Tuesday, April 24th | 9 Iyyar 5778


Be in the know!

Get our exclusive daily news briefing.

September 3, 2013 9:06 am

Syria: Forgetting Lessons of the Holocaust

avatar by Shmuley Boteach

Email a copy of "Syria: Forgetting Lessons of the Holocaust" to a friend

A victim of the alleged chemical weapons attack in Syria. Photo: Screenshot.

As a past critic of President Obama’s passivity in the face of Syrian slaughter, I was immensely impressed with the President’s forcefulness in holding Bashar Assad accountable for the use of sarin gas. On the contrary, it was Republican opposition to President Obama’s plans to punish Syria for gassing children that was so sorely disappointing, to say the least.

Is there any greater justification for attacking a country’s military than when it engages in mass murder of children?

And yes, I know the objections. It might not be productive in stopping Assad’s regime. The strategic objectives need to be more clearly defined. Presidents can’t be cowboys and attack without Congressional approval and United Nations support. Afghanistan is still a mess, do we really need further Middle Eastern entanglements? And, of course, America is near broke.

But towering above all these considerations was the bodies of hundreds of dead kids. How do you signal to Syria and all those who would follow her example, especially Iran, that using nerve agents against innocent people will never be tolerated.

I was therefore shocked to hear the President reverse course and say that time was not pressing to punish Syria, that he would seek Congressional approval and wider support for his strike.

Let’s be clear. If the gassing of children is not an urgent matter than nothing is. Timing is everything. When the Jewish lobby in World War II asked President Roosevelt to bomb the tracks to Auschwitz, people were being gassed at a rate of 15,000 per day. Waiting a week would cost the lives of another 100,000 people.

In Syria the numbers are smaller though still horrific. Already 100,000 dead. But would we tolerate even another 400 kids being gassed? And if you are going to insist on Congressional approval – which neither Reagan, when he attacked Libya, nor Clinton when he attacked Afghanistan and Sudan, sought – then at least call Congress back from recess.

In the Jewish community we often speak of how during the Holocaust not many people gave a damn as six million Jews were rapidly exterminated. So how can we as a community afford not to speak out when Arab children are gassed? Where is the outrage?

I’m not for putting boots on the ground in Syria. I’m just as weary as other Americans at Iraq and Afghanistan – and especially the ingratitude shown by so many Muslim countries that we liberated – to see American men and women die to create Islamist countries that are not fully committed to liberal democracy. I also know that America right now can’t afford much. Our national debt is a crisis of its own.

But we sure as heck can afford a few dozen cruise missiles and we sure as heck can bring the war straight to Assad’s doorstep by destroying his Presidential palaces so he’s forced to live like the animal he is in subterranean shelters.

Furthermore, The Wall Street Journal suggested in an editorial on Friday that we can use our missiles not just for President Obama’s declared ‘shot across the bow,’ which suggests that we won’t hit any substantive targets, but instead strike the six airfields being most used by Syria’s Air Force and effectively ground their war planes from doing further harm.

One thing we cannot do is play politics where people’s lives are concerned. This is not a time to be doing the all-American blood sport of Republican versus Democrat. I don’t give a damn why President Obama wants to strike Syria, whether it’s to salvage his credibility on his self-declared ‘red lines,’ to show Iran that he’s serious, or to protect his legacy as someone who did not sit back while children were murdered. His intention is immaterial. All that matters is the Biblical imperative: ‘Thou shalt not stand idly by the blood of your neighbor.’

We must stop the butcher in Damascus from killing more innocent Arabs. On this President Obama is absolutely right and I’m mystified why any Republican would oppose him.

One of the principal reasons I ran for Congress as a Republican was disappointment in my liberal friends (and coming from the worlds of academic and media most of my friends are staunchly anti-Republican) in not being fully committed to fighting evil.

Palestinians, they told me, should of course not be blowing up Israeli buses. But you need to see it from their perspective. They’re humiliated with check points and road blocks. To which I always respond, there is no justification whatsoever for targeting children, excuses be damned.

Is it any different when the children who are being targeted are Kurdish, or Syrian, or Arab? They are equally God’s children. And Republicans have been great at making that point strongly, especially in the case of Saddam Hussein. Yes, we’re all Iraq-weary. But I supported the overthrow of Saddam and thought it a great moment in American history because he had murdered tens of thousands of children with mustard gas at Halabjah in April, 1988. So where are the Republican voices of outrage now, when Assad is doing the same thing?

In America we play politics with roads, and subsidies, and unemployment – all important issues. But when it comes to ‘Never Again,’ we have to speak with one voice. ‘Never again’ means just that.

Never, ever, ever again. That the world will never again tolerate the mass slaughter of civilians by monsters like Assad. That civilization will never sit passively while brute thugs assail and slaughter the innocent en mass. If you use poison gas you are going to be hit by a Mack truck.

For goodness sake, let’s all get on the same page about this. President Obama has, of late, been exemplary in taking the lead on punishing Syria for atrocities. John Kerry even more so. Please, don’t falter now. Get your backbone back. “Do not murder” means just that. The Ten Commandments are not Democratic or Republican or American or Islamic. They are universal, accepted by all nations at all times.

It’s the 21st century, people. It’s time we finally get serious about stopping mass murder or our passivity will make us complicit.

Shmuley Boteach, “America’s Rabbi,” is founder of This World: The Jewish Values Network, which promotes universal Jewish values in the culture. He has just published The Fed-Up Man of Faith: Challenging God in the Face of Tragedy and Suffering.” Follow him on Twitter @RabbiShmuley.

Share this Story: Share On Facebook Share On Twitter Email This Article

Let your voice be heard!

Join the Algemeiner
  • Fortune



  • Tabitha

    1. The Muslims kill each other whether or not we involve ourselves; women and children are second-class citizens and quite dispensable.
    2. The Rebels are Muslim Brotherhood, and we are their air force against Assad, helping them take over Syria. Muslims are killing all over the world; we’re helping the MB. What about the Coptic children being burned in the Christian churches? our administration’s been quiet. Therefore, the purpose is to support the MB, not humanitarian at all.
    3. This could endanger Israel and Obama has said nothing about putting Israel in harm’s way and then offering support if necessary.
    4. then let’s realize we should have bombed Iran’s nuclear facilities long ago, and there’s still time…where it’ll do the most good.

  • Yoel Nitzarim

    I stand right alongside Rabbi Boteach on this issue. It is hard to understand why perhaps 75% of the American public wants to stand aside on this issue. The extremely desperate financial situation in America aside, this calamity in Syria which took place less than a month ago must not be forgotten, Syrian leadership must not be left untarnished, innocent people must not be left to die at the merciless hands of dictators. Indifference is the greatest of all crimes when a crime against humanity has been committed and will probably be committed again by the same people or people aligned with those in Syria and by Iran. Whether the crime be by gas or by nuclear fission, weapons of mass destruction must never be used–never, never, never! As one who is making aliyah in the next 3 1/2 months, I stand steadfastly with those who would not disavow their part in humanity and strenuously take action who would!

  • And when Al Nusra and others in the rebellion WHO HAVE ADMITTED AND FOUND TO BE USING THE SAME WEAPONS win, and then have control of these weapons, but whose untrammeled consciences make of Assad a Mafia boss compared to pure and sure zealots?
    The USA can do NOTHING worse than to functionally HELP AL QAEDA and its think-alikes.
    And PS.. nothing could be worse for Israel.
    We should ALL be pulling for a permanent draw while the USA acts with efficiency (good luck) in helping the FSA and ensuring they are not just another Ikwhan appendage.
    What is it people think will happen to the people of Syria if the crazy Salafis beat the crazy mafioso Assads? Or the reverse?

  • ralph levitt

    There is a chance of genocidal murder in Syria—-but not
    by the Assad regime. The perpetrators would be Al-Queda
    and its associates and the victims would be the Christians, Alawites, Druze, Kurds, Yazidis and any other
    This is not speculation since we have as an example the
    conduct of the Muslim Brotherhood—Obama’s ally—in
    Egypt—–the devastating attacks on the Coptic Christians and their churches.
    Assad has no such record. Of course, he is a mamzer but if
    every country led by a mamzer were to be attacked, we’d have to bomb the USA.

  • Jan Mel Poller

    A weak response, one that gives Assad to hide his weapons, one designed to do nothing but send a message is worse than nothing.

    The message he wants to send is nothing but a weak message. It comes after multiple gas attacks with no note or response from President Obama.

    The intended message will encourage Assad to do more.

    What should be done is an attack on Iranian nuclear facilities and weapons manufacturing facilities. After all, Iran is the hand behind the throne of Syria and Hezbollah. It is bring Iraq under its evil wing.

    What we have is a losing hand at what looks like game-playing.

  • ralph levitt

    Be a mensch————speak up for the Christians that Al-
    Queda has been murdering and whose churches are being destroyed. The Assads, pere et fils, have been protecting
    the rights of Christians and other minorities for decades.
    Mamzer that he is, Assad is certainly no worse than Al-
    The current situation is outstanding. Hizbollah kills Al-
    Queda and Al-Queda kills Hizbollah. What don’t you like about that?
    The holocaust analogies in this situation are without any
    Your contribution proves one thing: there is no yold quite so yoldish as a Jewish yold.

    • Elliot J. Stamler

      What is a yold?

      • ralph levitt


  • Dan

    Shmuley Boteach may be “America’s Rabbi” but I’m glad to say he’s not mine.

    • Michael Garfinkel

      Ever hear of Rent-A-Rabbi?

      In 1995, Michael Jackson introduced the song “They Don’t Care About Us,” the lyrics of which contained the folowing phrase: “Jew me, sue me, everybody do me/ Kick me, kike me, don’t you black or white me.”

      Foxman and the ADL went ballistic, and the Jackson organization suddenly had a real public relations fiasco on their hands.

      Enter Shmuley Boteach from “Rent-A-Rabbi,” who became (in)famous serving as flack and apologist for the notorious child molester.

      America’s rabbi? God help us.


  • Sunshine

    How do you know it is Assad? Where you there when it happened? People like you make for a dangerous world.

    The only copy of the sole video of the attack (all others were suddenly erased) clearly shows it is the rebel army.


    The patients in the hospital told U.N. it was the rebels.

    Now, hacked emails are surfacing with the very probable theory that the U.S. had pre-planned the attack with Turkey.

    Strangely, the muslim brotherhood recently showed up in Syria and its new leader is a Canadian muslim who just flew there…

    What’s wrong with this story?

    P.S. There are people who detest Jews and others who regard them very highly, of which I am the latter. I wonder why…

  • Otto Schiff

    I like the idea of using missiles in Syria and not boots on the ground. We have enough military cemeteries in this country already. But Assad must be destroyed.