Monday, July 16th | 4 Av 5778

November 30, 2015 8:54 am

The Jews and the ‘Ordinary Citizens’

avatar by Judith Bergman

Email a copy of "The Jews and the ‘Ordinary Citizens’" to a friend
French Ambassador to the US Gerard Araud. Photo: Wikimedia Commons.

French Ambassador to the US Gerard Araud. Photo: Wikimedia Commons.

After the terrorist attacks in Paris, French citizens living in the United States received a letter from Gerard Araud, France’s ambassador in Washington. After expressing solidarity with the people of France and praising the US and President Barack Obama for “being on our side in the fight against extremism and terrorism,” Araud wrote: “These are the foundations of our model of society that the terrorists seek to destroy: yesterday, journalists and Jews; now, ordinary citizens whose only crime was to enjoy life on a Friday night in Paris.”

Understandably, French Jews were outraged by the implication that they are apparently not viewed by official France as “ordinary citizens,” but a category apart. Some have suggested this was just a slip. That is highly unlikely, as professional diplomats and their embassy staffs weigh every word extremely carefully before making any kind of written statement. Others have maintained that French Jews were overreacting, since all the ambassador was doing was acknowledging that Jews were an early target.

Not so. The ambassador was indeed expressing what official France thinks of the Jews: that they are a category apart from “ordinary” Frenchmen. Proof of this is not just in his words, but in the deeds of the French.

French Jews have heard this kind of talk before. When, in October 1980, a terrorist bomb in a synagogue in Rue Copernic in Paris killed four people, two of them non-Jewish passersby, then-Prime Minister Raymond Barre had this to say: “They aimed at the Jews and they hit innocent Frenchmen.” (The same Raymond Barre, by the way, stated in a radio interview in 2007 that “opposing the deportation of Jews from France was not a matter of major national interest.”)

Forty years before that, it was the French police under the collaborationist Vichy government who rounded up and deported 80,000 Jews to their deaths in the German concentration camps. Nowhere in Western Europe did the Nazis receive such substantial collaboration from the local administration. The French even set up their own concentration camps on French soil, which held thousands of Jews, some of whom died of starvation and disease even before they could board the death trains. After the war, in 1946, French philosopher Jean-Paul Sartre said: “Now all France rejoices and fraternizes in the streets. … Do we say anything about the Jews? Do we give a thought to those who died in the gas chambers at Lublin? Not a word. Not a line in the newspapers. That is because we must not irritate the anti-Semites.”

Already in 1967, official France was at it again. Shortly after the Six-Day War, Charles de Gaulle characterized the Jewish people in language that brought back the wrong kind of associations: “Some even feared that the Jews, hitherto scattered but remaining what they had always been, that is, an elite people, self-assured and domineering, might, once they were reunited in the city of their former grandeur, turn the very moving hopes of 1,900 years into a burning ambition of conquest.” Every anti-Semitic cliche in the book.

After the 1980 bombing, President Valery Giscard d’Estaing took five days to even respond to the Jewish victims, warning Jews “not to retaliate” and underplaying the danger of antisemitism.

French Jews, therefore, have very good reason to be skeptical of and outraged at statements like the one that Araud made. Especially because until Charlie Hebdo and the November Paris attacks, they alone were at the receiving end of the terror and violence perpetrated mainly by French Muslims against synagogues and Jewish schools, against rabbis and Jewish children. This terror against the Jewish communities in France has been ongoing for about 15 years, increasing exponentially year by year, and the French did nothing substantial against it. Clearly, it did not bother them that so many of their citizens were living under a state of siege.

The French did not flood the streets in sympathy demonstrations with the Jewish children ‎Mohamed‎ Merah hunted down and shot through the head in front of their school in Toulouse. Earlier they did not react when Ilan Halimi was slowly tortured to death over the course of three weeks by Muslims in Paris.

The French masses did not rise in solidarity with the countless numbers of French Jews who have in recent years been subjected to verbal and physical abuse, harassment on the streets and in the school yards, on the Metro, in front of Jewish restaurants and even in their own homes.

The French barely noticed when a march for Gaza in the summer of 2014 nearly ended in a pogrom on a Parisian synagogue filled with Jewish worshippers. They did not protest when a mob of thousands marched in the streets of Paris, hollering that the Jews did not belong in France.

Now they are horrified. Because now they themselves are at the receiving end.

Still, official France, in the words of Araud, has the nerve to say, “Yesterday, journalists and Jews; now, ordinary citizens whose only crime was to enjoy life on a Friday night in Paris.”

What was the “crime” of the Jews? Just being Jews.

Judith Bergman is a writer and political analyst living in Israel.

This article was first published in Israel Hayom.

The opinions presented by Algemeiner bloggers are solely theirs and do not represent those of The Algemeiner, its publishers or editors. If you would like to share your views with a blog post on The Algemeiner, please be in touch through our Contact page.

Share this Story: Share On Facebook Share On Twitter Email This Article

Let your voice be heard!

Join the Algemeiner
  • Sam Harris

    Not surprised by the French.

  • Franklin Delano Paskutnik

    Excellent article Ms.Bergman!Is it any wonder that the French collaborated so enthusiastically with the Vichy/Nazi regime and silently stood by as tens of thousands of French Jews were shipped off to their deaths in Nazi concentration camps? And who was the symbolic head of Vichy – none other than Marshal Petain – one of France’s great heroes of the First World War. France has always been – and still is – a hotbed of anti-Jewish and anti-Israel propaganda and conspiracy theorists.
    It is high time that the Jews of France reconsider their position : is it really worthwhile living fortress-like amidst a sea of Jew-hating Muslims and anti-Semitic Catholics?As for the duplicitous Charles de Gaulle,who, in an instant,changed from pro-Israel to pro-Arab after the Six Day War – I believe he was envious of Israel’s military victories – something that he failed so miserably to achieve in the Second World War.In the Catholic mindset Jews are not supposed to win any wars – they must always be victims as eternal punishment for their “crime” of killing Jesus.It all started with Matthew 27:24-25 : “His blood on us and our children”.In the minds of many Frenchmen the Jews are and always will be “Christ killers” and must suffer retribution until the end of time.The bottom-line is that the survival and protection of the Jewish people is contingent upon the survival and strength of our cherished Land of Israel.

  • Sam Omekara

    Jews should not be under any illusions that official antisemitism is dead in Western Europe or North America. The sentiments against Jews are in tandem with Hitler’s final solution. I am sure that if Hitler hadn’t mixed his territorial ambitions with his genocidal goals the world would have gladly joined hands in his evil actions against the Jews.
    Yes, out of every generation there will arise those intend on destroying the Jew but HaShem will always save Zion.
    The only safe place for Jews is Eretz Israel. There is no future for Jews in Europe. Europe could have been collaborators of medieval Islamic insurgents, Daesh or ISIS, if the latter had only Jews in their sights.
    To the dismay of the antisemites of all ages the Eternal nation will remain the light unto the nations.

  • Remember once and for all…French is spelled V-I-C-H-Y….case closed!

  • The future for French Jews is in Israel. Jews are ‘Extraordinary Citizens’ wherever they reside. It is no “crime” to be a Jew and Jew-haters are criminals.

  • Gilou

    This guy must be schizophrenic. He is openly gay.

    He was surely happy to live in the most gay-friendly city in the world (when he was the French ambassador in Israel).

    But he can’t keep speaking of his love for those marvellous islamic countries, where gays are hanged or beheaded.

  • =============================================
    How French Police Handle Anti-Jewish Attacks

    Judge after judge told him [Sammy Ghozlan,
    a 72-year-old retired Paris police commissioner]:

    “There is no anti-Semitism charge applicable unless someone dies.”

    New Dangers for the Jews of Paris by Marie Brenner, Vanity Fair magazine, August 2015, page 114

    PS: * * * *

  • What has the world learned since Charlie Hebdo?
    The “Je Suis Charlie” campaign began as something good and right, honoring the victims of terrorism and restating the importance of freedom of speech.
    The Je Suis Juif, “I am a Jew” campaign, did not catch on with the same amount of enthusiasm.
    As a Jewish, Israeli I say that until we all learn to say “Je Suis Kafir” none of us will be safe: