Friday, May 25th | 11 Sivan 5778


Be in the know!

Get our exclusive daily news briefing.

December 30, 2013 2:02 am

The Guardian Whitewashes Anti-Semitism of French Soccer Player, Comedian

avatar by Adam Levick

Email a copy of "The Guardian Whitewashes Anti-Semitism of French Soccer Player, Comedian" to a friend

Nicolas Anelka. Photo: Screenshot.

A major controversy erupted on Saturday at Upton Park in London after French Muslim footballer Nicolas Anelka used a gesture widely considered to be antisemitic and often described as “the Nazi salute in reverse.” After his first goal in the 3-3 draw at West Ham, “he celebrated with his right arm extended towards the ground, palm opened and the other one bent across his chest touching his right upper arm.”

Anelka is now under investigation by the Football Association for the gesture – which was almost certainly inspired by the gesture promoted by antisemitic French comedian Dieudonné M’bala M’bala – and was swiftly condemned by the French Sports Minister as a “shocking, disgusting” display of antisemitism.

Dieudonne M’bala M’bala is a notorious racist “comedian” who, per Hope Not Hate, “has moved towards the antisemitic fringe of French politics.” The site notes that Dieudonne has become “increasingly marginal culturally and increasingly shrill in his antisemitism, denying the Holocaust, blaming Jews for the slave trade and more generally for the oppression of the Black and Arab peoples.” Dieudonne also traveled to Iran to meet with President Mohammed Ahmadinejad, and subsequently hailed Iran as “a place where anti-Zionists can meet and communicate and develop.”

Additionally, Dieudonne had befriended the late far-right extremist Jean-Marie Le Pen, and also once invited Holocaust denier Robert Faurisson onstage at a performance, and asked the audience to applaud.

In reviewing UK newspaper coverage of the row, the Guardian naturally stands out in downplaying the episode and, more specifically, whitewashing Dieudonne’s antisemitism.

Guardian/Observer, Dec. 28: West Bromwich Albion’s Nicolas Anelka could face ban after arm gesture:

Relevant passage:

Dieudonné is a controversial figure in France, having been accused of insulting the memory of Holocaust victims. The quenelle is Dieudonné’s signature gesture, although he insists it is an anti-establishment gesture and not against Jewish people

Interestingly, other British papers were much clearer on Dieudonne’s antisemitic history, with some characterizing him as an “antisemitic comedian” or “antisemitic activist” without qualification:

The Independent, Dec.28: Nicolas Anelka gesture: Striker’s two goals overshadowed by controversial celebration after alleged anti-Semitic gesture

Here’s the relevant passage:

His celebration was a mirror image of the gesture made popular by French, anti-Semitic comedian Dieudonne M’bala M’bala…

The Telegraph, Dec. 29: Nicolas Anelka’s ‘quenelle’ gesture in support of ‘racist’ friend Dieudonné causes outrage in France

Relevant passage:

In the last few years, Dieudonné M’bala M’bala, his full name, has become an anti-Semitic activist and campaigner…

Mail Online, Dec. 28: Anelka’s ‘Nazi’ salute storm: Striker could face lengthy FA ban for offensive goal celebration along with sanctions in France

Relevant passage:

Dieudonne has been convicted six times in France for alleged anti-Semitic remarks. He was fined £6,000 in 2008 for describing Holocaust remembrance as ‘memorial pornography’.

Sunday Times, Dec. 29: FA acts over Anelka’s ‘race-hate’ gesture (pay wall)

Relevant passages:

Dieudonne has been prosecuted for making antisemitic comments

Dieudonne has been convicted six times in France for alleged anti-Semitic remarks. He was fined £6,000 in 2008 for describing Holocaust remembrance as memorial pornography.

The Guardian stands alone in whitewashing the “comedian’s” clear record of anti-Jewish rhetoric – another antisemitic sin of omission at the “liberal” broadsheet which has, by now, achieved a well-earned reputation for such curious moral blind spots on the topic of racism.

Adam Levick is the managing editor of CiF Watch, an affiliate of the Committee for Accuracy in Middle East Reporting in America (CAMERA).

Share this Story: Share On Facebook Share On Twitter Email This Article

Let your voice be heard!

Join the Algemeiner
  • Gilles

    This is the story of a french black comedian, who started his career with fellow comedian Elie Semoun (a jewish comedian, by the way), whose talent as a writer and an actor is huge, could have enjoyed a seamless and successful career on stage and in cinema, but fell out of favor because he chose to do things his way. He tried to revive his ongoing career using disturbing political stunts, and publicly acknowledging animosity towards jew public figures (singer and actor Patrick Bruel, philosopher Bernard Henri-Levy, minister Pierre Moscovici and recently columnist Patrick Cohen). As an artist, Dieudonné keeps saying things he believes, sometimes it is unclear if it’s just an act or true beliefs, but he keeps fighting for free speech. Not everything he says is right, not everything he says is politically correct, but instead of ignoring him, people blow his every move out of proportion to make it news, even going into his theater with an hidden camera to record without permission his act, and put it on TV. Now members of the government and the press are joining forces to shut him down. Remember, this is just one man, one comedian who can’t get on TV, and would never be heard of if not for the press. So we see three black athletes supporting this comedian, Teddy Riner, Tony Parker and Nicolas Anelka, they are not anti-Semitic, they are just supporting a black comedian, using a sign that, as created by Dieudonné, is not anti-Semitic in itself. Quenelle has been used by Mouloud Achour, another french comedian, in response to racist remarks by a public figure. So please, Guardian, get to the bottom of this story, and help people see the truth.

  • E Pluribus Wombat

    Of course they did. The Guardian is openly antisemitic. It’s their editorial policy. No one seriously questions that.

    • William Moskowitz

      Gilles, Wake up, take a look around you and smell the coffee. In case you hadn’t heard, the rise in the number of anti-semitic incidents in France has risen by 30% last year alone. And that’s just reported incidents. Europe in total? We all know that the resurgence just 70 years after a World War fought to quell its acidic bile boggles the mind and befuddles the senses.
      I know that there were many many people in the late 1920’s that said “he’s just a fringe politician, don’t give him another thought”. So, yes, we are sensitive whenever and wherever anti-semitism rears its head. We have seen its results countless times over the course of history, we know what it looks like and what its results are. So please, save your sanctimonious humanity for something more worthy and dont be afraid to look evil on the eye and call it what it is.