November 2023: An Israeli soldier helps to provide incubators to Al Shifa Hospital in Gaza. Photo: Screenshot

Thane Rosenbaum’s new book is a breath of fresh air amid the stench of antisemitic slander perpetrated by Jew-hating mobs.

Rosenbaum is a professor at Touro College, a noted interviewer and lecturer, columnist for The Jewish Journal, and author of many books, including the newly-released, Beyond Proportionality: Israel’s Just War in Gaza.

Rosenbaum goes through both the logic and the legalese to demonstrate that Israel is not committing a genocide, and that those who make such erroneous claims are divided into people who do so simply to harm Israel, those who don’t know what the term means, or those creating an alternative definition of the word to try to attack Israel.

Rosenbaum also makes clear that it is a tragedy that Palestinian noncombatants are killed, but that it is difficult to avoid this when Hamas is fighting in civilian areas and using human shields. He also notes there is a possibility that in individual instances, Israel or any country in any war may commit individual war crimes that should be investigated to determine what took place. But Israel never purposefully attacks civilians, as opposed to Hamas, whose primary policy is to target innocent women, children, and men.

Rosenbaum also notes that Hamas has given no figure of how many of its “fighters” or terrorists have been killed, but the ratio of combatant to non-combatant deaths indicates anything but a genocide. He also talks of a friendship with the late Jewish CBS reporter Bob Simon. Rosenbaum recounts that Simon could not tolerate the killing of Palestinian children, which no person of good conscience wants to occur. Asked how to avoid casualties when children are deliberately placed in harm’s way by terrorists, Simon told Rosenbaum he didn’t know how that could be done.

The same is true if you watched as many debates as I have since October 7. When some people say Israel had a right to respond to October 7 but has gone too far, they are often asked what combatant to non-combatant ratio would have been acceptable. Usually, they have no answer. The alternative, as Rosenbaum notes, is that by not seeking to defeat Hamas, Israel would be saying that the Hamas blueprint of murdering and raping civilians, and also taking hostages, should be repeated all over the world — because it worked.

In order to win a war, quite often you kill more people than the other side has killed. This has been true since the beginning of war, and does not mean a war is genocide. Rosenbaum correctly points out that rather than playing with “house” money, Hamas is playing with Qatari and Iranian money, and while Israel makes sure nearly every Israeli home has a bomb shelter, Hamas does not allow its citizens to seek protection in tunnels, claiming most absurdly that it is the UN’s responsibility to provide protection.

He also correctly notes that virtually nothing has been done to stop the spread of antisemitic vitriol on college campuses, which has been fueled by professors who talk about intersectionality and the oppressor vs. oppressed mentality.

One of the important points Rosenbaum makes (which you will never see on Joe Rogan or Piers Morgan’s shows) is that Professor Salman al Dayah, the former dean of the faculty of Sharia law at the Islamic University of Gaza, issued a fatwa, or religious edict, against Hamas’ Oct. 7 attack for “violating Islamic principles governing jihad.” Why his voice has not been amplified, or there have not been many others like him is tragic.

But the anti-Israel movement seeks to take away all agency from Hamas and Palestinians, and blame Israel and Prime Minister Netanyahu for everything negative that has occurred. In his most sober moment, Rosenbaum writes: “I think it is high time for Israel to stop apologizing for fighting a war in self-defense. It has to stop listening to people who have never been to war, like Joe Biden, Antony Blinken and Barack Obama, who have no understanding about the Middle East where Jews have always faced murderous enemies.”

Rosenbaum’s book is a crucial read at this time, and while many who need to read it may not, if at least some can, it will be extremely worthwhile in the asymmetrical battle Israel and Jews face against blood libels and lies geared to turning the world into Jew haters.

The author is a writer based in New York.