Thursday, May 24th | 10 Sivan 5778


Be in the know!

Get our exclusive daily news briefing.

November 3, 2016 6:29 am

Human Sanctity and the Animal Kingdom

avatar by David Stav

Email a copy of "Human Sanctity and the Animal Kingdom" to a friend
Noah's Ark on Mount Ararat by Simon de Myle. Photo: Wikimedia Commons.

Noah’s Ark on Mount Ararat by Simon de Myle. Photo: Wikimedia Commons.

In this week’s reading of Parshat Noah, the Torah presents the first in a series of teachings where God imparts a code of ethics for how our “new world” should be guided.

Through a modern lens of morality, one would expect that the commands might focus first on relations among fellow men, prohibiting murder and theft or something similar. While God does eventually mention these prohibitions, they only come later.

As might be expected, the first teaching stresses the commandment to “be fruitful and multiply,” which is understandably the very core of our continued existence and deserves its place as the first mitzvah in the Torah.

But the very next commandment seems strange: “Every living creature should be for your consumption — just like the grasses of the fields, I have given all for you.” Even though the Torah later qualifies this teaching in terms of which living creatures are included, the understanding is clear: we are permitted and even encouraged to consume animals for our nutritional needs.

The obvious question is why this is so important as to be raised as one of the first commandments. Is it possible that God has prioritized our right to eat steaks and schnitzel? After having essentially destroyed the world He created, is this a priority?

Soon thereafter, God quickly turns to the topics that we would have thought would come first: prohibiting the murder of fellow humans, etc.

But the question of why the mitzvah to eat meat preceded this one remains a mystery.

We know that every letter in the Torah has meaning, as does the order of the commandments.

I would suggest that God wants us to understand from the very outset that there is a definite hierarchy among living creatures and that by saying we are permitted to eat animals, God intends us to infer that humans must be placed on a higher level. All living things are not equal, and we cannot and must not treat humans the way that we are allowed to treat animals.

In Nazi Germany, there were many people who valiantly promoted the rights of animals and at the very same time were actively participating in the very worst acts against humans.

During the expulsion of Gush Katif, I recall animal-rights advocates who prioritized the plight of animals left behind in the evacuated areas. I am troubled to recognize that those same advocates had far less concern for the humans who were forced out of their homes.

This should in no way be interpreted as a callous approach to the importance of animals. The Torah makes it very clear that animals should not be unnecessarily mistreated, and that their slaughter must be performed in the least painful manner possible.

Yet, the lesson from the teachings of God to Noah is that there must be priorities in how we measure life — and that human life is indeed superior.

At a time when our people are once again being targeted in Israel and around the world simply for being Jews, this lesson should be remembered, as we recall the sanctity of man who was created in God’s image.

The opinions presented by Algemeiner bloggers are solely theirs and do not represent those of The Algemeiner, its publishers or editors. If you would like to share your views with a blog post on The Algemeiner, please be in touch through our Contact page.

Share this Story: Share On Facebook Share On Twitter Email This Article

Let your voice be heard!

Join the Algemeiner
  • Andrea

    There are far, far more quotes one can cite from Torah that do not condone eating animals. Noah was a vegan! Letting humans eat other animals was G-d’s compromise. Animal rights activists are the most compassionate people on the planet. How dare you accuse them of not caring for the humans? Everyone is caring for the humans; only a small number of us will care for the animals as well. When HaShem sees the sick methods of factory farming and animal abuse that humans have come up with to consume their animal products cheaply, he is sickened. Many Rabbis agree! Join Jewish Veg and learn that the true spirit of Judaism is embodied in veganism. There is a reason Israel is the MOST VEGAN country on Earth.

  • Lucy S.

    Another pathetic attempt to justify a sick attitude towards our fellow living beings by slandering animal rights people as “Nazis”. How revolting.

  • Reb_Yaakov

    Humans are animals, as anyone who has studied biology knows. The Torah has never encouraged the consumption of meat — on the contrary. There is no nutritional need for meat. And people who are concerned about the plight of non-human animals do not prioritize those animals over humans. Further, playing the Nazi card no longer works.

    The Rav, Joseph Ber Soloveitchik, considered all life to be part of one continuum. He wrote, as published in “The Emergence of Ethical Man” (Ktav, 2005, p. 36): “Animal hunters and flesh-eaters are people that lust. Of course, it is legalized, approved. Yet it is classified as ta’avah, lust, repulsive and brutish.” Let the real Judaism now stand up — a faith and weltanschauung embodying a deep respect for the sanctity of all life.

  • Jane Tracy

    Of course it’s a form of racism that has always followed humans, but when you compare the behavior characteristics of homo-sapiens with other carnivores , it’s obvious by the very word of G-d himself, that bugs are closer to him than us.