Sign up now to receive our regular news briefs.

EXCLUSIVE: Audio Reveals Brooklyn College Misled Public on Eviction of Jewish Students From BDS Event (AUDIO)

February 12, 2013 6:29 pm 27 comments

Karen L. Gould, the president of Brooklyn College. Photo: CUNY.

An audio recording obtained exclusively by The Algemeiner appears to indicate that Brooklyn College representatives misled the public in their account of events that took place at Thursday night’s BDS (Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions) event aimed at Israel and sponsored by the University’s Political Science Department, where four Jewish students were evicted by security personnel.

On Friday, Brooklyn College explained the incident by accusing the students of disrupting the event in no uncertain terms, with spokesperson Jeremy Thompson telling The Algemeiner, “From the first speaker they began to speak out, they were becoming vocal and disruptive to the members around them and one of the student organizers of the event went to them and said ‘you really need to be quiet you’re disrupting other people around you.’ They then did not comply and a couple of police officers asked them to come out into the lobby.” Thompson also added that school officials in attendance, including Brooklyn College Vice President Milga Morales, confirmed this account.

The four students — Melanie Goldberg, Ari Ziegler, Yvonne Juris, and Michael Ziegler—contended, however, that they were thrown out for possessing BDS fact sheets. Goldberg told The Algemeiner the day after the event that “One of the SJP (Students for Justice in Palestine, which organized the event) members came over and got really close to my face and told me to give him the sheets, or he would call security. I told him I would not. We were simply taking notes so we could ask informed questions like we were encouraged to do by the school and Political Science Department.”

When Goldberg then asked Brooklyn College Vice President Milga Morales  to intervene, as she was nearby during the incident, she declined to do so.

“I told her this was a clear violation of academic freedom, she just looked at me and said ‘this is their event, they can do what they want,’ which is not true, the political science department co-sponsored it,” Goldberg recounted.

The student who confronted Goldberg was later identified as SJP member Carlos Guzman.

In an opinion piece he wrote for The New York Daily News, Ari Ziegler also vehemently denied the school’s allegations:

“As far as I can tell, what happened is that a student who disagreed with my views called security and told them to remove me. The fact is that I was barred from asking questions in an open forum, from trying to understand an opposing viewpoint,” he wrote.

“The college has said that ‘based on official reports, they were being quite disruptive.’ This is a complete fabrication,” Ziegler added.

The audio file makes plain that the school was falsely accusing the students, and/or greatly exaggerating the claims made by SJP members that the students were being disruptive throughout their time at the lecture. The file captures the first speaker, Judith Butler, and terminates at the ejection of the four students. At the 28:14 mark Melanie Goldberg can clearly be heard saying, “I’m not allowed to hold a pamphlet?” This appears to contradict the claim made by Brooklyn College that the students were simply asked to be quiet and did not comply, and one made by an SJP organizer that they were asked to quiet down and stop passing fliers between themselves before they were ejected. At the end of the audio file you can hear Goldberg saying, “This is an oppression of freedom of speech, this is an oppression…”  no time before that, despite the fact that according to The Algemeiner’s source the recording device was positioned only two rows in front of the Jewish students and was able to clearly pick up the voice of Judith Butler several rows ahead, does it appear that any disturbance was being caused. In fact, the first time a voice is clearly audible besides that of Butler’s is when Melanie Goldberg asks about the pamphlet, 28 minutes into the event.

Yesterday CUNY Chancellor Matthew Goldstein issued a statement in which he said an investigation into the incident would commence. “There were reports that some said they were asked without cause to leave the event.  If this were true, it was wrong and we need to understand exactly what the circumstances were.  At the request of President Karen L. Gould, I have asked General Counsel and Senior Vice Chancellor for Legal Affairs Frederick P. Schaffer to quickly investigate these allegations. This investigation will be coordinated by CUNY’s Office of Legal Affairs, working with an independent consultant, and charged with reporting directly back to me,” Goldstein said.

From statements made today by Brooklyn College, it appears the school has backtracked somewhat from its earlier statements—statements that were given with the backing of anonymous school officials and the vice president of the school.

The school told The Algemeiner in a statement Tuesday that “Given the serious concerns raised by the students, President Gould has asked the university to conduct a thorough independent review of the college’s actions in order to ascertain all the facts. We stand by our previous statements that the college should be a place where all may express their views. If we learn that these students were denied that opportunity without cause, as they allege, the decision to have them removed will have been inappropriate and the college will issue a formal apology.”

The audio of the Brooklyn College BDS event can be heard below:


  • Three outstanding facts
    1)An event calling for the destruction of Israel was sponsored by Brooklyn “college”, and not by a student organization. Therefore, the administration of Brooklyn “college” is officially on record as supporting the destruction of Israel. This is antizionist
    2) Jews were excluded from this event, and was witnessed by VP Milga Morales, who by not intervening, demonstrated approval of Jewish exclusion. This is not just antizionist, but antisemitic as well
    3) Brooklyn “college” tried to cover this up

    Necessary steps to be taken
    1) Public funding to institutions that espouse anti-semitism must end.
    2) President Gould and VP Morales must resign effective immediately
    3) Employers should seriously consider whether applicants who have degrees from Brooklyn “college” truly are college educated.

  • So refreshing to know that no one give a hoot about the 70,000 plus muslims that are being tortured and slaugthered by fellow muslims in syria. yes, let’s boycott israel, folks and your women soon will be wearing burkas.

  • B’SD
    The Jewish students musty have more rallies to go after BDS and run Gould the backstabber to Jews and Israel out JDO says on theri website.

    Recently an Al Qaeda Islamic Nazi was arrested from that group and was attending Brooklyn College Politiccal Science Dept.

    Read more about this

  • The proceedings must be recorded, video and audio, to prove or disprove the charges.

    And the “political science” department should be a sub-department of the Psychology department.

  • Steve Manhattan

    then gee Lance, your buddy Bernie the attorney was apparently way off on his “rule” regarding Zionists since I don’t seem to remember Jewish or pro Israel students shouting down anyone. And what’s Bernie’s on on these junior Islamic fascists? Anything goes as long as they wear a kaffiyeh?

  • The comments remind me of what my Jewish friend, Bernie the Attorney said about typical Zionist discourse. He said it usually falls into what he calls “the 180 rule” (i.e. acussing others of your own tactics).

    • Liar (or at least malicious antagonist, fabricator), with a rich creative fantasy, pants on fire!

    • lancebuster,

      Is that like Islamists accusing Israelis of hijacking four passenger planes on 9/11?

      Or Islamists accusing Israelis of bombing London transport on 7/7/05?

  • Judith Butler erred in stating that Israeli Arabs cannot serve in the military. They are not required to serve but may if they choose to do so. Shocking that given her anti-Israeli activism she would be so unaware of so basic a fact.

  • What goes around comes around. Take courage my Jewish friend.

  • The Jewish students should institute a massive suit against the school, its admin, and BDS and the members involved for depriving American citizens of their Constitutional right, and harassment. And, in this process, they should seek to remove the foreign heads of BDS from US shores.

    Further, the school should be deprived of US taxpayer public funding, and the administrators involved, dismissed.

  • This audio is self explanatory, Jews are right- Brooklyn College and SJP are wrong.

  • Pure, blatant Anti-Semitism. This is worse than anyone imagined. Stuff lawsuits are made of.

  • A formal apology would not be enough. These students should sue CUNY. Even Alan Dershowitz thinks so. See his analysis at

  • I was there, sitting a few rows in front of the disruptors. It is very rude and disruptive to come to an event and distribute fliers while someone is speaking. I don’t understand why its a surprise they were asked to leave.

    • A little rich coming from intolerant BDS supporters who take every opportunity to barge into Jewish/Israeli cultural events and Jewish-owned businesses like thugs

    • There were anti-Israel students at the David Horowitz event screaming out catcalls repeatedly, but campus security refused to ask them to leave. Handing out leaflets is zero compared to the violent catcalls at the Horowitz event, but campus security and Karen Gould refused to ask the disruptive students at the Horowitz event to leave. The students at the Barghouti event were not giving out leaflets. They merely held the leaflets in their hands. It seems like Brooklyn College is like Nazi Germany–anti-Semitic protestors at the Horowitz event must be allowed to stay, but Jews at the Barghouti event are asked to leave for holding notes.

    • Sarah Williams

      There is nothing rude or disruptive about passing fliers back and forth (not “distribute” as you spin it). It’s certainly a lot less rude than Palestinian activists shouting down pro-Israel speakers (UC Irvine, USC, UC Berkeley) and in several cases, blocking doors and knocking people down. Free speech is an American right, as is the right to assemble, and engage in academic discussion. If you don’t like it, move to to an Arab country where you’ll be more at home with unquestioned idolatry of Palestinianism and unfettered Jew-hating.

    • BDS is notorious for disrupting political and cultural events.

  • A formal apology???!!! Too little, too late. What an empty thing. Student should boycott the graduation ceremonies and poli sci majors should change their majors or transfer to another school.

  • It’s good they are saying they are sorry…maybe the snow will lighten up and kids can go back to school! :) To those with wisdom..

  • Brooklyn College has become a place where the Martin Heideggers of the teaching profession can be comfortable professing their admiration for the beauty of Hitler’s hands. Clearly the administration is a group of dhimmis who obey the wishes of a gang of Muslims who revere a sociopath named Muhammad who personally decapitated 900 unarmed Jews at Quarayza.

    • Not quite, Richard. Muhammad did not personally decapitate anyone. Even the final decision for execution was made by someone else. This did not happen at a place called ‘Quarayza’. Bani Qurayza was the name of the Jewish tribe in question. A better argument is to say that, despite being God’s Prophet and the overall ruler of Medina, he did nothing to stop the executions. As in other cases, his evident lack of compassion makes him suspect as a religious leader. Was he a sociopath? Surely that’s something we can’t be sure of.

  • jerry jacobson

    It seems like Brooklyn College is sending a message to Jewish Students. We will tolerate you if you are passive and accept our very liberal left wing views. JUST DON’T BE VOCAL. Keep your opinions to yourself.
    Perhaps people should give their money to other educational institutions.


Leave a Reply

Please note: comments may be published in the Algemeiner print edition. Comments written in all caps will be deleted.

Current day month ye@r *


  • Arts and Culture Beliefs and concepts What’s That Huge White Bridal Dress Floating Over the Tower of David?

    What’s That Huge White Bridal Dress Floating Over the Tower of David? –  “What’s that huge white bridal dress floating over the Tower of David?” That’s what visitors to Jerusalem’s Old City asked last week. The wedding gown, created by leading Israeli artist Motti Mizrachi, is part of the 2nd Jerusalem Biennale for Contemporary Jewish Art, an event that blew into town as the Sukkot holiday got underway. Mizrachi, who lives and works in Tel Aviv, created the dress that floats majestically over the Tower of David, the main exhibition site […]

    Read more →
  • Features Opinion The Top 10 Places to Visit in Israel

    The Top 10 Places to Visit in Israel

    Israel is a holiday destination on many travelers’ bucket lists. No matter the style of holiday you are after, Israel has the answer. Whether you prefer to relax by the beach, hike up mountains in the desert, visit religious and historical sites, eat your way through the country or just enjoy some retail therapy, your journey through Israel will be one to remember. While there are obviously so many things to see and do, here is a list of 10 of […]

    Read more →
  • Pioneers/Philanthropists US & Canada Jewish American Fashion Mogul Ralph Lauren to Step Down as CEO

    Jewish American Fashion Mogul Ralph Lauren to Step Down as CEO – Jewish American fashion mogul Ralph Lauren announced his plan to step down as chief executive officer of the renowned fashion brand. The head of Gap Inc’s Old Navy brand will take over the position. The 75-year-old Lauren, who founded Ralph Lauren Corp. in 1967, will continue to serve as executive chairman and will continue leading the fashion house’s design team, according to a statement by the company. After the announcement, Ralph Lauren shares rose 3.79 percent while Gap shares […]

    Read more →
  • Featured Sports US & Canada Jewish Boxer Dustin ‘White Tiger’ Fleischer Scores Fourth Knockout Victory

    Jewish Boxer Dustin ‘White Tiger’ Fleischer Scores Fourth Knockout Victory

    Jewish boxer Dustin Fleischer, who said his quest is to become the first world champion descended from a Holocaust survivor, stayed unbeaten with a first-round knockout. Fleischer, nicknamed “The White Tiger,” moved to 4-0 with the defeat of Ira Frank on Saturday night in Beach Haven, New Jersey, near his home, he reported after the fight on his Facebook page. The 26-year-old welterweight has won all his bouts by knockout. Read full story at JTA.

    Read more →
  • Featured Israel Pioneers/Philanthropists Meet Israel’s Santa Claus, the Trustee Tasked With Handing Out Leona Helmsley’s Billions (INTERVIEW)

    Meet Israel’s Santa Claus, the Trustee Tasked With Handing Out Leona Helmsley’s Billions (INTERVIEW)

    Renowned New York attorney Sandor (Sandy) Frankel, one of four trustees of the Leona M. and Harry B. Helmsley Charitable Trust, was in Israel earlier this month to look at additional philanthropic options and to observe the progress of those endeavors already funded – to the tune of multi-millions. Frankel, who recently joined the prestigious Park Avenue law firm Otterbourg P.C., met with Israeli politicians and other bigwigs to get a sense from them about which projects in the country […]

    Read more →
  • Book Reviews Food Spirituality/Tradition ‘Pastry Secrets’ Arrive Just in Time for Rosh Hashanah

    ‘Pastry Secrets’ Arrive Just in Time for Rosh Hashanah – Babka. Strudel. Stollen. Danish pastry. Not to mention Gugelhopf and Charlotte. The names set the mouth to watering and conjure up lovingly concocted pastries that feed the body and comfort the soul. If you didn’t have a grandmother who baked these delicacies, you wish that you had. George Greenstein was never a grandmother, but his life as a baker provided his children and grandchildren with memories infused with the smell of fresh baked bread and rugelach. His daughters, Julia […]

    Read more →
  • Book Reviews Spirituality/Tradition Fusing Israeli and Holocaust History, Novel Offers a ‘Middle Eastern Western’

    Fusing Israeli and Holocaust History, Novel Offers a ‘Middle Eastern Western’ – There is a game that all of us have played at some time in our lives. We ask ourselves: What would my life be like if I had gone to this school instead of that one, or if I had married this girl instead of that one? In their newly published book The Ambassador, authors Yehuda Avner and Matt Rees play that game with modern Jewish history. Avner — who died earlier this year, and was a speechwriter, secretary and adviser to […]

    Read more →
  • Israel Lifestyle A Toulouse Fashion Student Finds Style and Harmony in the Holy Land

    A Toulouse Fashion Student Finds Style and Harmony in the Holy Land

    A unique group of young fashion bloggers and designers recently visited Israel to learn more about the country’s fashion industry and diverse culture. Hailing from the Philippines, Korea, Kenya, Japan, Brazil, Spain, France, Germany, Russia, and the U.K., the 10 participants toured the country and met with top Israeli fashion designers throughout last week. “It was an amazing experience,” said Meissene Maghni from Toulouse, France — one of the participants of the program. “I’m Muslim and I really wanted to see Israel […]

    Read more →