Tuesday, March 20th | 4 Nisan 5778


Be in the know!

Get our exclusive daily news briefing.

December 8, 2014 5:37 pm

As Israeli Government Collapses, Arab Candidate Announces Run for ‘Jewish Home’ Party

avatar by Alina Dain Sharon / JNS.org

Email a copy of "As Israeli Government Collapses, Arab Candidate Announces Run for ‘Jewish Home’ Party" to a friend

Israel's Knesset. Photo: Tazpit News Agency.

JNS.orgThis week a meeting between Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and now-ousted Finance Minister Yair Lapid (leader of the Yesh Atid party), which was intended as a bid to salvage Israel’s coalition government, has ended in a stalemate. A new election is now expected in the country, as JNS.org previously reported.

Netanyahu then fired Lapid, as well as Hatnuah leader and Justice Minister Tzipi Livni. Part of the disagreement between Netanyahu and Lapid centered on legislation approved by the Israeli cabinet at the end of November cementing Israel’s status as a Jewish state. The bill confirms that Israel is the national home of the Jewish people and a place where Jews have the historical right to realize their aspiration for self-determination.

This right to national self-determination in Israel is unique to Jews, the legislation states, though the civil rights of all minorities in Israel are also protected. Just before the cabinet vote, the language of the bill was amended to describe Israel as both a democratic and Jewish state, and an addition was made that Arabic would remain an official language of the state of Israel.

“Israel is a Jewish and democratic state. There are those who wish to see the democratic aspect overshadow the Jewish aspect, and there are those who wish to see the Jewish aspect overshadow the democratic aspect. The principles of the bill that I present here today ensure that these two values are equal and are given equal consideration,” Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said before the bill’s passage in the cabinet.

However, Lapid and Livni both opposed the law. “The bill submitted today puts the Jewish state before democracy,” Lapid said is a speech at Tel Aviv University in November according to Haaretz. “Neither I, nor the Yesh Atid party, will vote for the law.”

Israeli Arab MK Ahmad Tibi also criticized the bill on CNN this week, stating that “the nationality bill is totally proof of what I said during the last decades: that in Israel, Israel is democratic towards Jews and Jewish towards Arabs.”

In the midst of this political turmoil, comes an interesting political surprise in the form of Muslim Arab resident of northern Israel Anat Haskia, who has announced her candidacy for the primaries of the Habayit Hayehudi (Jewish Home) Party. The party is chaired by Naftali Bennett and has supported the Jewish State bill along with Netanyahu’s Likud party.

Haskia, all of whose children served in the Israel Defense Forces (IDF), posted on her Facebook page Thursday, “I have decided to join the Jewish Home party. In order to get on the list of candidates I need you to join. Together we will fight against the incitement emanating from the Arab community, and encourage more young Arabs to identify with the state of Israel.”

Haskia’s position represents the complicated reality of Israeli politics, which involves many disagreements among people and politicians of all political spectrums, and different faiths. She also stands out in a community of Muslim Arab citizens of Israel and Palestinians who tend to be critical of the Israeli government, and in some cases violently hostile toward Israel, as showcased by a string of recent terrorist attacks against Israeli civilians, most recently a stabbing attack by Palestinians at an Israeli supermarket east of Jerusalem in Judea and Samaria Wednesday.

Those Israeli Arabs who tend to hold more favorable views toward the Israeli government are most often Christian or Druze. The Druze in Israel have a tradition of serving in the IDF, and Arab-Christian leaders, such as Greek-Orthodox Father Gabriel Nadaf, have been campaigning for Christians to volunteer to serve in the Israeli army.

Recently the Israeli government recognized the official ethnicity of Christians in Israel as “Aramean” instead of Arab, a decision praised by leaders such as Nadaf as a way of separating themselves from the anti-Israel mentality of many Muslim Arabs, and as a way of developing a more positive relationship with Israel.

“Jews who seek change in Arab attitudes should help me, by empowering me to fight in the Knesset against other Arab MKs” who are critical of the Israeli government, Haskia also wrote on Facebook.

“Now is the time to support me…And if you are already Jewish Home members and plan to support my candidacy I would love to hear from you,” Haskia said, as translated from Hebrew by the Israel National News.

Share this Story: Share On Facebook Share On Twitter Email This Article

Let your voice be heard!

Join the Algemeiner
  • Dr.M.Otero

    Doesn’t Haskia’s offer challenge Bibi’s and Bennet’s position?

  • Julian Clovelley

    Maybe Israeli politicians and others need to look at the legislative mess that was Apartheid in South Africa. It too had to define the ethnicity of its population. The first Act concerned was the Population Registration Act 1950 and amongst the provisons were the following:

    Section5. (1) Every person whose name is included in the register shall be classified by the Director as a white person, a coloured person or a native, as the case may be, and every coloured person and every native whose name is so included shall be classified by the Director according to the ethnic or other group to which he belongs.

    (2) The Governor-General may by proclamation in the Gazette prescribe and define the ethnic or other groups into which coloured persons and natives shall be classified in terms of sub-section (1), and may in like manner amend or withdraw any such proclamation.

    (3) If at any time it appears to the Director that the classification of a person in terms of sub-section (1) is incorrect, he may, subject to the provisions of sub-section (7) of section eleven and after giving notice to that person and, if he is a minor, also to his guardian, specifying in which respect the classification is incorrect, and affording such person and such guardian (if any) an opportunity of being heard, alter the classification of that person in the register.

    HOWEVER to allow for potential error an appeal process had to exist and this was done via special boards

    Section 11 in part read:

    (7) The decision of a board shall be final and binding upon all persons including the Director: Provided that any person who considers himself aggrieved by a decision of a board in regard to his own classification may within thirty days after the decision of the board has been given, appeal against that decision by way of application on notice of motion to the provincial or local division of the Supreme Court of South Africa having jurisdiction in the area within which such person is ordinarily resident.

    (8) The division of the said Supreme Court to which appeal is made shall enquire into and consider the matter and shall confirm, vary or set aside the decision of the board, or give such other decision as in its opinion the board ought to have given, and may make such order as to costs as it may deem fit.

    (9) Any judgment given or order made by a provincial or local division of the said Supreme Court in terms of sub-section (8), shall be subject to appeal to the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of South Africa in the same manner and on the same conditions as a judgment given or order made in a civil proceeding in that provincial or local division…..

    If Israel goes down the path of Netanyahu’s Zionist “Jewish State” fantasy, then the question of who is and who isn’t a Jew becomes a matter of Law. In fact unless the identity classification of a Jew was sufficiently weak a large percentage of the immigrant population would arguably legally not fit it. So how then do you include them in your “Jewish Class” and exclude others. After all in Judaism is the recognition the Jews and Arabs share the same ancestry. So if an Arab converts does he then become a full Jew? – and who has a right to deny him entry when such denial becomes a matter of personal power relationship, access to some employment and access to certain accommodation etc?

    There are some hornets’ nests best left well alone.

  • Charles Martel

    Is Ms. Haskia a devout Muslim? By her words and actions she is not, which makes her an apostate, and a real secular, “moderate” Muslim. If this is the case, I wish her the best. If she is only playing a role until she is in a position of power, then I hope she ends in the deepest pit in hell.