabs that you sent there? ;-)

  • I totally agree with Brandon’s comments that Israel should get on with the annexation of the ‘West Bank’ and have thought and prayed about this for several months now. this is Bibi’s opportunity to be a ‘king maker’ as was hinted at in the Time magazine feature back in May. Israel has absolutely nothing to loose and everything to gain. The recent Levy Report confirms it would be Israel’s legal right in accordance with International Law to annex the ‘heartland’ of Israel.

  • Transfer of all of the Arab population from the land that used to be called “Palestinian mandate” to the Sinai peninsula, an area of land that is comparable with the entire Palestinian mandate, which included Israel, Gaza, Judea, Samaria, Golan Heights and Jordan! This plan provides the opportunity for a permanent peace:

    • Thank you for the petition link. I just signed it and will forward to my 2 lists. I’d love to spread this too:

      “JEW GO HOME!!!”

      YOUNG/HEALTHY/STRONG JEWS & SYMPATHIZERS: STOP WHINING/CRITICIZING ISRAEL:
      NO COUNTRY WILL HELP US. NO ANTISEMITES EVER CHANGE. LEAVE YOUR ROTTEN COUNTRIES AND STAY IN ISRAEL. PROCREATE IN ABUNDANCE AND FIGHT FIERCELY AS NEVER BEFORE. EMPOWER ISRAEL TO REGAIN HER RIGHTFULLY-WON TERRITORIES AND EXPAND! ISRAEL NEEDS TO PREVAIL IN FULL FORCE, INCREASING POWER CONTINUALLY TO ASSURE NOT BEING ATTACKED EVER AGAIN!!! ISRAEL NEEDS YOU, YOUNG AND HEALTHY YIDS NOW! HOW ELSE DID AMERICA BECOME GREAT? IT’S NAIVE/INSANE TO “TALK” THE WORLD TO RESPECT US!!! UNTIL WHEN THE BLOODY MERRY-GO-ROUND??? TOO MUCH ISRAELI BLOODSHED FOR NOTHING! STOP THE STATUS QUO AND GIVE A PURPOSE TO BLOODSHED – IT’S TIME TO KILL OR BE KILLED AND FINISH THIS VICIOUS CIRCLE ONCE AND FOR ALL!!! http://wordfromjerusalem.com/?p=4033

  • Esther Sarah Evans

    b”H
    Aye, ’tis a good idea.

  • Too simplistic and disruptive an approach, I think. A more realistic (and less hazardous) plan might be something akin to the APoJi proposal; see link provided @ my name.

    Your concept may represent more risk than I would deem prudent, Brandon, but your ideas have been duly noted and will be given appropriate consideration. Thanks.

    Froy, don’t write off the usefulness of a special permanent residency class, as outlined in the aforementioned doc.

    • You try and give them permanent residency. See how many seconds they take to start a civil rights movement asking for full citizenship, and how many minutes the world supports them en masse. We are in the 21st Century. You can’t keep people stateless. Everyone has a right to citizenship and nationality in their country of birth.

  • annexing gaza as well, as it is part of our torah-land.
    “permanent residency”? i don’t know. any residency must be contingent on loyalty to the state of israel…how many of them would do that?

    but your statement is clear, necessary and yes, should’ve been done lonig ago.

  • Permanent resident status is a much better deal than any Jews would get in a “palestinian” state.

  • For 19 years(1948-1967) the Arab/Muslim world had the chance to demonstrate that it accepted Israel within those pre1967 borders. Did they? Of course not. For 19 years the Arabs/Muslims invaded Israel on a nightly basis killing as many Jews as they could each night. The PLO was formed in 1964…I repeat 1964…
    The PLO CHARTER calls for the murder of six million Jews…
    Those 19 years make clear to true intentions of the Arab/Muslim world toward Israel and in fact all Jews.

    .

  • Wow, “permanent resident status”! So generous! Considering they are living in their own ancestral homeland where they and all their known ancestors were born, they must be thrilled to be offered the chance of becoming permanently stateless for the rest of their lives along with those of their descendants, or being offered money to go into exile. I’m sure they will be queuing up to accept your deal. Just hold your breath until they start arriving.

    • Such a bunch of baloney, Mr. Froy!
      If you just read some history, or even travel journals, like “The Innocents Abroad” by Mark Twain, certainly not a Jewish sympathizer, written in the mid 1850′s; or some REAL HISTORY, like Joan Peters’ book; “From Time Immemorial” (see abstracts here: http://www.eretzyisroel.org/~peters/ ) you’d know that what is probably over 80% of today’s “palestinians” were NOWHERE TO BE FOUND IN “Palestine” – which is, BTW, an INSULTING term chosen by Roman Emperor Hadrian to ERASE THE MEMORY OF THE KINGDOM OF JUDEA after he deported over 1.5 million Jews! What some call “Palestinians”, a term reserved exclusively for Jews until the late 1940′s, were just Arabs living in Sudan, Syria, Saudi Arabia, Egypt, Bosnia and even Afghanistan until the JEWS STARTED TO COME BACK TO THEIR ANCESTRAL AND LARGELY DESERT LAND EN MASSE in the 1870′s. Most of the Arabs living today in the land of Israel are PEOPLE WITH NO HISTORICAL AND RELIGIOUS CONNECTION TO THAT LAND, but the REAL FOREIGNERS, descending from ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS, as both OTTOMAN AND BRITISH DOCUMENTS PROVE.

      • Accusing someone of using “baloney” and quoting Joan Peters in the same paragraph is quite a show of nerve.

    • Froy, are you joking? You must be a heck of a comedian to say that Judea and Samaria is the “ancient homeland” of the people who call themselves “Palestinians”.

      If I’m wrong, please name one “palestinian” king, currency, historical dates, places, people, it’s borders, when it existed and how it stopped existing.

      You have got to be kidding. When you write things like this, you either show your incredible comedic ability or your complete lack of knowledge or your anti-semitism.

    • Not saying Israel should follow your suggestion, just pointing out that the Muslim World is big on population transfer and they don’t offer compensation either, Iranians displaced, Kurds displace, 400 000 Pals displaced from Kuwait, 10s of 1000′s from Syria in recent months. Of course the usual liberal narrative would be to demonise Israel as Nazis. By the way what Arab state compensated Jews for having to flee after 1948.

    • Froy. Ancestral homeland? Time to send them back to Syria, Egypt and Jordan where the Arabs come from. Oh that’s right! Their homelands never accepted them and kept them as “refugees” with the hope of one day wiping out the State of Israel, the true ancestors of the land of Israel (All 12 tribes).

      Froy, if you are not Muslim, they will be coming for your land soon, probably already in the process of being taken.

    • Hey Froy–i do agree 100% with your views – it stinks==
      Really —- The Israelis do not want PEACE- and the Americans do nothing about-it = the People in Charge of Israel have not Learned from the Past .

    • ONLY the Jewish people and no one else have had a continued presence in THE JEWISH homeland. Do your homework. Nowhere in the Koran is Jerusalem even mentioned.

    • Froy. Misled as you are by your media circus, can I at least offer you some indisputable facts. Ancient ancestors:- arabs with whom I work in a quarry in the Jordan valley come from the village of Reina (next to Nazareth) and the extended family (most of the village) name is Tattour and they are the proud descendants of Tartar moslems brought over by the Turkish Ottoman empire about 120 years ago. Likewise, the nearby village of Kfar Kama is of Caucasion origin and date and in fact all signs in their village are written in cyrilic. Christian missionary records and Mark Twains visit at the latter part of the 19th century, remark of the paucity of arab villages. Crusader records show even fewer arab presences. Finally, Abed Ali, mohameds’ second in command (due to his literacy) records almost no presence of non Jews. You surely can’t accuse him of being biased.

    • It isn’t their ancestral homeland. They’re squatters, at best.

    • Hey Mr. Froy…if you love the palestinians so much why don’t you go join them and see how life is among them? See if you can stand them, then….don’t blame me if you get sick of them, that is, if they don’t cut your throat first!

  • I believe that the idea of compensating Palestinians to move our of the territories can be done without making such a huge deal of this. If only Sheldon Adelson (and others) would use their money to compensate people who move out rather than trying to buy the President. It can be done right away.

Leave a Reply

Please note: comments may be published in the Algemeiner print edition.


Current day month ye@r *

More...

  • Arts and Culture Middle East Hamas Commander Reportedly Urges Hezbollah to Join Forces Against Israel

    Hamas Commander Reportedly Urges Hezbollah to Join Forces Against Israel

    JNS.org – Five months after Israeli forces tried to assassinate Hamas military commander Mohammed Deif in Gaza, Deif appears to have signed a letter that the terrorist group claims he wrote in hiding. The letter, addressed to Hezbollah chief Hassan Nasrallah, expressed Deif’s condolences for the death of Hezbollah terrorists during Sunday’s reported Israeli airstrike in Syria. Deif is said to have survived multiple assassination attempts, but he has not been seen in public for years. According to the Hezbollah-linked Al-Manar [...]

    Read more →
  • Jewish Identity Theater Shlomo Carlebach Musical Has the Soul to Heal Frayed Race Relations

    Shlomo Carlebach Musical Has the Soul to Heal Frayed Race Relations

    JNS.org – The cracks that had been simply painted over for so long began to show in Ferguson, Mo., in November 2014, but in truth they had begun to open wide much earlier—on Saturday, July 13, 2013. That is when a jury in Sanford, Fla., acquitted George Zimmerman of culpability for the death of a 17-year-old black man, Trayvon Martin. The cracks receded from view over time, as other news obscured them. Then came the evening of Aug. 9, 2014, [...]

    Read more →
  • Theater US & Canada ‘Homeland’ Season Finale Stirs Controversy After Comparing Menachem Begin to Taliban Leader

    ‘Homeland’ Season Finale Stirs Controversy After Comparing Menachem Begin to Taliban Leader

    A controversial scene in the season finale of Homeland sparked outrage by comparing former Israeli Prime Minister Menachem Begin to a fictional Taliban leader, the UK’s Daily Mail reported. In the season 4 finale episode, which aired on Dec. 21, CIA black ops director Dar Adal, played by F. Murray Abraham, justifies a deal he made with a Taliban leader by referencing Begin. He makes the remarks in a conversation with former CIA director Saul Berenson, a Jewish character played by Mandy [...]

    Read more →
  • Arts and Culture Spirituality/Tradition Placing Matisyahu Back Within a Life of Observance

    Placing Matisyahu Back Within a Life of Observance

    Shining Light on Fiction During the North Korea-Sony saga, we learned two important lessons. The first is that there are two sides to this story, and neither of them are correct because ultimately we should have neither inappropriate movies nor dictators. The second is that we cannot remain entirely fixed on the religious world, but we also must see beyond the external, secular view of reality. It’s important to ground our Torah-based thoughts into real-life activism. To view our act [...]

    Read more →
  • Arts and Culture Blogs Nine Decades of Moses at the Movies

    Nine Decades of Moses at the Movies

    JNS.org – Hollywood has had its share of big-budget biblical flops, but until now, the Exodus narrative has not been among them. Studios have brought Moses to the big screen sparingly, but in ways that defined the image and character of Moses for each generation of audiences. The first biblical epic In 1923, director Cecil B. DeMille left it to the American public to decide the subject of his next movie for Paramount. DeMille received a letter from a mechanic [...]

    Read more →
  • Arts and Culture Blogs Exodus on Screen (REVIEW)

    Exodus on Screen (REVIEW)

    JNS.org – The story of the Exodus from Egypt is a tale as old as time itself, to borrow a turn of phrase. It’s retold every Passover, both at the seder table and whenever “The Ten Commandments” is aired on television. But the latest adaptation—Ridley Scott’s epic film, “Exodus: Gods and Kings”—fails to meet expectations. Scott’s “Exodus” alters the source material to service the story and ground the tale, but the attempt to reinvent the biblical narrative becomes laughable. Moses [...]

    Read more →
  • Jewish Identity Lifestyle ‘Jewish Food Movement’ Comes of Age

    ‘Jewish Food Movement’ Comes of Age

    JNS.org - In December 2007, leaders of the Hazon nonprofit drafted seven-year goals for what they coined as the “Jewish Food Movement,” which has since been characterized by the increased prioritization of healthy eating, sustainable agriculture, and food-related activism in the Jewish community. What do the next seven years hold in store? “One thing I would like to see happen in the next seven years is [regarding] the issue of sugar, soda, and obesity, [seeing] what would it be like to rally the [...]

    Read more →
  • Blogs Education Seeds of ‘Start-Up Nation’ Cultivated by Israel Sci-Tech Schools

    Seeds of ‘Start-Up Nation’ Cultivated by Israel Sci-Tech Schools

    JNS.org – Forget the dioramas. How about working on an Israeli Air Force drone? That’s exactly the kind of beyond-their-years access enjoyed by students at the Israel Aerospace Industries (IAI) industrial vocational high school run by Israel Sci-Tech Schools, the largest education network in the Jewish state. More than 300 students (250 on the high school level and 68 at a two-year vocational academy) get hands-on training in the disciplines of aviation mechanics, electricity and energy control, and unmanned air [...]

    Read more →



Sign up now to receive our regular news briefs.