Friday, October 20th | 30 Tishri 5778

Close

Be in the know!

Get our exclusive daily news briefing.

Subscribe
June 19, 2015 10:56 am

Michael Oren’s New Book Lifts Veil on US-Israel Relationship

avatar by Ben Cohen / JNS.org

Email a copy of "Michael Oren’s New Book Lifts Veil on US-Israel Relationship" to a friend
Former Israeli ambassador to the U.S. Michael Oren. PHOTO: Wikipedia.

Former Israeli ambassador to the U.S. Michael Oren. PHOTO: Wikipedia.

JNS.org – It’s safe to say that in the coming weeks, you’ll be reading a great deal about the forthcoming memoir, “Ally,” authored by Israel’s former ambassador to the United States, Michael Oren.

Oren spent the years 2009-13 as Israel’s envoy in Washington. Once a dual national of both the U.S. and Israel, the New Jersey-raised Oren had to surrender his U.S. passport at the American Embassy in Tel Aviv before taking up his ambassadorial post—an emotionally wrenching episode that he describes in detail. Oren’s complicated identity as an American and an Israeli is a theme that runs throughout the book, and his treatment of this subject is a welcome tonic to the dreary and rather smelly charges of “dual loyalty” that too often accompany examinations of the relationship that Jews in the diaspora have with the Jewish state.

The main attraction of the book, of course, is its account of the Obama administration’s Middle East policies, and Oren’s candor has already gotten him into trouble. Dan Shapiro, the current U.S. ambassador in Israel, who makes several appearances in Oren’s memoir, this week told Israel’s Army Radio that “Ally” is “an imaginary account of what happened,” going on to belittle Oren for having, as a mere ambassador, a “limited point of view into ongoing efforts. What he wrote does not reflect the truth.”

This is a serious charge, and it remains to be seen if Shapiro will attempt to substantiate it. In the meantime, it should be pointed out that what makes “Ally” such a fascinating read is that it provides, from Oren’s perspective, a detailed sense of the bitter atmosphere in both Washington and Jerusalem that underlay diplomatic efforts on the issues we are all intimately familiar with, from the negotiations over Iran’s nuclear program to the stalled Israeli-Palestinian peace process. Unlike other diplomats, Oren didn’t wait 20 years to publish his story—most of the key individuals in his book, most obviously President Barack Obama and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, are still in power, and the bilateral tensions which Oren agonizingly explains haven’t been lessened since his departure from Israel’s Washington embassy. Diplomats aren’t supposed to be this transparent, which is why Oren will be regarded in many circles as a man who broke “omerta,” the code of silence which ensures that us ordinary mortals are kept in the dark about what our leaders are saying in private.

Related coverage

October 20, 2017 11:55 am
0

What Really Happened With Saeb Erekat’s Lung Transplant?

Saeb Erekat, the chief Palestinian Authority (PA) peace negotiator and Secretary-General of the PLO executive committee, underwent a successful lung transplant in...

While it’s true that Obama comes in for heavy criticism, Oren rubbishes the claim that the president is “anti-Israel.” The reality is more complex; as Oren writes, “the Israel [Obama] cared about was also the Israel whose interests he believed he understood better than its own citizens.” One might add that this paternalistic approach has informed Obama’s stance on the entire region, resulting in a sly policy that presents itself to Americans as a much-desired withdrawal from the Middle East’s endless bloodshed while, at the same time, fundamentally redistributing the region’s balance of power in favor of Iran, whose rulers have spent almost 40 years chanting “Death to America.”

The reader is struck, reading Oren’s analysis of Obama’s policy speeches, by how often the president has used the phrase “I’m not naive”—surely a case, as Shakespeare might have put it, of “our elected leader doth protest too much.” On a visit to Turkey in April 2009—his first visit abroad—Obama emphasized his personal regard for that country’s irascible leader, President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, pointedly adding “I’m not naive.” He reached for this formulation again in an address to the U.N. General Assembly the following September, in which he articulated the demand for a “contiguous” Palestinian state. “I’m not naive,” Oren quotes the president saying, “but all of us must decide whether we are serious about peace or whether we will lend it lip service.”

“All of us,” as Oren’s book makes clear, was really code for “Israel,” and, specifically, Netanyahu. The fork-tongued Palestinian Authority President, Mahmoud Abbas, never experienced the same degree of diplomatic pressure from the Americans, and nor was he subjected to the kind of ugly whispering campaigns that have targeted Netanyahu.

Ironically, though, Obama’s zeal to resolve the Palestinian question by insisting on the 1967 lines as the border between two sovereign states actually boxed in the Palestinian leader. Despite Abbas’s apparent willingness “to concede parts of the West Bank and East Jerusalem to Israel,” Oren says, “the White House continued to condemn Israeli construction in some of the very areas that Abbas offered to forgo.” Obama’s visceral opposition to settlements also placed Abbas in an awkward position when it came to other potential concessions from the Palestinian side. “Mahmoud Abbas,” Oren memorably writes, “could not be less Palestinian than Obama.”

On Iran—the source of a truly existential threat to Israel—Oren’s book offers little in the way of comfort. Oren recalls hearing Israel’s late prime minister, Yitzhak Rabin, warning in the early 1990s that Iran “was covertly working to produce nuclear bombs”—a deadly prospect that has been kept alive in the ongoing negotiations with Tehran. In Obama’s eyes, though, this reality has been inverted. “When I came into office, Iran was united and the world was divided,” Oren quotes the president asserting. “And now what we have is a united international community that is saying to Iran, you’ve got to change your ways.” Somehow, somewhere along the line, the successive U.N. Security Council resolutions demanding an end to Iran’s enrichment activities must have disappeared.

Since none of the problems described in “Ally” have been resolved—if anything, they have been exacerbated—the book can be regarded as an important reality check for those readers who still believe that the current administration has Israel’s back. Oren recalls a “fuming” Susan Rice, who now serves as Obama’s national security adviser, telling him, “If you don’t appreciate the fact that we defend you night and day, tell us. We have other important things to do.” The contemptuous tone isn’t the most worrying aspect of this remark; rather, it’s the absurd implication that the security relationship between the U.S. and Israel flows in one direction only. The vital fact that Israel fights its own wars and doesn’t require American troops to risk their lives for its security again appears to have been overlooked.

As we head towards the ostensible climax of the Iran negotiations on June 30—which will likely be accompanied by a renewed assault on Israel’s legitimacy stemming from the publication of the U.N.’s biased report on the Gaza conflict of July and August 2014—the timing of Oren’s book couldn’t be better. My modest advice, then, is to ignore the background noise, read the book, and decide for yourselves whether or not the smothering “chibbuk” (Hebrew for hug) in which the U.S., under Obama, has placed Israel is in the best interests of the world’s only Jewish state.

Ben Cohen, senior editor of TheTower.org & The Tower Magazine, writes a weekly column for JNS.org on Jewish affairs and Middle Eastern politics. His writings have been published in Commentary, the New York Post, Haaretz, The Wall Street Journal, and many other publications. He is the author of “Some of My Best Friends: A Journey Through Twenty-First Century Antisemitism” (Edition Critic, 2014).

The opinions presented by Algemeiner bloggers are solely theirs and do not represent those of The Algemeiner, its publishers or editors. If you would like to share your views with a blog post on The Algemeiner, please be in touch through our Contact page.

Share this Story: Share On Facebook Share On Twitter Email This Article

Let your voice be heard!

Join the Algemeiner
  • defiantjewess

    • 3 days ago
    Obama has underhandedly lied to the Jewish people, starting with his AIPAC speech when he vowed to keep Jerusalem undivided. Then it was off for a whirlwind visit to the ME, where he met with Arab leaders, and kowtowed, even doing something no leader of the USA ever has done, bowing to the SAUDI king. From then on it was pressure all the way towards giving the PA a state, all the while calling himself an ‘get this, Honest broker.” Oren’s book goes on in detail about the backstabbing done by the Obama administration. No one in his right mind believes this man is good for the Jews in Israel or around the world. Open your eyes and get the twinkle berries out of them Even his body language when around the PM shows how uncomfortable he is. Thanks to Obama my entire family are now staunch Repubs. He took the democratic party and infused it with Jew hatred, through and through.

  • Avi

    Yeah, must read. I already ordered my copy from Amazon. This book and Carolyn Glick’s The Israel Solution ( I’m on final chapter) highly recommended.

  • Paul

    You write “The vital fact that Israel fights its own wars and doesn’t require American troops to risk their lives for its security again appears to have been overlooked.”
    This is amazing !!
    Does the US really owe us anything ? Do they HAVE to come and rescue us ?
    What arrogance !!!

  • Leslie Benjamini

    Finally someone tells the truth.

  • Theo

    This book and others, by equally competent authors, will highlight the Obama mind – set whereby he deserts allies in favour of masters of terror We are dealing with a particular inverted personality for which America and the world will pay a high price

  • yuval Brandstetter MD

    Oren has no one but himself to blame for the shoddy way he and his boss were treated by Obama.
    It is oren and his “centrist” political camp who advocated forever that Isarael give up on its ancestral heartland and pass it to a bunch of hoodlooms masquerading as a proto-state. All Obama did is take up this defeatist attitude and adapt it to the islamic view of Jews as submissive subservient diasporic dhimmis, and demand they take this attitude to its logical conclusion. When the cur refused to back down Obama produced alternatively the lash and the cloying “assistance” of which oren and Bibi were all to happy to partake. Let Oren look into his own beliefs and policy before he blames others for the inevitable conclusions of those beliefs and policies

    • defiantjewess

      • 3 days ago
      Obama has underhandedly lied to the Jewish people, starting with his AIPAC speech when he vowed to keep Jerusalem undivided. Then it was off for a whirlwind visit to the ME, where he met with Arab leaders, and kowtowed, even doing something no leader of the USA ever has done, bowing to the SAUDI king. From then on it was pressure all the way towards giving the PA a state, all the while calling himself an ‘get this, Honest broker.” Oren’s book goes on in detail about the backstabbing done by the Obama administration. No one in his right mind believes this man is good for the Jews in Israel or around the world. Open your eyes and get the twinkle berries out of them Even his body language when around the PM shows how uncomfortable he is. Thanks to Obama my entire family are now staunch Repubs. He took the democratic party and infused it with Jew hatred, through and through.

  • yuval Brandstetter MD
  • Okey

    How demeaning that the head of Mr Oren’s Kulanu Party reportedly apologised to the Obama Administration for Mr Oren’s book.
    Was this because Barack Hussein Obama issued a fatwa against the author?

  • Michael Mayben

    When is Obama going to admit that he’s a pro-Islamic Radical. He and his heavily weighted Muslim Administration and pictures if him removing his shoes to pray to his God Mohammad is enough for me to believe he’s a fox in America’s hen house. Over 75% of Americans think the Iran nuclear deal is bad for America. France, Germany, and the U.K., the European powers part of the P5+1, are between 62% to 81% against it and China views are at 61% against the deal. In the Middle East Israel is 90% against the deal, Jordan’s view of Iran is 89% negative followed by Turkey at 64%, Lebanon at 58%, and in the Palestinian Territories at 57% . Through out the Middle East the Iranian President Hassan Rouhani receives very low scores as the leader of the Islamic State. What’s it going to take to get Congress to listen to America’s Allies, the Middle East neighbors of Iran, and the other nations of the world. Iran is an untrustworthy enemy of all nations of the world. Iran will use nuclear weapons to threaten and intimidate every nation that doesn’t accept Islamic beliefs and is prepared to destroy the earth to achieve their goal of an Islamic world or die for their fictitious paradise.

  • Michall Oren: Why Obama is wrong about Iran being ‘rational’ on nukes
    http://www.madisdead.blogspot.co.il/2015/06/micheal-oren-why-obama-is-wrong-about_19.html

    Bernard Lewis:
    In this context, the deterrent that worked so well during the Cold War, namely M.A.D. (Mutual Assured Destruction) , would have no meaning. At the End of Time, there will be general destruction anyway. What will matter is the final destination of the dead– hell for the infidels, and the delights of heaven for the believers. For people with this mindset, M.A.D. is not a constraint; it is an inducement…
    http://www.madisdead.blogspot.co.il/2012/05/why-are-bernard-lewiss-views-on-mad.html

    • theo

      The two state idea is total lunacy !
      Israel in good faith and with the best intentions withdrew from Gaza And what did they get in return ?
      Daggers and missiles and tunnels aimed at their civilian population
      Only a president who looks to the demise of Israel would expect them to repeat this grave error
      Israel is not in the business of committing suicide
      Abbas ,who is the eleventh year ( or is it now the 12th )of his five year term is only a sneeze away from falling to Hamas
      Obama shows his true self when he bullies Israel to stick to the two- state solution
      A state the size of New Jersey must dissect itself even further to satisfy the POTUS Not a hope !

Algemeiner.com