Friday, May 26th | 1 Sivan 5777

Close

Be in the know!

Get our exclusive daily news briefing.

Subscribe
April 27, 2015 5:14 pm

Legal Report Explains Why IDF Targeting Practices Are Worthy of ‘Emulation’

avatar by Eliezer Sherman

Email a copy of "Legal Report Explains Why IDF Targeting Practices Are Worthy of ‘Emulation’" to a friend

IDF soldiers find a terror tunnel in Gaza last July. Photo: IDF

The IDF’s targeting practices are compliant with international law, keep with U.S. standards and even deserve “emulation,” a professor of international law and a military judge advocate concluded in a report published on Friday.

“While there are certainly Israeli legal positions that may be contentious, we found that their approach to targeting is consistent with the law and, in many cases, worthy of emulation,” wrote Director of the Stockton Center for the Study of International Law at the U.S. Naval War College, Michael Schmitt, and John Merriam, U.S. army judge advocate.

“Broadly speaking, we concluded that IDF positions on targeting law largely track those of the United States military,” they wrote.

Related coverage

May 25, 2017 12:53 pm
0

Netanyahu Presented With Plan to Transfer Some Eastern Jerusalem Neighborhoods to Palestinian Municipal Control

JNS.org - Knesset member Dr. Anat Berko (Likud) has presented Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu with a plan to separate some...

The two authors had been invited to investigate the IDF’s targeting practices and applications of the law of armed conflict shortly after last summer’s 50-day war between Hamas and Israel concluded. They published the abstract of their findings in the New York University academic legal journal, Just Security.

The report did not focus specifically on last summer’s conflict, but rather standard IDF practice.

According to the authors, Israeli targeting practices are within the “mainstream of contemporary state practice.” But they are also “nuanced,” they wrote, because of the military context in which the IDF is engaged.

For example, the IDF’s destruction of a house that was used as a site to launch rockets may strike outside observers as “excessive,” the authors wrote, but to the IDF the high military advantage of destroying the site, which prevents future indiscriminate rocket attacks against Israeli population centers, “may justify … levels of collateral damage.”

Understanding Israel’s “acute casualty aversion,” Hamas has developed a network of underground tunnels to infiltrate Israeli positions. Hamas “masks its fighters among the civilian population close to Israeli communities in an effort to surprise and overwhelm,” they wrote.

“Therefore the IDF places a high priority on the destruction of tunnels and the infrastructure that supports them, and is willing to operate aggressively both by ground and by air to root out Hamas fighters from the civilian population among which they hide,” the authors wrote. “Strikes on tunnel entrances, on cement plants that Israel claims are used to construct the tunnels, and on Hamas concentrations in civilian settings sometimes lead outside observers to question the degree to which Israel honors the principle of distinction, the rule of proportionality, and the requirement to take precautions in attack.”

Also on Monday, a letter written by U.N. Secretary General Ban Ki-moon blasted Palestinian groups in Gaza for hiding weapons in U.N. schools that were not being used for shelters during the conflict last summer.

The letter was published together with a U.N. inquiry into the air strikes against U.N. compounds in the Gaza Strip during last summer’s hostilities. Ban also railed against Israel for actions that killed at least 44 Palestinians at U.N. facilities.

“I will work with all concerned and spare no effort to ensure that such incidents will never be repeated,” he wrote.

Share this Story: Share On Facebook Share On Twitter Email This Article

Let your voice be heard!

Join the Algemeiner
  • PAT CONDELL SAID:

    “If we are serious about peace in the Middle East, then we need to stop pretending that the Israelis are dealing with a rational enemy they can negotiate with; because in doing that, we are helping to feed a massive political lie whose gravitational force has become so great, it has warped reality. It is Hamas who has turned Gaza into a ware-zone recently, not Israel…”

    SOURCE: Peace in the Middle East by Pat Condell
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sNNhG0zDtA8

    MICROBIOGRAPHY:
    Pat Condell is an atheist who was born in Ireland around 1950 CE and raised in England as a Roman Catholic and educated in Church of England schools.

  • PAT CONDELL SAID:

    “Irrational Islamic Jew-hatred is the root cause of the problem in the Middle East.”

    PAT CONDELL SAID:

    “It is often said, because it is true, that if the Arabs laid down their weapons, there would be peace, but if the Jews laid down their weapons, they would be massacred, because the Arabs, the Muslims Arabs for all you hair-splitters out there, don’t want peace, they want the Jews dead.”

    SOURCE: Useful idiots for Palestine by Pat Condell
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LeGYAfh9A1k
    MICROBIOGRAPHY:
    Pat Condell is an atheist who was born in Ireland around 1950 CE and raised in England as a Roman Catholic and educated in Church of England schools.

  • 10

    THE JEWS ARE SUPPOSE TO LOOK OUT FOR EACH OTHER AND MAKING SURE ALL THINGS ARE JEWISH BUILDING IT IN EVERY WAY. YOUR NOT SUPPOSE TO PUT ON THE NEWS A 6 STATE SOLUTION COMMON SENSE. A KOSHER CHINESE RESTAURANT HAD SPANISH ON THEIR TELEVISION INSTEAD OF SUPPORTING JEWISH STATION.

  • 10

    GOD IS PERFECT WHITE PURE HOW WE FIT IN WE ACCEPTED BELOW TO DEEP AND MIDDLE EAST WALKING RELIGIOUS PASS TIME INTO STAY CURRENT LIVING OF VIOLENCE.

    • TheAZCowBoy

      Typical racist Jewish thinking….

      “Who loves U scumbags?!”

  • 10

    OUR LIVES LEAD PUSHED TO MISERY AND SHORT LIVED BY THE BELIEFS OF OUR COPIED RELIGION THAT TAKE OUT LIVES AWAY.

  • 10

    Calypso John Denver Jacques Cousteau YOUTUBE GOD WORK

  • 10

    REVERSING THE RELIGION BELONG TO GOD THEN GOD CAN TAKE CARE OF HUMANS EQUAL AND ALL LIVING THINGS WITHOUT NO FIGHTING ABOVE GROUND AND BELOW,

  • 10

    WE ARE PROGRAMMED TO LEAVE NOT BY GOD BUT THE PRAYERS OF THE COPIED RELIGIONS

  • 10

    john denver calypso IS GOD CREATION

  • 10

    MIDDLE EAST RELIGIOUS GUIDED BY SATAN. RELIGION AND VIOLENCE HIS TOGETHER.

  • 10

    BY GOD POWER INSTRUCTION I HAD ISRAEL ALL BELONGS TO THE JEWS AND YOU DIDN;T KNOW IT BY THE PROLONGING CORRUPTED NEWS

  • 10

    ONLY THE SELECTIVE JEWS WHO KNOW BY GOD POWER CONTACTED. I CAN MELT IT AWAY THEY KNOW WHO THEY ARE. MERGE JEW TO JEW OR I WILL PRESS YOUR FRID AND SAT WORSHIPING SATAN DAY

  • 10

    IF YOU DECIDE THIS IS NEWS YOU WILL DIE TELLING IT

  • 10

    IF ANY JEWS DECIDE THIS IS NOT GOOD FOR YOU THEN YOU WILL JOIN YOUR BELOVED 70 YEARS AGO

  • 10

    THE JEWS WERE POOR WITH HALF RELIGION JEWISH LAWS REVERSED YOU FRIED FOR IT. A MEZUZAH CROOKED EXPLANATION SO YOU WOULD TAKE IT. GOD MEZUZAH IS STRAIGHT.

  • 10

    GOD TOLD ME TO INSTRUCT NETANYAHU AND GAVE WAY TO BENNET OPENED THE DOORS TO LEIBERMAN AND BARKAT FOR 7 YEARS WRITTEN AND DONE BY THE POWERS OF GOD. I MADE YOU AND WHAT YOU HAVE ALL OF ISRAEL. I AM THE MESSIAH OF GOD RETURN I WILL REVERSE ALL OF ISRAEL AND YOU WILL FEEL IT.

  • 10

    THE MUSEUMS HAVE THE PERMISSION TO WRITE THE HISTORY TO BLEND WITH THE RELIGIONS APPROVED

  • 10

    CLOISTER CASTLE CLEARED OUT WITH FALSE CROSS OF JESUS AND ARTIFACTS RAVING OF ANOTHER NOT GOD. JEWISH SEEN A SMALL GLASS OF NOTHING. ALL IS INCORRECT INFORMATIONS TO PLEASE TO STAY THE PREFERENCE ALLOWED THAT GOES FOR THE OTHER MUSEUMS TOO

  • 10

    GOD GAVE US NORMAL INTIMATE IN THE FRONT AND SATAN GAVE US THE BACK ASS RELATIONSHIP

  • 10

    THE DESCIPLES WERE NOT SUPPOSE TO LEAVE ISRAEL BUT THE CONDITION AFTER JESUS THEY DID AND WALKED INTO ANOTHER RELIGION

  • Egyptian Islamic clerics Sheik Said Al-‘Afani and Sheik Muhammad Abd Al-Salam appeared on Egytian Al-Rahma TV on 2009 January 17.
    This is what they said:

    Sheik Said Al-‘Afani said:

    “(The Jews) are the accursed people, who incurred the wrath of Allah.
    They are the offspring of snakes and vipers, the slayers of our Prophet Muhammad, whose death was a consequence of his being poisoned by a Jewish woman.

    We should know that the Jews are the slayer of all the prophets.
    They killed the prophet Yahya (John the Baptist) and the prophet Zakariya.
    The slaughtered the righteous prophet Yahya, and they presented his head as a gift to an Israelite prostitute. Our hatred of them [the Jews] is purely on religious grounds, and not because of the pure, sacred land, which was blessed by Allah, or because of Gaza…

    Not only because of Gaza, not only because of [the] al-Aqsa [mosque] and so on.

    We hate them [the Jews], first and foremost, because of their enmity towards Allah, and because they slayed our prophets. Let me clarify that it is our duty to hate them, as part of our faith.”

    Sheik Muhammad Abd Al-Salam said:

    “Right. People have become confused about this, some think that it is a territorial or national issue, or that it has to do with the blessed Al-Aqsa mosque; but the issue is much broader, it is a matter of faith. We are obligated to hate them because they are a murderous people, and the enemies of all that is good and of Islam.”

    SOURCE: Why Muslims hate Israel?
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uC0EqKI_Obs
    (a pricelessly honest 1.5 minute video from MEMRI TV)

  • 10

    Judas Priest – You’ve Got Another Thing Comin’ (lyrics) HE OWNS AND MADE AND GAVE TO US. HE IS ALL OVER MAD NO CREDITS TO HIM. BLOCKING GOD

  • 10

    THE REASON WHY CHRISTIAN CAN SHACK UP IN PALESTINIAN TERRITORY.

  • 10

    OTHER RELIGIONS DO THE SAME THING PRAY FOR IT NEGATIVES THEN GIVE HELP TO THE NEEDY

  • 10

    NEPAL BECAUSE JEWISH WAS HEARD FROM PEOPLE IN HINDU TERRITORY

  • 10

    REMEMBERING PRIME MINISTER IN HIS SPRING CLEANING

  • 10

    THE POWER OF PRAYERS FROM THE ULTRA ORTHODOX JEWS I CAN OVERIDE YOU FROM GOD POWERS OF DISCOVERY.

Algemeiner.com