On Campus Antisemitism, Shai Davidai Kept the Receipts
Error: Contact form not found.
by Uriel Zehavi

Pro-Hamas demonstrators at Columbia University in New York City, US, April 29, 2024. Photo: REUTERS/Caitlin Ochs
On erev Pesach 2024, Shai Davidai walked up to the gates of Columbia University to go into the encampment on his own campus. He had asked for a police escort, and Columbia had told him to hold his event in a “counterprotest area” on another lawn.
At the gate, with Cas Holloway, then the chief operating officer, standing there, he found his university ID had been deactivated.
In American Intellectual Antisemitism he describes meeting Gerald Rosberg, then Columbia’s senior executive vice president, in November 2023 and offering to help the university condemn Hamas the way it had condemned the attacks in Paris and Orlando. Rosberg, he writes, told him Columbia “was not in the business of making moral condemnations.”
In March 2024, he says, not one of the senior officials he asked, Holloway among them, would say Hamas was a terrorist organization, and he published a recording of exactly that.
On Oct. 7, 2024, he followed a march across campus with a body camera and confronted the officials who wouldn’t stop it, Holloway again among them. That evening, by his account, Columbia told his lawyers it was barring him from campus for having “harassed and intimidated” employees, which he denies. To return would mean undergoing three hours of “sensitivity training,” which he accepted, and a gag order, which he wouldn’t sign. He called one chapter “Keep the Receipts,” and he did.
Khymani James, later a spokesperson for the encampment, said in a video he posted that “Zionists don’t deserve to live.”
Columbia’s own task force recorded a Jewish student being told, “It’s such a shame that your people survived in order to commit mass genocide.”
An imam, talking about Davidai in a webinar for Columbia students, said that “if you’re able to take out somebody like that and make an example, that might shut up a hundred more.”
In October 2023, at a vigil on campus, Davidai asked the 30 or so people there to take out their phones, then said: “President Minouche Shafik of Columbia University, you are a coward.” Of the months that followed he writes, “In the ideological standoff between Columbia and Hamas, Hamas had already won.”
He’s a social psychologist, and in the best three pages of the book he takes the ordinary forces in any campus group — wanting to belong, assuming everybody else already agrees, masks that let a crowd do what nobody in it would do alone, small commitments that ratchet into bigger ones — and argues that Students for Justice in Palestine runs on every one of them. It’s an argument that clearly lands. If you’re a parent wondering how a decent 19-year-old ends up chanting for an intifada, start there.
He calls the two Jewish students who sprayed protesters with a novelty fart spray “immature and entirely unacceptable.” His pages on Jewish extremism run from Meir Kahane to Baruch Goldstein and beyond — and he lands on a line I’d cosign: “Extremism, no matter the banner it flies or the religion from which it claims authority, remains extremism.” He has long backed a two-state solution. On that we must differ. I think it’s a delusion that has cost lives, and his case against Columbia doesn’t need it.
The idea on the cover, “American Intellectual Antisemitism,” gets a definition — Jew-hate that “cloaks itself in progressive jargon and academic rhetoric” — and then a roster of Columbia professors, Said, Khalidi, and Massad among them, with a damning quote or two apiece.
The studies he cites show syllabi leaning hard in one direction. The bigger claim, that whole fields “had been shaped by Soviet-era propaganda,” gets a few pages where it could easily handle a few chapters. And for a book with “American” in its title, most of the evidence comes from one campus in Morningside Heights. Though, in fairness, it is reflective of what we see elsewhere and that is where he has the most first-hand knowledge.
Speaking up cost him. He told Congress his home address had been posted online and pictures of his children published, and he has since left Columbia. What he kept is a first-hand account of how its leaders behaved while it was happening. His fixes run from first-year courses co-taught by professors who disagree in front of the students to the $400 million federal freeze he credits with finally moving Columbia.
Disclosure: Shai Davidai opens the Author’s Table, the Atlanta Israel Coalition’s book club, online on Tuesday, Nov. 17, at 8 pm Eastern. It’s free and open to everyone: atlantaisrael.org/events/book-
Uriel Zehavi is Managing Director of the Mitzpe Institute (mitzpe.org) and writes the Israel Brief (israelbrief.com), Monday to Thursday. He is the author of four books, most recently Rooted in Judea: Lives and Law in the Heart of Israel.
Jewish Precincts in Michigan Shifted Heavily Away From Democratic Party, Survey Finds
Herzog to Task Would-Be PM With Forming Gov’t on Sunday as Eisenkot Secures Backing of 67 MKs
Irish Medical Association Pushes Boycott of Israeli Drugmaker Teva, Raising Concerns Over Patient Access to Medicines
What Ordinary Iranians Think of the Democrats’ Midterm Victory
Netanyahu’s Office Hails Imminent Halt in US Military Assistance as Shift ‘From Aid to Partnership’
Holocaust Survivor, 90, Wounded in Bondi Beach Shooting Dies One Year After Massacre
Charity Receiving Prize Money From ‘Celebrity Traitors’ Win Linked to Hamas, Accused of Antisemitism
Iran Sent Nuclear Proposal to the US Via Qatar, Says Senior Iranian Official
Syria Aids Saudi Arabia With Military Advice, Training Amid Houthi Attacks, Sources Say
The US-Israel Alliance Is the Midterms’ Biggest Loser





Charity Receiving Prize Money From ‘Celebrity Traitors’ Win Linked to Hamas, Accused of Antisemitism
Iran Sent Nuclear Proposal to the US Via Qatar, Says Senior Iranian Official
Eisenkot Gets the Names While Netanyahu Keeps the Chair
Netanyahu’s Office Hails Imminent Halt in US Military Assistance as Shift ‘From Aid to Partnership’
Syria Aids Saudi Arabia With Military Advice, Training Amid Houthi Attacks, Sources Say



