How Can Black Lives Matter Support Antisemitism Yet Claim to Promote Justice?
Error: Contact form not found.
by Jonathan Greenberg

Black Lives Matter protesters on July 17, 2013 in Beverly Hills, California. Photo by Jose Lopez, from Black Lives Matter website.
In its new platform, Black Lives Matter (BLM) has, despite the total lack of relevance to its own agenda or interests, thrown whatever heft it has behind the antisemitic movement to Boycott, Divest, and Sanction (BDS) Israel. In doing so, it is inarguably contributing to the campaign to “other” the world’s only Jewish state and, with it, the Jews themselves.
Using the justification that US military aid to Israel “diverts much needed funding from domestic education and social programs,” the platform launches into a ridiculous, one-sided assault on Israel. It accuses Israel of committing “genocide” against the Palestinians (a word rendered utterly meaningless when used to describe a situation in the which the alleged target population increases each year). It labels Israel “an apartheid state,” accuses Israel of arresting four-year-olds “without due process,” and of bulldozing Palestinian homes “to make way for illegal Israeli settlements.” It supports the aims and activities of the BDS movement. It has all the sobriety and nuance one might expect from a play written and performed by the pre-K kids at Hamas summer camp.
These are not, as the Anti-Defamation League’s Jonathan Greenblatt inexplicably phrased it, things about which “we strongly disagree.” We can “strongly disagree” about appropriate marginal tax rates. But we don’t merely “disagree” with rabidly anti-Jewish lies told in furtherance of a movement that exists to single out Jews for discrimination and hatred. We condemn them and reject those who propagate them. “Disagreement” suggests there is a point at which we could reach agreement. How does one meet halfway on “Israel is committing genocide?”
No, these are disqualifying falsehoods that should send any sympathizer of good conscience fleeing for the exits. Even if you agree with some or all other aims of BLM, isn’t lying about and supporting the isolation and demonization of another group of people precisely the opposite of what a movement for equality and justice should be about?
To its credit, the organized Jewish community has thus far risen to the challenge of calling the BDS movement what it is; unadulterated, classical Jew-hatred. Even if BDS didn’t rely on a vile mixture of lies, distortions, and stereotyping (which it does), its singular focus on this conflict – ignoring other, far more violent and globally significant ones – reveals its actual motives. Its use of classical antisemitic tactics such as economic, cultural, and academic collective abuse signals its true target. And its use of classically antisemitic tropes, symbols, and images to depict Israel or Israelis is evidence of a core hatred that, you would think, a movement claiming the mantle of equality and justice would want to avoid.
But BLM presents a unique challenge to a significant subset of the Jewish community that is overwhelmingly leftist, fixated on platitudinous conceptualizations of “social justice,” and in love with the idea of its own virtue (as “virtue” is defined by contemporary leftist politics). It is these people who are least likely to walk away and, as one rabbi already did in the English-language version of Israel’s most anti-Israel newspaper, most likely to give us a clause full of “but” after paying lip-service to the anti-Jewish sections of the platform.
Forget the demands made by BLM and whether or not you agree with many or most of them. They have openly embraced a movement, BDS, the explicit goal of which to is to make a pariah – an “other” – of a minority population comprising no more than .2% of the world. They have trafficked in blatant falsehoods about the national project of those people and done so in ways that, in the long run, complicate international efforts to name and remedy actual genocides. Why would anyone of good will want to be in coalition with such people? What can they possibly claim to stand for that would make it okay to Jew bash?
If BLM wants to be taken seriously – and I hope it does – it should stop doing to Jews what it accuses the United States of doing to our African American neighbors; slandering, ostracizing, debilitating, and bringing violence upon them. Until then, regardless of what else they do, it is they and any who ally with them who should be held at arm’s length.
Jonathan Greenberg is an ordained reform rabbi and the senior vice president of the Haym Salomon Center. An expert in Middle East policy and former staffer at the American Israel Public Affairs Committee, you can follow him @JGreenbergSez. This article was originally published by The Washington Times.
80-Year-Old Israeli Tourist Brutally Attacked in Paris Hotel Room, Suffers Severe Facial Fractures
Northern Ireland Triathlon Bans Israeli Athletes Citing Public Safety Concerns, Support for Palestinians
Kosher Community Fridge in Illinois Dedicated to Murdered Hamas Hostage Hersh Goldberg-Polin
Hillel International, Repair the World Expand Popular Fellowship for Jewish and Non-Jewish Students
US and Allies Push IAEA Board to Report Iran to UN Security Council, Diplomats Say
Israel Says It Has Cleared Hezbollah Fighters From Tunnels Under Key Lebanon Ridge
Why I Built a Publishing House for the Jewish Stories That the Mass Media Refused to Sell
George Clooney, Mark Ruffalo, and the Free Speech Straw Man: How Cowardice Sanitizes Hate
The Lesson That Parshat Nitzavim Has for Each of Us Today
Is the Palestinian Authority Planning to Cancel Elections Again?





Antisemitic Pundits Hasan Piker, Candace Owens Rejected by Overwhelming Majority of Democrats, Republicans, Poll Shows
New Nonprofit Publishing Company for Jewish, Israeli, Zionist Writers Welcomes Submissions
Belgian Authorities Cancel Israeli Soccer Match Over ‘Security Concerns,’ Sparking Outcry
France Tightens Security Around Jewish Sites Ahead of High Holy Days Amid Rising Antisemitic Threats
Why I Built a Publishing House for the Jewish Stories That the Mass Media Refused to Sell



