Thursday, February 2nd | 11 Shevat 5783

November 22, 2013 1:58 pm

Thanksgivukkah: Abe Lincoln the Maccabee

× [contact-form-7 404 "Not Found"]

avatar by Shmuel Silber

The painting "Maccabees," by Wojciech Stattler (1800-1875). Photo: Wojciech Stattler via Wikimedia Commons.

I have fond childhood memories of Thanksgiving. I can’t quite remember what was on the menu, but I do remember the feelings of familial warmth and cohesion. In the midst of the manic pace of life, the last Thursday in November offered us the opportunity to catch up and enjoy each other’s company.

I remember that Rabbi Yosef Dov Soloveitchik, who was known for his lengthy classes, would begin teaching earlier on Thanksgiving to allow his students the opportunity to spend quality time with their families. In many ways, Thanksgiving has become an important anchor in familial connection for Jews and non-Jews alike.

And this year, American Jewry is abuzz with excitement surrounding a calendrical anomaly that has not occurred since 1861, and will not occur again in our lifetimes – the marriage of Chanukah and Thanksgiving.  This “family time” extravaganza is already known by many as “Thanksgivukkah.”

I, for one, am very excited about Thanksgivukkah.

Related coverage

September 16, 2016 2:04 am

Were God Merely to ‘Exist,’ Our Prayers Would Be Meaningless

“God is a circle whose center is everywhere and circumference nowhere,” said Voltaire. Indeed, trying to describe God is like trying to...

But other than bonding with our next of kin over copious amounts of food, is there any real connection between these holidays?  Indeed, the connection is more profound than you might imagine.

On Chanukah, we commemorate and celebrate two miracles: our military victory over the Greeks and the cruse of oil lasting eight days. As great as the Divinely orchestrated military victory was, it seems to have been eclipsed by the miracle of the oil. Although we mention the military victory in our prayers, it is the kindling of the Menorah that defines our observance of this holiday.

No one will dispute the awesomeness of the supernatural display of one day’s supply of oil burning for eight, but it was the military victory that secured our future. Still, the oil takes center stage. What about this miracle allows it to do so?

The Talmud (Shabbos 21b) explains that after defeating the Syrian Greek army, the Maccabees returned to the Temple to find it in total disarray.  The Altar had been used for idolatrous service, the golden utensils (including the Menorah) were gone – everything was in shambles. The Maccabees knew they had to do something to ignite the flame within the hearts of their Jewish brothers and sisters, so they began to look for oil. Much to their disappointment, they found only one small jug with the seal of the High Priest (indicating its ritual purity).

They had to make a momentous decision:  To light the Menorah or not to light the Menorah?

On the one hand, it didn’t make much sense to start a process that they would be unable to complete.  There was clearly not enough oil to keep the Menorah burning. And even if they kindled the Menorah, it would be a week until they could secure additional ritually-pure oil. Perhaps it would have been better to wait, and inaugurate the Menorah service properly a week later.

On the other hand, the Maccabees realized that there was an opportunity in front of them, and they dug deep for the courage to resolve it, no matter how imperfect the opportunity really was.

At that moment, there was an opportunity to infuse light, and they grabbed it. They kindled the Menorah, and God helped them make history.

As such, the Menorah has become Chanukah’s dominant theme because it reminds us to take advantage of opportunities, no matter how imperfect or fraught with uncertainty.

Don’t wait for the perfect moment; make the current moment perfect.

Abraham Lincoln was thinking like a Maccabee when he re-established Thanksgiving.

Thanksgiving observances and celebrations date back to the 1500s. But in 1863, just two years after Chanukah coincided with Thanksgiving (the last such occurrence), President Lincoln declared Thanksgiving a legal holiday.

The Civil War was raging, and Lincoln penned a special Thanksgiving proclamation:

“In the midst of a civil war of unequaled magnitude and severity … harmony has prevailed everywhere except in the theatre of military conflict … I do therefore invite my fellow citizens in every part of the United States … to set apart and observe the last Thursday of November next, as a day of Thanksgiving and Praise to our beneficent Father who dwelleth in the Heavens.”

In the midst of a brutal war that pitted brother against brother, a war that created countless widows, orphans, and shattered dreams, Lincoln reminded us that we must take the opportunity to thank God for all that is good, even in the midst of challenge and tragedy.

Life is filled with beautiful moments and opportunities to express gratitude and appreciation. However, virtually all of these moments are imperfect.

Like President Lincoln, let us find our inner Maccabee and seize the moments when they present themselves. Let us honor the tradition of this great country and remember to thank God even during challenging times.

Rabbi Shmuel Silber is the Founder and Dean of the Institute for Jewish Continuity (, an online resource that provides inspiring and intellectually invigorating Torah courses for students of every age and at all levels.  He also serves as Rabbi of Suburban Orthodox, Congregation Toras Chaim in Baltimore, MD.

Share this Story: Share On Facebook Share On Twitter

Let your voice be heard!

Join the Algemeiner

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.