Who Wants Israel Out of the Golan?
Error: Contact form not found.
by Stephen M. Flatow / JNS.org

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Security Cabinet members get a tour with the Northern Front Command in the Golan Heights on Feb. 6, 2018. Photo: Kobi Gideon/GPO.
JNS.org – America’s recognition of Israeli sovereignty in the Golan Heights is supported by a broad cross-section of the American Jewish community — with the glaring exception of six Jewish ex-State Department officials who always manage to find a way to criticize Israel.
Dennis Ross, Daniel Kurtzer, Richard Haas, Aaron Miller, Martin Indyk, and Indyk’s assistant David Makovsky have all retired from the “peace-processing” business and are now busying themselves posing as Mideast “experts” on talk shows and op-ed pages.
This Gang of Six, who spent so many years trying to convince us that Yasser Arafat was a moderate and that parts of Jerusalem should become the capital of “Palestine,” are now trotting out all the reasons why the United States should not recognize the legitimacy of Israel’s control of the Golan.
Dennis Ross said in an interview with Foreign Policy magazine that the US action will “make it harder” for the Arab world to support peace with Israel. That’s dumb, but at least it’s not weird. His colleagues’ comments, by contrast, have been downright bizarre.
Miller told The Washington Post that the US position “could incentivize” Iran and Hezbollah. Get that? Until now, Iran and Hezbollah didn’t have any incentives to hate America and Israel, but now they will. Brilliant.
Indyk tweeted that Russian President Vladimir Putin “will use this as a pretext to justify Russia’s annexation of Crimea” and “the Israeli right will use it as a pretext for Israel’s annexation of the West Bank.”
So much blather in so few words.
Putin, according to Indyk, needs a “pretext” to justify occupying Crimea; he didn’t have one until now (which didn’t seem to stop him anyway), but now he will have one. Huh?
And, Indyk further imagines, “the Israeli right” will use the Golan action as “a pretext for Israel’s annexation of the West Bank.” Except for the inconvenient fact that the part of the Israeli right that is in the government has never made any attempt to annex it.
Makovsky, for his part, can’t seem to decide whom he hates more — the Israeli prime minister who doesn’t want to give the Golan to Syria or the American president who supports him.
“Bibi was Trump before there was Trump,” Makovsky sputtered in an interview with The Christian Science Monitor. Like Donald Trump, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is “not looking to be a unifying symbol of the state.”
Makovsky apparently thought he was being very clever to point out (because I guess nobody has ever noticed this before) that “both leaders find themselves and their political entourages under investigation by national judicial authorities — Mr. Trump under the cloud of the Mueller investigation.” Too bad for Makovsky that the Mueller report came out before the ink was dry on his Christian Science Monitor interview.
Make no mistake about it: The only reason to oppose American recognition of Israeli control of the Golan is if you oppose Israeli control of the Golan. The Gang of Six spent decades promoting a “peace process” that included giving the Golan Heights to the genocidal Hafez Assad or, since his death, to his genocidal son Bashar.
The latest missiles fired from Gaza into Israel are a painful reminder of what would have happened to the Golan if the Gang of Six had their way. Instead of having a terrorist mini-state only on its southern border, Israel would now have terrorist mini-states on both its southern and northeastern borders. Wonderful.
Because they live in the safe and comfortable suburbs of New York City and Washington, DC, Ross, Indyk, Makovsky, et al, have the luxury of pontificating about the need for Israel to give up territory without ever having to deal personally with the consequences of such withdrawals. But for the Israelis who now live within missile range of Gaza — and who could have been within missile range of the Syrians if they were on the Golan Heights — the consequences are very real.
Stephen M. Flatow, an attorney in New Jersey, is the father of Alisa Flatow, who was murdered in an Iranian-sponsored Palestinian terrorist attack in 1995. His book, A Father’s Story: My Fight for Justice Against Iranian Terror, has just been published.
Anti-Israel Billboard Truck Targets Haley Stevens With Dual-Loyalty Message
‘This Is Our Holy Mission’: Accused Hamas Financier Tied to Official Who Denied Oct. 7 Atrocities on Piers Morgan
Chile, Honduras Restore Ambassadors to Israel After Nearly Two Years of Diplomatic Strains Over Gaza War
Irish Government Removes Israeli-Made Navigation System From €53 Million State Jet in Latest Move Targeting Israel
US Supreme Court Allows For Enforcement of $656 Million Lawsuit Against PA and PLO
Anna Wintour Consulted With Jewish Leaders About Met Gala Honoree John Galliano’s Antisemitic Comments
Israel Secures Its First Medal Win at World Lacrosse Women’s Championship
Palestinian Authority Once Again Says That Martyrdom Is the Highest Ideal in Its Society
Antisemitism Now Speaks in Code — and We Need to Be Aware of Those Symbols and Phrases
We All Want Peace — But a Militarized Palestinian State That Allows Terrorism Will Not Lead to It





Anti-Israel Billboard Truck Targets Haley Stevens With Dual-Loyalty Message
Anna Wintour Consulted With Jewish Leaders About Met Gala Honoree John Galliano’s Antisemitic Comments
US Supreme Court Allows For Enforcement of $656 Million Lawsuit Against PA and PLO
Antisemitism Now Speaks in Code — and We Need to Be Aware of Those Symbols and Phrases
‘This Is Our Holy Mission’: Accused Hamas Financier Tied to Official Who Denied Oct. 7 Atrocities on Piers Morgan



