British Library Publishes 1917 Letter Calling for Creation of Jewish State in Saudi Arabia (PHOTOS)

April 4, 2014 12:20 pm 3 comments

The letter from Britain's Ambassador to France, Lord Francis Bertie, turning down a proposal from Dr. M L Rothstein for a Jewish state in today's Saudi Arabia. Photo: Screenshot / British Library.

The letter from Britain's Ambassador to France, Lord Francis Bertie, turning down a proposal from Dr. M L Rothstein for a Jewish state in today's Saudi Arabia. Photo: Screenshot / British Library.

Weeks before the November 3, 1917, Balfour Declaration, in which Britain promised to help create a Jewish homeland in “Palestine,” how the land of today’s Israel and Jordan was known, an obscure, Paris-based, Russian Jew formally requested British support to equip an army for the “creation of a Jewish State on the Persian Gulf,” according to recently uncovered documents now on display at the British Library.

While the exhibit highlights much of the excitement Jews had about creating a Jewish state after World War I, a historian familiar with the period said the letter exchange was typical of the British response to many eager, and creative, Zionists of that time.

On Thursday, the British Library said on its website that, in the letter, in French, dated September 12, 1917, Britain’s Ambassador to France, Lord Francis Bertie, received this “unusual proposal” from the unknown Dr. M. L. Rothstein.

The saga was revealed in diplomatic correspondence between Bertie and British Foreign Secretary Arthur James Balfour, who weeks later published his eponymous declaration, in a letter to Lord Rothschild, expressing Britain’s support for the Zionist movement’s aim of “the establishment in Palestine of a national home for the Jewish people.”

Rothstein asked for British arms and support “for the conquest of the Turkish province of El Hassa,” an oasis on the east coast of present Saudi Arabia, that had been promised but not yet delivered to the Ibn Saud family.

Rothstein said: “I undertake to assemble, for next spring, a Jewish fighting troop, a force of 120,000 strong men” that could be doubled with soldiers provided by Britain and its allies. He admitted that the plan “may appear unrealistic,” but this would cease “as soon as the first thousand men have arrived on the scene.”

The British Library wrote that the plan called for the troops to gather at Bahrain and, as soon they reached 30,000, a “coup de main,” a swift attack, would ensue, taking the “Turkish province of Al Hassa, near the Persian Gulf” which “will become a Jewish State, ‘un État juif.’” Rothstein thought Turkey would respond with a “state of war,” and the Jewish troops would respond against Turkey with their own campaign.

“Besides his self-description as a ‘Russian medical doctor’ and a 1938 description by Juda Tchernoff, little is known about Rothstein,” the British Library said. “He prefaces his proposal with his family’s ‘moral qualities’ and refers to Maurice Barrès, who cites Rothstein’s son, Amédée, a young Russian Zionist, in his book ‘Les Diverses Familles Spirituelles de la France.’  Although Barrès was a famous anti-Dreyfusard and popularized French nationalism, he considered Amédée as exemplifying Jewish loyalty to France due to his patriotic death at the Battle of Verdun in 1916.”

The actual 'Balfour Declaration' declaring British support for "a Jewish homeland" in Palestine, the letter from British Foreign Secretary Arthur James Balfour to Lord Rothschild. Photo: Screenshot / British Library.

The actual 'Balfour Declaration' declaring British support for "a Jewish homeland" in Palestine, the letter from British Foreign Secretary Arthur James Balfour to Lord Rothschild. Photo: Screenshot / British Library.

Britain rejected the plan, after dismissing it as “wholly inappropriate.” Balfour’s private secretary wrote to Bertie on October 3, 1917 requesting that he reply to Rothstein, informing him that the British government could not give effect to his proposal. One month to the day later, the Balfour Declaration was announced.

The British Library said the Rothstein plan could be viewed in the light of other alternatives to Palestine mooted at the time for a “Jewish home” in Uganda, Argentina, Russia, Cyprus.

“Although Rothstein’s proposal appears obscure and has been almost entirely forgotten by history, it reflected an historical momentum for the establishment of a Jewish national home, ideologically grounded in European nationalism and seeking legitimacy from European imperial powers,” it said.

But the British Library said it also had a letter from the British India Office’s Thomas William Holderness, about the region, that showed Rothstein seemed to be out of touch with the reality on the ground.

“Hassa had ceased to be a Turkish province in 1913 with the conquest of Ibn Saud, a British ally, and Bahrain’s Al Khalifah rulers had been in treaty relations with Britain since 1820,” it wrote.

In the government’s reply, Rothstein, the unknown proposed Zionist warrior, was told, “His Majesty’s Government could not countenance… any proposal affecting their territorial rights or the status quo.”

Historian and author Edwin Black, in his book ‘The Farhud,’ wrote about the excited times leading up to the Balfour Declaration, and told The Algemeiner on Friday that in researching his book, he’d seen hundreds of similar letters, though none he could recall specifically referencing Saudi Arabia.

“At the time, Jews would send in letter, after letter to Britain, arguing the Crown should establish a Jewish state in one far off territory or another,” Black said. “In response, they’d always receive a very formal, but firm letter an official letterhead for their trouble.”

“I don’t believe that any other land, beyond Mandate Palestine, today’s Israel and Jordan, was ever seriously considered by Britain to become the Jewish state,” the historian said.


3 Comments

  • Julian Clovelly

    I am afraid, Ms Bacon, that the British did not really have big plans for anything, in the aftermath of the disastrous Great War. Elements in Government and the Foreign Office may well have had fantasies but “the British”, for the most part, were trying to survive the devastation that the Great War had brought. In the case of my own family that was the death of my own grandfather from Spanish Flu, a few days after the Armistice, as he awaited transport home to England. He is buried in Greece near the Turkish border.

    Britain did not become anything approaching a democracy until the full enfranchisement of women after the Great War. Disparity in prosperity and financial collapse was to lead to the General Strike of 1926 which nearly brought the entire British State down

    In a nation with such chronic class divisions, it is stretching a point to blame the “nationality” for anything. The majority of that nationality have no control even via the ballot box. All British Governments have broken promises, lied, and disappointed.

    As far as the world stage is concerned British Foreign policy has predominantly been one of disengagement – but the situation of particular territories made that difficult in the inter war period – in particular with the defeat and collapse of the Ottoman Empire. Britain might appear to have been in control but mostly that seems to me to have been by recognising and acceding to existing situations, and using such terminology as “granting independence” where in reality no such thing exists – you can’t “grant independence”, you can only leave people alone, in military terms “withdraw”

    Revisit the twentieth century in terms of “national blame” is often unhelpful, and really only confuses modern issues. Political History, especially, needs to be viewed in a more objective fashion if we are to learn from the past. What matters is the situation we find ourselves in now

    I can imagine the world I would have lived in had my grandfather survived and the family not been reduced to poverty. I can imagine the world we might have lived in had my family not been forced to flee Belgium in the sixteenth century as Huguenots. But I cannot live in that world, apportioning blame in every direction with the advantage of hindsight. We are where we are. What matters is not how we imagine past worlds to be, but how we improve the one in which we live now. Neither the situation of the Israelis, nor the situation of the Palestinians can continue as it is. A state of undeclared war almost always breaks out eventually as a real one. What is most required is de-escalation of the present process, with all sides removing deliberate annoyances that it is within their power to remove, and aiding the poor of the region on a humanitarian basis

    Compassion might well achieve what anger only worsens.

  • This is not as crazy as it seems. Before the advent of Islam, and even afterwards, there was a large Jewish population in the Hejaz (now Saudi-Arabia), the Khaybars, who fought Muhamad, though some converted to Islam. The British, however, had big plans for Saudi-Arabia after the defeat of the Ottoman Empire and handed it over to a branch of the Hashemite family as a gift.

    • Mr bacon
      Why you stop 1500 years back with Islam?if you travel a little more you will learn it is
      Not anyone els but you who convert into pigs and monkies and you brother Darwin Was blind that he never found any similarity with pig,you are also blind can you look ,I am giving you a chalange,you can learn in five minuts and it is very common knowladge,you can
      Ask any fireman,colour,flesh,hair,habits,food,taste of meat,Evan smell after burning and that is the reason firemen must knows because they got spray of burning essence of pork,why not you claim that homosexual pig,monkey,instead your Darwin lied about monkies,it was simply other way around and that is in religious books from thousands of years,you have been cursed and your own book is forbidding you from any state unless a Messiah come,And
      Thats why your own Jewish scholars are againest Tha state of Israel,go online look at these facts yourself,put racism in a locker,just think you r not a Jew,then start digging facts and ask
      Yourself you are responsible for all the mischief in this world,because you always got power and people are suffering from thousands of years,look at the bombs you made and food parcels for needy,your bombs are billion time heavy and and spending on destruction is trillion time more then relief,and I tell you a fact everyone knows but you are in power you got the media and you are showing opposite picture,do not under estimate others,people watched your killings of un armed civilians and everyone agreed it is genocide but you think you can bring news in media and change people opinion but how long before another Hitler and no one exapt Muslims will give you refuge,no matter what you do to us we still consider
      Your children as innocent as our own and if some power is killing you we will give refuge,that is the first and last policy of Islam and under this policy you were allowed back in Palestinian
      In caliph ummer,s time after 500 years of exile by Christians,you spent your golden time under Muslim Spain and after Muslim lost you lost too and you seeked refuge in Muslim
      Lands in 1600,what next is coming ,do you know?

Leave a Reply

Please note: comments may be published in the Algemeiner print edition.


Current day month ye@r *

More...

  • Jewish Identity Sports Cycling the Desert: New Israel Bike Trail Connects Mitzpe Ramon to Eilat

    Cycling the Desert: New Israel Bike Trail Connects Mitzpe Ramon to Eilat

    As the popularity of cycling continues to increase across the world, Israel is working to develop cycling trails that make the country’s spectacular desert accessible to cyclists. The southern segment of the Israel Bike Trail was inaugurated on Feb. 24 and offers for the first time a unique, uninterrupted 8-day cycling experience after six years of planning and development. The southern section of the Israel Bike Trail stretches over 300 kilometers in length and is divided into eight segments for mountain biking, [...]

    Read more →
  • Jewish Identity Theater Forthcoming Major Action Movies Inspired by Jewish Comic Artist Jack Kirby

    Forthcoming Major Action Movies Inspired by Jewish Comic Artist Jack Kirby

    JNS.org – With the recent Oscars in the rearview mirror, Hollywood’s attention now shifts to the rest of this year’s big-screen lineup. Two of the major action films coming up in 2015—Avengers: Age of Ultron, which hits theaters in May, and the third film in the Fantastic Four series, slated for an August release—have Jewish roots that the average moviegoer might be unaware of. As it turns out, it took a tough Jewish kid from New York City’s Lower East [...]

    Read more →
  • Book Reviews Jewish Identity When Torah Teaches Life and Life Teaches Torah (REVIEW)

    When Torah Teaches Life and Life Teaches Torah (REVIEW)

    JNS.org – Rabbi Gordon Tucker spent the first 20 years of his career teaching at the Conservative movement’s Jewish Theological Seminary (JTS) and the next 20 years as the rabbi of Temple Israel Center in White Plains, N.Y. I confess that when I heard about the order of those events, I thought that Tucker’s move from academia to the pulpit was strange. Firstly, I could not imagine anyone filling the place of my friend, Arnold Turetsky, who was such a talented [...]

    Read more →
  • Arts and Culture Blogs Oscars 2015: Reflecting on Love at First Sight

    Oscars 2015: Reflecting on Love at First Sight

    JNS.org – I’m in love, and have been for a long time. It’s a relationship filled with laughter, tears, intrigue, and surprise. It was love at first sight, back when I was a little girl—with an extra-terrestrial that longed to go home. From then on, that love has never wavered, and isn’t reserved for one, but for oh so many—Ferris Bueller, Annie Hall, Tootsie, Harry and Sally, Marty McFly, Atticus Finch, Danny Zuko, Yentl, that little dog Toto, Mrs. Doubtfire, [...]

    Read more →
  • Blogs Book Reviews Examining America’s First Foray into the Middle East (REVIEW)

    Examining America’s First Foray into the Middle East (REVIEW)

    At the turn of the 21st century through today, American involvement in Middle Eastern politics runs through the Central Intelligence Agency. In America’s Great Game: The CIA’s Secret Arabists and the Shaping of the Modern Middle East, historian Hugh Wilford shows this has always been the case. Wilford methodically traces the lives and work of the agency’s three most prominent officers in the Middle East: Kermit “Kim” Roosevelt was the grandson of president Theodore Roosevelt, and the first head of [...]

    Read more →
  • Relationships US & Canada Seniors at Los Angeles Jewish Home Give Witty Dating Advice Ahead of Valentine’s Day (VIDEO)

    Seniors at Los Angeles Jewish Home Give Witty Dating Advice Ahead of Valentine’s Day (VIDEO)

    Residents of the Los Angeles Jewish Home give dating advice to a young Jewish man in a comedic video posted Monday on YouTube just in time for Valentine’s Day. Jonathan, an associate at the Jewish home, quizzes the senior citizens on an array of topics including having sex on the first date, kissing a girl, who should pay for dinner and whether online dating is a good idea. When the 28-year-old asks a male resident named Lee about his experiences [...]

    Read more →
  • Arts and Culture Jewish History Kutsher’s Documentary an Amazing, and Tragic, Look at the Past (REVIEW)

    Kutsher’s Documentary an Amazing, and Tragic, Look at the Past (REVIEW)

    Anyone who spent time in the Jewish Catskills hotels – especially those like me, who returned for decades – must see the new documentary,”Welcome to Kutsher’s: The Last Catskills Resort.” Not only will the film transport you back to the glory days of your youth and thousands of memories, but it will also make you long for a world that is now lost forever. I returned to Kutsher’s one last time in the summer of 2009, but by then, the [...]

    Read more →
  • Education Jewish Identity Lifestyle Riding the Wave of Change in Part-Time Jewish Education

    Riding the Wave of Change in Part-Time Jewish Education

    JNS.org – Amid the numerous studies and analyses regarding Jewish American life, a simple fact remains: part-time Jewish education is the most popular vehicle for Jewish education in North America. Whenever and wherever parents choose Jewish education for their children, we have a communal responsibility to devote the necessary time and resources to deliver dynamic, effective learning experiences. The only way we can do this is by creating space for conversations and knowledge-sharing around innovative new education models. That also [...]

    Read more →



Sign up now to receive our regular news briefs.