Wednesday, March 21st | 5 Nisan 5778


Be in the know!

Get our exclusive daily news briefing.

July 22, 2016 6:43 pm

Columnist Says Israel ‘Last Hope’ for Arab Christians Before Total Annihilation

avatar by Lea Speyer

Email a copy of "Columnist Says Israel ‘Last Hope’ for Arab Christians Before Total Annihilation" to a friend
Columnist Luma Simms called Israel the "last hope" for Middle East Christians. Photo:

Columnist Luma Simms called Israel the “last hope” for Middle East Christians. Photo:

Arab Christians must come to understand that Israel represents their “last hope” to be saved from annihilation by jihadists in the region, a Middle Eastern Christian columnist wrote Thursday in an op-ed published by the online news magazine The Federalist.

According to Luma Simms — who grew up in Ba’athist Iraq — Middle Eastern Christians must overcome widespread anti-Jewish indoctrination that is rampant in Arab lands.

“Anyone who claims that the Arab world — Muslim and Christian — is not pathologically antisemitic is delusional. This is the elephant in the room in the Arab Christian subculture; the secret sin no one wants to bring to the light,” she wrote.

It is this “secret sin” — which Simms calls “a blight upon the people of my heritage” — that prevents Arab Christians from reaching out to Israel for help as they suffer at the hands of radical Islamic jihadists.

Antisemitism has deep roots in the Middle East, Simms wrote, recorded as far back as the biblical Book of Esther outlining the genocidal plans of Persian vizier Haman against the Jewish nation. Islamic rulers adopted the idea of Jews as the “scapegoat” for their problems and this antisemitism “trickl[ed] down to minority groups living in Islamic dominated lands.”

Middle Eastern antisemitism in unique, Simms contends, saying it “goes beyond garden-variety envy. It is the belief that Israel is behind every evil in the world and especially the evil that befalls the Arab world. Therefore, it ought to be destroyed!”

The Arab world’s failure to recognize Israel as a Jewish state — with the exceptions of Jordan and Egypt — is a consequence of this unique form of antisemitism, Simms said, adding:

Because for Arab countries to acknowledge a Jewish state would require that they acknowledge Jewish people as people, as human persons. Their antisemitism does not allow them to do this. Antisemitism in the Arab bosom sets the relationship between the Arab and the Jew in what Austrian-German Jewish philosopher Martin Buber called the ‘I-It’ relationship, rather than the ‘I-You.’ They cannot recognize the state because they cannot recognize the people; they cannot recognize the people because they have established a relationship with them not as human persons but as an ‘It,’ as object rather than subject.

Simms expressed her hope that Arab Christian culture — which she believes is acting under a type of Stockholm Syndrome — will “break this spell” of antisemitism. “But hope is running out — Christianity may not survive in the Middle East,” she wrote, adding:

Israel is the last hope for Arab Christians; it’s as simple as that…Helping them, doing good to the Christians in the Arab world, would require Israel overcoming her neighbors’ antisemitism, even of those Christians who will not ask for help because of their prejudices. Arab Christians…feel caught between Muslim interests on one side and Israeli interests on the other. They are bitter. They are a weak minority, always overlooked…Their bitterness makes them miss an important ally: Israel. As the genocide of Middle Eastern Christians continues, the only hope of an Arab Christian remnant — a remnant that would keep and pass on its beliefs, traditions, and customs — is through help from the state of Israel. It is the humanitarian thing to do.

Praising Israel for its “humane treatment of her enemies,” Simms hailed the Jewish state’s decision to set up field hospitals near its borders where the IDF can discreetly treat those injured by conflict in bordering Syria.

Israel, for its part, must remember its own history and the many attempts to wipe the Jewish people off the map, Simms argues, writing:

Remember, Israel, that you were enslaved, persecuted, and almost exterminated. Remember that some wanted to destroy you from the face of the earth. Even now many of your neighbors want to annihilate you. What better way to do good to some of your enemies and save yourself at the same time than by forging an alliance with Arab Christians?

Concluding her article, Simms called on the Jewish state to “rise up and lead that region of the world.”

“Let it always be said: In the dark age of ISIS, when desolation and despair covered the Arab world, Israel was the house of light,” she wrote. “Like the prophet Jonah whom God commanded to go to Nineveh and offer redemption to the Assyrians, may Israel go and redeem Assyria — redeem the Nineveh plains once again.”

Share this Story: Share On Facebook Share On Twitter Email This Article

Let your voice be heard!

Join the Algemeiner
  • Bob M

    Christians love to EXCLUDE themselves from the concept that “ALL NATIONS” will be against Israel. It is not hard to imagine laws against Jew being enacted, nor hard to imagine christians righting off the persecution as “justice” because Jews continue to reject their god.

    Sorry, christians; “ALL” means ALL. I would fully expect that when the going gets tough, you’ll stand aside and let Israel take ANOTHER beating!
    But that is OK. All Israel needs is G-d anyway.

    The theology of christianity could have been written by antiochus epiphanes: reject the books; outlaw the Shabbat; replace all the days ordained by G-d Himself; abolish the food laws.

    Yup! antiochus epiphanes would be chosen to be a deacon or pastor in most churches.

    What antiochus epiphanes tried to accomplish with the sword, christianity is trying to accomplish with doctrine.
    The truly despicable part is that they try to convince everyone that their doctrine was the plan all along and that it actually came from G-d.

  • Historically, Arab Christians have been every bit as hostile to Jews as Arab Muslims, possibly more so. Just to give one example, the only real opposition to the change in Catholic teaching on Judaism that Vatican II approved was from the bishops in the Middle East.

  • robert davis

    PS. Of course I do know muslims would not like it to see South Lebanon christian villages to be bolstered and more of them created so as to make the place a christian stronghold and this is why I said it will take a lot of courage for christians to do that but this is what Israelis did at the start and therefore it is possible in particular with the help of a friendly and powerful neighbour. Still it is not easy and the christian migrants would have to turn muslims’ obstacles. It takes idealism and I am not sure arab christians’ forte is …idealism!

  • robert davis

    Simms is clever and brave but she does not say HOW christians could ally with Israel apart from the fact those christians who would want to ally with Israel do it only when they are on the verge of annihilation not by friendship. I can see only one way for the lebanese christians to muster South of Lebanon and set up a Republic with the helpof Israel. But how can they do it? it would take far more COURAGE than they can muster. Christians fromNorthern Lebanon and Beyruth should migrate SLOWLY to South Lebanon and regroup in christian villages first, create more christian villages until they get a population large enough with weapons they could get from Israel, expel the muslims and only then ask for Israel’s help to crush the hizbollah which would try to crush the christian villages. There is a strategic and tactical way to set up a christian stronghold which could in turn defend all mid east christians with the help of Israel.Such a thing does not occur overnight thanks to a philosophical thought.

    • Cortland Richmond

      It starts in the heart or it dies.

  • nat cheiman

    How true!

  • Lyrrem

    Simms knows her biblical history and has real spiritual insight into Middle Eastern cultural barriers and the anti-semitism that have excluded Israel from any Arab thinking, even Christians. This article is right on time and right on the money – as they say – and I hope that Arab Christian leaders will see an open door and help their people seek this door of freedom, at the risk of losing all…
    He who watches over Isrsel neither slumber a nor sleeps….