Monday, March 19th | 3 Nisan 5778


Be in the know!

Get our exclusive daily news briefing.

October 11, 2015 7:56 am

Controversial Israeli Rabbi Says Terrorists May Not Be Left Alive After Attacks

avatar by David Daoud

Email a copy of "Controversial Israeli Rabbi Says Terrorists May Not Be Left Alive After Attacks" to a friend
Rabbi Shmuel Eliahu (pictured) said that it is forbidden to leave a terrorist alive after they carry out an attack. PHOTO: Rabbi Eliahu's Facebook Page.

Rabbi Shmuel Eliyahu (pictured) said that it is forbidden to leave terrorists alive after they have carried out attacks. PHOTO: Rabbi Eliyahu’s Facebook Page.

An Israeli rabbi known for his extremist views published a halachic ruling on Thursday that terrorists may not be left alive after they have carried out attacks, Israeli news website nrg reported.

Safed Chief Rabbi Shmuel Eliyahu made the announcement on Facebook in response to a query he had received about whether it was permissible to leave terrorists alive in order to interrogate them.

Eliyahu wrote, “If you leave him alive, there is a fear that he will be released and kill other people.” But, he added, it is necessary to adopt counter-terrorism methods most compatible with the law.

He continued, “Only of there is no other option, and there is a ticking bomb, is it permissible to keep him alive, to interrogate him, and to send him to hell as quickly as possible.”

Eliyahu also ruled that soldiers or police officers who leave terrorists alive in the wake of attacks should be prosecuted. He called for the establishment of a committee to investigate the circumstances under which terrorists are not killed, implying that no one should be exempt from scrutiny. “Maybe there are people in the State Attorney’s office who should be prosecuted; maybe there are officers in the police or the army who should be shaken [into action].”

Two Facebook commenters challenged the rabbi’s post, asking him whether he would also apply his dictum to Yigal Amir, the Jewish terrorist who assassinated Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin, and Yishai Schlissel, who stabbed marchers at a Jerusalem gay pride parade in 2005 and again this year, fatally wounding 16-year-old Shira Banki. Eliyahu did not respond.

Eliyahu is no stranger to controversial statements. In the past, he has advocated “carpet bombing the general area from which Qassam rockets are launched into Israel, regardless of the risk to Palestinian life,” and for “state-sanctioned revenge” against Arabs.

After the 2008 terror attack on the Mercaz HaRav Yeshiva, in which eight Israeli students were murdered, Eliyahu called for the state to take “awesome revenge,” such as “hanging the children of the terrorist who carried out the attack… from a tree.”

Eliyahu was also involved in the publication and distribution of, “On Either Side of the Border,” a pamphlet promoting a conspiracy-theory based on purported testimony from a “Hezbollah officer who spied for Israel,” who claimed that the Vatican helped organize tours of the Auschwitz death camp for Hezbollah members to teach them how to kill Jews.

Share this Story: Share On Facebook Share On Twitter Email This Article

Let your voice be heard!

Join the Algemeiner
  • What is so controversial about that? It’s common sense to kill murderers. In Israel there is death penalty for Nazis and those who kill Jews BECAUSE they are Jews. This is EXACTLY what’s going on here despite what the Knesset members say.

  • Martin Katchen

    It has always been the derech eretz in the Middle East that when captives are taken it is a duty to ransom them–generally by taking captives from the nation of the captors. Anyone who is imprisoned is considered to be prisoners to be exchanged at some point. The idea of prisoners losing their liberty for a set amount of time as payment for a crime is totally alien in the Mideast. So Muslim prisoners taken invite either jailbreaks or Jewish prisoners taken to be exchanged. If one is serious about punishing a serious crime, Arab regimes execute people. So Israel is not following derech eretz when it fails to execute terrorists.

  • Martin Katchen

    Israel has lost a lot of respect in the world by being the only nation on the Asian continent without a death penalty.

  • Emanuel

    It’s not controversial it’s the American way tell that to the arbitrator and remember killing them is better than desecrating their bodies it’s more respectful and it’s also what they want.