Wednesday, July 26th | 3 Av 5777

Close

Be in the know!

Get our exclusive daily news briefing.

Subscribe
December 12, 2016 7:20 am

The Palestinians Can’t Define Israel or Its Future

avatar by Justin Amler

Email a copy of "The Palestinians Can’t Define Israel or Its Future" to a friend
The Temple Mount in Jerusalem. Photo: Wikipedia.

The Temple Mount in Jerusalem. Photo: Wikipedia.

There are many people who want to define Israel by its conflict with the Palestinians. They say that in order to “save” Israel, we must “save” the Palestinians — that by giving the Palestinians a state, we will guarantee Israel’s future.

Because of this misguided worldview, they try to force Israel into concessions and bad deals that would actually undermine its future.

The truth is that Israel is not defined by the Palestinians.

Related coverage

July 26, 2017 10:41 am
0

The Epic Failure of the BDS Cultural Boycott

For weeks, the headlines focused on the campaign by Roger Waters to persuade Radiohead to cancel its Israel gig. Yet...

Israel and the Jews are defined by ourselves — by our history, culture and heritage — our past and our future. This is not a history written on paper and UN resolutions, but one etched in the very dust beneath our feet. It’s a history that is found in mountaintops and valleys — in desert bushes and stones that have seen hundreds of generations pass by. It is carried by the wind that blows through every corner of this small and ancient country.

We don’t just read about Israel’s history; we live it.

And the Palestinians, as much as they want to force themselves into that past, are simply not part of it. They’re not even a footnote. Abbas and his minions want to tell you about the glorious history of Palestine that existed thousands of years ago, yet there has never been a single stone uncovered, or a single brick unearthed to back up those claims.

The Palestinians, throughout their very short history, have always tried to make the conflict about them and their “historical grievances” — when the history of the Holy Land never knew of such a people.

The Arab world has always been a tribal world, and Arab nationalism never existed prior to forces of the British and French exerting their power in the area, drawing lines — and borders — in the sand. Israel does not need to create a 23rd Arab state.

The Palestinians are not part of our history. We should stop giving them prominence by making them think they are.

And if their claims are so strong and indisputable, then why did the UN have to create a separate refugee category that exists solely for Palestinians and no one else?

Prime Minister Netanyahu wants Abbas and the Palestinians to recognize Israel as a Jewish state — something that Abbas has flatly refused to do. Why, then, should Israel recognize the Palestinians as anything more than just another Arab people living in the Middle East?

The future of Israel and the Jewish people is dependent on us. It is not dependent on the United Nations, and certainly not on the Palestinians. We should start acting accordingly.

Share this Story: Share On Facebook Share On Twitter Email This Article

Let your voice be heard!

Join the Algemeiner
  • Ken – USA

    Am Yisroel Chia – Cheers to you Justin!!!!!

  • Mara Cohen

    Reb_Yaakov. Israel is very much the Jewish Nation. It is the Ancestral and present day Home of the Ethno Religious People known as Jews.
    You may indeed think that Israel is not a Theocracy. It isn’t. Nor does it have to be.
    And I must agree with you, never has a Jewish State ever been without others as Citizens. It is almost as though we need the leavening of others.
    However, just as we legally received our Land via the San Remo Accords, the Treaty of Sevres, and League of Nation’s Mandate System to once again take legal control of our ancestral homeland, 99% of all the Lands available in the area under the League of Nations, was given to Arabs. Of the Land set aside for Jews to develop and support Jewish sovereignty and self determination, 77% was then cut off from Jews, Jews were ethnically cleansed and this part of the designated Jewish National Home was given to the Arab Palestinians. It was called “TransJordan”.
    For those Local Arabs who wish to now be Israeli, A path to Citizenship, even if that Citizenship doesn’t necessarily have enfranchisement or suffrage, should be available. Those are entitlements. Not guaranteed privileges. And frankly, there should be an enforced loyalty oath to the State of Israel, along with a series of accountability measures for those who choose to break that Oath. And frankly? All Israeli should be required to take this Loyalty Oath.

  • Eva Stein

    Excellent, bravo, thank you!!

  • SuriW

    Excellent as always…

  • NKaton

    Spot on.

  • Excellent piece.

Algemeiner.com