Ta-Nehisi Coates. Photo: Wiki Commons.

In his latest salvo against the Jewish state, acclaimed American writer Ta-Nehisi Coates dismissed concerns of terrorism as an Israeli excuse to enact a so-called “apartheid” regime and compared the plight of Palestinians to black Americans living in the segregated South during the Jim Crow era.

Coates sat with anti-Israel scholar Noura Erakat at Rutgers University on Monday night to discuss his frustrations about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, the ongoing war in Gaza, and the “false notion” that Israel is a moral state. While describing his 10-day trip to Israel and the West Bank last year, Coates expressed disillusionment over the Jewish state’s policies in the Palestinian territories.

Coates urged journalists to stop relying on “a list of facts” when discussing Israel and instead indulge their “sense of morality.” He argued that members of the media need to display “wisdom”  by embracing the Palestinian cause instead of acknowledging the historical complexities of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. 

The writer also attempted to draw a parallel between the modern Jewish state and the legacy of racism in the United States, asserting that Israeli concerns about Palestinian terrorism “are no different” than anti-black arguments during the height of slavery. He argued that Israeli concerns about the Palestinian terrorist group Hamas, which launched the Gaza war with its invasion of southern Israel last Oct. 7, are “just the language of apartheid” and accused the Jewish state of creating a fictional “narrative” to justify “holding half a population at a level below yourself.”

“You know that during segregation [white people] were like ‘yes, but what about the crime rates?'” Coates said. 

“I used to think, ‘wow, who could be the person who could actually argue for segregation?’ I’m talking to them. I’m talking to them now,” Coates added in reference to supporters of Israel.

Coates then claimed that the dynamic between Israelis and Palestinians represents “that same story of white supremacy globalized.” He claimed that American institutions “have to lie about” Israeli policies on marriage, land use, and freedom of movement, arguing that otherwise US policy toward the Jewish state, the lone democracy in the Middle East, would have to change. 

“You don’t really have the intellectual politics yet to accept that [Israeli apartheid] as fact. The denial almost has to happen,” Coates said. 

The writer also called Zionism “disturbing,” claiming that when Jews established the modern state of Israel they did not “seek to eliminate” the same forms of oppression they suffered from. He asserted that Jews in Israel largely cared to “empower themselves” at the expense of the Palestinians. 

In recent months, Coates has embarked on a media tour to promote his new book , The Message. The book, which details Coates’s singular 10-day trip to Israel in 2023, has come under heavy fire over its biased depiction of the country as an “apartheid” regime and its refusal to acknowledge the various terrorist threats looming over the Jewish state. The book did not mention Hamas, the violence committed against Jews during the First or Second Intifada, or any of the previous peace negotiations between Israel and the Palestinians. 

In October, Coates engaged in a heated on-air debate with Jewish CBS news anchor Tony Dokoupil regarding the content of The Message, in which Dokoupil grilled the writer over his omission of the various terrorist groups threatening Israel and refusal to engage with the pro-Israel perspective. Dokoupil’s pointed questioning of Coates drew outrage from CBS News staffers and much of the broader media landscape.