The JTA Gets it Wrong on Settlements

July 28, 2013 7:54 pm 12 comments

View of the Har Homa settlement in the West Bank. Photo: James Emery.

A recent Jewish Telegraphic Agency (JTA) news brief quoted Christine Quinn’s campaign as saying she “believes the West Bank is a disputed territory and that the Israelis and Palestinians must sit down and negotiate a solution.”

According to the JTA, “Quinn’s position runs counter to that of the U.S. government, which considers the West Bank Israeli-occupied territory.” Actually, Quinn was restating a long-held U.S. position. If the status of territories weren’t legitimately disputed, there would be nothing to negotiate.

No Arab entity held clear title and exercised peaceful sovereignty over the territory prior to the 1967 Six-Day War. If one had, Israel’s conquest would have been an act of aggression and it would have been obligated to clear out decades ago.

But the ’67 War was one of Israeli self-defense. The territory known as Judea and Samaria during the British Mandate had been illegally occupied by Jordan during Israel’s 1948-1949 War of Independence, renamed the West Bank and used to attack Israel. Hence the wording of UN Security Council Resolution 242, written by American and British diplomats not long after the Six-Day War.

U.S. Undersecretary of State Eugene Rostow, one of Resolution 242’s drafters, explained that Washington’s position “was sharply drawn, and rested on a critical provision of the Armistice Agreements of 1949. Those agreements provided in each case that the Armistice Demarcation Line ‘is not to be construed in any sense as a political or territorial boundary, and is delineated without prejudice to rights, claims or positions of either party to the Armistice as regards ultimate settlement of the Palestine question.’”

That means the status of the territories, until resolved through negotiations, is disputed.  Later Arab-Israeli diplomacy, including Israeli-Palestinian agreements reached in the 1990s as part of the Oslo process, and the 2003 “road map” advanced by the “quartet” of the United States, Russia, the UN, and European Union, takes 242 as a reference point.

That “the U.S. government … considers the West Bank Israel-occupied territory,” as JTA reports, doesn’t put candidate Quinn into conflict with Washington either. The United States doesn’t consider the Israeli occupation illegal any more than post-World War II Allied occupation of Germany was illegal.  Having gained the territories in self-defense, Israel is the legitimate military occupational authority. Among other things, it is obligated to see to the basic health and welfare of the residents until the lands’ disputed status is resolved through the required diplomacy. Those responsibilities are now administered primarily by the Palestinian Authority—as a result of previous Israeli-Palestinian negotiations.

The JTA also claimed that “successive U.S. administrations have opposed Israeli Jewish settlement construction in the West Bank as unlawful and obstructive to a two-state solution.” Successive U.S. administrations have claimed that construction of Jewish settlements in the West Bank obstructs a negotiated conclusion. But only the Carter administration, reversed by the Reagan White House, declared building illegal.

International law supports the settlements, anti-Israeli propaganda and the latest European Union sanctions against them notwithstanding. As CAMERA has noted previously, the San Remo Treaty of 1920, in which the victorious World War I allies dealt with the remnants of the defeated Ottoman Turkish Empire, created an entity called Palestine along both sides of the Jordan River. The powers intended it as the land on which Great Britain would turn its 1917 Balfour Declaration from aspiration to reality, assisting the Zionist movement in re-establishing the Jewish national home.

The Franco-British Boundary Convention of 1920 demarcated the French mandate for what would become Syria and Lebanon from that of the British in Palestine. This was in part to prepare for the Jewish state. Article 6 of the League of Nations’ 1922 Palestine Mandate encouraged “close Jewish settlement” on the land west of the Jordan River. Only west of the river because Great Britain, in the same year, unilaterally severed Transjordan (Jordan) from Palestine.

The Anglo-American Convention of 1924 saw the United States endorse British administration of the remaining Mandate lands, so long as London helped bring a Jewish state into being. The 1945 UN Charter, Chapter XII, Article 80, continues Jewish rights recognized under the Mandate. It protects “the rights whatsoever of any states or any peoples or the terms of existing international instruments.

The Obama Administration has objected to what it terms the “illegitimate” nature of “continued settlement activity.” That is new language, not the words of “successive U.S. administrations.”

The New York City mayor’s race will sort itself out. One hopes the same happens with JTA’s reporting of Israeli-Palestinian diplomacy.

Eric Rozenman is Washington director of CAMERA, the 65,000-member, Boston-based Committee for Accuracy in Middle East Reporting in America.

12 Comments

  • And don’t forget the Jerusalem Embassy Act [of 1995], the law of the land [USA], which states that Jerusalem is part of Israel. Notwithstanding the dolts of our always-wrong State Dep’t.

  • You can bury your heads in the sand, you can play games with the names, you can occupy and abuse the people who have been living on the land for three thousand years,and more, as they don’t seem to have left ,like others might want to suggest to us. You can pretend that you have departed this land for three thousand years(so you claim), you can claim the old Mighty ,being a Real Estate agent and he has the authority to deed you a land ownership, which is unheard of in the realistic logical state of minds ,unless somebody took hallucinating drugs. Playing all this games and intimidating people ,countries and bribing others will not change the facts ,There are and always have been people on this land ,and the majority of them were not of the Jewish faith, and if they were, maybe they converted. You try to call them what you wish, but they happen to call themselves Palestinians. Till ,you come clean and recognize that and stop to sabotage their lives and existence, your dream of being rewarded for your blatant aggression will never materialize ,and your desire for a legitimate place to call your own, is not done by theft and displacement of others. The whole world know they have the right to the land they lived on for many many generations. Just because you have few Christian evangelist fanatics, and some Racist European and Americans Zionists whom are religious zealots, and blinded to everything else ,but the coming of the Messiah/Jehovah, as to convert the Jews , and kill the ones who don’t convert, or from the Jewish fanatics, their own Messiah will come and rule Israel for a thousand years, and so on and so fourth, is just the most destructive notions to humanity that i have ever heard of. What Gods are these and what predictions we are putting out there? There should be something better than this. I did not forgot the Muslim Mahdi, so you racists,Islam Phobes out there don’t start jumping ,up and down. Religious fanatics, come in all shapes and colors, and if God, who you say, created us , why would he wish upon us such a doomes day ? As sinners? He ,I thought created us ! If we kill each other ,He/She will redeem us? There is a lot of work ahead of us, just to sound simi-sane.
    Please lets cut the BSh..t. and be realistic. games and Hasbaras and lies and PR campaigns are just not working that well. Facts and truth are surfacing all the times and history have shown us that. I for one want the Jewish people to have a home land and live in security, but not on the account of another people, the Palestinians, or any people for that matter Jews or not Jews. According to some historical data gathered by an author, the Jews have suffered enough. They have been chased out of 75 places or countries in the last three thousands years or so. So, what are they trying to say now ,if it was 75, it will not make a difference to make 76 ? or, never again, just means that we have Nuclear bombs and WMD, if the Messiah does not bring Armageddon, then we will with the bombs? What is the deal? Can some one please explain to me? We all need to wake up and become realistic in sharing this earth and the space on it. Palestine, Israel . Isratine? what ever, just stop this none sense, and try to co- exist.

  • Larry Levine

    The “West Bank” of Israel, the “Settlements”, or Jerusalem are neither Occupied Territory, or Disputed Territory!

    They are all UNDISPUTED ISRAELI TERRITORY, and all the world’s politicians, mayoral candidates of New York, the President of the United States, and the European Union must come to this understanding if any sort of peace in the region can be achieved.

    The present “Peace Talks” are a sham, and can produce no positive results. Israel gives everything and the “Palestinians” give nothing but murder.

    Albert Einstein once gave a definition of insanity: he said it’s “…doing the same thing over and over again expecting different results.”

  • Elliot J. Stamler

    Here in NYC all politicians with one glaring exception will say whatever they think will help get Jewish votes. (The one exception was City Councilman Charles Barron, recently defeated in a Democratic congressional primary, and who is a rip-roaring black Marxist communist, anti-white racist and thorough-going Jew-hater.) Nobody here cares what our local candidates for municipal office think about foreign policy and certainly nobody cares about what Christine Quinn thinks. We have enough serious local issues to contene with.

  • A very well written, succinct explanation, which will help when explaining the real facts to others.
    Thank you,
    JB Silver

  • “No Arab entity held clear title and exercised peaceful sovereignty over the territory prior to the 1967 Six-Day War. If one had, Israel’s conquest would have been an act of aggression and it would have been obligated to clear out decades ago.” Artcohn is absolutely right. The Balfour Declaration granted the West Bank (and Gaza and even Sinai!) to the Jews and they have every right to be there.

  • Raymond in DC

    All that the author states here, and more, is covered at length in the Levy Report, produced by a commission appointed by Netanyahu. The Report’s thrust, which provides both the background and the legal claims Israel holds regarding the territories, is deemed too politically sensitive to be officially accepted, because Israel isn’t allowed to have rights and claims, or is at least expected to keep silent about them. Only it’s enemies are deemed to have claims, even if they’re bogus.

  • And there were American politicians who, in 1936, traveled to then Mandate Palestine to make sure the US was upholding its commitment to establish a Jewish National Home in all of western Palestine, visited the Temple Mount and the Western Wall to assure Jewish rights and even later, in 1948, stood forthrightly for Jewish legitimate demands (see: http://myrightword.blogspot.co.il/2010/11/us-american-relations-in-1936-and-in.html )

  • . The territory was known as Judea and Samaria not only during the British Mandate, but also prior to the Mandate. My father in law went to school in Gallicia, then a province of Austria-Hungary. I have his school atlas, published in 1914, which names the areas west of the Jordan River as Samaria and Judea.
    Of course the names go back to biblical times. The Anchor Bible volume on “Samuel” has a map of the area controlled by King Saul that is virtually identical to that now called “the West Bank”

  • Steve MacLeod

    Thank you for your article We certainly do not get the facts in our news. I am happy that our Prime Minister has chosen to deliberately support Israel yet I am a bit uncertain having our good guy disguise change slightly. We in the west have been naive about the Arabs and Islam.
    May the God of Abraham Issac and Jacob bless this nation and may his people awaken to his existence again.

  • We have a right to hope.

Leave a Reply

Please note: comments may be published in the Algemeiner print edition.


Current day month ye@r *

More...

  • Music US & Canada Lady Gaga Accepts ADL Award: ‘Your Philosophies Are So in Line With Ours’ (VIDEO)

    Lady Gaga Accepts ADL Award: ‘Your Philosophies Are So in Line With Ours’ (VIDEO)

    Pop superstar Lady Gaga on Thursday accepted an award from Jewish human rights group the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) on behalf of her Born This Way Foundation, which strives to combat bullying among young people. “Your philosophies are so in line with ours,” she said of the ADL upon accepting the Making a Difference Award in a videotaped message, which was shown at a ceremony in New York City. “We want to help young people know that their feelings and who they are on [...]

    Read more →
  • Music Personalities At 80, Singer-Songwriter Leonard Cohen’s Jewish Roots ‘Very Much Intact’

    At 80, Singer-Songwriter Leonard Cohen’s Jewish Roots ‘Very Much Intact’

    JNS.org – Eighty years young, Leonard Cohen fits many descriptions—singer, songwriter, poet, novelist, monk. From his Jewish upbringing in Canada to the present day, Cohen has always explored his spiritual side. This month, the singer-songwriter released the CD (May 12) and iTunes (on May 8 of this year) formats of his latest album, Can’t Forget: A Souvenir of the Grand Tour, which features live recordings from his world tours in 2012 and 2013. Last year, Cohen’s Popular Problems was voted by Rolling Stone [...]

    Read more →
  • Europe Sports FIFA Head Says Israel Should Not be Booted From World Soccer Association

    FIFA Head Says Israel Should Not be Booted From World Soccer Association

    JNS.org – Fédération Internationale de Football Association (FIFA) head Sepp Blatter said during a meeting with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu that contrary to Palestinian complaints, Israel has not violated any FIFA statutes and should not be suspended from international soccer’s governing body. “We should not come to one federation saying we will exclude them,” said Blatter, the Jerusalem Post reported. “If the national association is fulfilling its obligations then there is no need to intervene,” he said. “I’m on a [...]

    Read more →
  • Featured Middle East Sports Jewish Rights Group Slams Palestinian Attempts to Suspend Israel From FIFA

    Jewish Rights Group Slams Palestinian Attempts to Suspend Israel From FIFA

    Jewish human rights group the Simon Wiesenthal Center (SWC) said on Tuesday it was “appalled” by a Palestinian Football Association initiative to suspend Israel from FIFA, calling it another “front waged in the context of the Palestinian Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions (BDS) campaign.” “We are appalled at the temerity of the Palestinan Football Association (PFA) demand that FIFA suspend Israel at your forthcoming Congress in Zurich,” wrote the group’s international relations director, Dr. Shimon Samuels, in a letter to FIFA President Joseph [...]

    Read more →
  • Theater US & Canada Star of Auschwitz Thriller Says ‘God Was Holding the Hand of Every Jew in the Gas Chamber’ (VIDEO)

    Star of Auschwitz Thriller Says ‘God Was Holding the Hand of Every Jew in the Gas Chamber’ (VIDEO)

    The lead actor in Son of Saul, an Auschwitz thriller featured at this year’s Cannes Film Festival, told the UK’s The Guardian that he believes God was “holding the hand” of each Jew who died in the Nazi gas chambers during the Holocaust. “I do not for one nanosecond like to pretend that God is off the hook. He could and should have stopped it at a much earlier stage,” Géza Röhrig, 48, said. ”But I would not be able to get [...]

    Read more →
  • Music Backstreet Boys Singer Howie D Gushes Over Masada During Israel Trip

    Backstreet Boys Singer Howie D Gushes Over Masada During Israel Trip

    Backstreet Boys singer Howie Dorough took to Instagram on Tuesday to marvel about climbing the famed Masada fortress with his band during their visit to Israel, where they will perform this week for the first time. The group’s second day of sightseeing in the Jewish state included the Masada hike, and taking a mud bath at the Dead Sea. A picture from the band’s official Twitter page shows the five singers covered in mud. While relaxing in the Dead Sea, [...]

    Read more →
  • Book Reviews US & Canada ‘Arms and the Dudes:’ New Book, Film Detail How Ex-Orthodox Yeshiva Guys Became Top Suppliers for Afghan Army

    ‘Arms and the Dudes:’ New Book, Film Detail How Ex-Orthodox Yeshiva Guys Became Top Suppliers for Afghan Army

    A new book and its upcoming film adaptation tell the true story of how three former yeshiva students who habitually smoked marijuana scored a $300 million contract from the U.S. government to supply weapons for the Afghan Army, the New York Daily News reported on Sunday. Arms and the Dudes details how the Miami Beach potheads became “the most unlikely gunrunners in history,” according to the book’s author, investigative reporter Guy Lawson. The tale begins with Efraim Diveroli, nephew of [...]

    Read more →
  • Blogs Theater Natalie Portman: Israel-Themed ‘A Tale of Love and Darkness’ Not Political

    Natalie Portman: Israel-Themed ‘A Tale of Love and Darkness’ Not Political

    JNS.org – Natalie Portman, who directs and stars in the new Hebrew-language film adaptation of author Amos Oz’s A Tale of Love and Darkness, says that despite Oz’s record as a vocal left-wing critic of Israel, her film is not political. Like the book on which it is based, Portman’s film is about a young boy at the time of the founding of the state of Israel. “I think the movie is very much about this very particular, specific family story. Of [...]

    Read more →



Sign up now to receive our regular news briefs.