Tuesday, November 29th | 5 Kislev 5783

April 28, 2015 12:19 am

Why I Miss George W. Bush

avatar by Shmuley Boteach


George W. Bush. Photo: White House.

Hearing President Bush speak on Saturday night at a Republican Jewish Coalition event in Las Vegas sent me into a reverie of nostalgia. The President was in top form, speaking lucidly and compellingly about the threat from Iran and ISIS. So this is what it’s like to hear a world leader speak with moral conviction about evil. Oh yes, I remember this.

And yes, I know, I know. President Bush made plenty of mistakes. In his speech he fessed up to a few. But he also gave the world moral direction and served as the scourge of tyrants. What a change from the double-speak of the current White House where evil is an entity to make deals with.

But given that our world is in such bad shape, why doesn’t the former President ever speak up? He addressed this question directly. “The office of the Presidency is more important than any particular occupant,” he said. He wanted to preserve the respect for the office by not second-guessing his successor. He wanted to give him the latitude to operate without a predecessor second-guessing him.

I only partially agreed. That all works if your successor doesn’t trash you constantly. But given that President Obama has blamed President Bush for every global mishap, why would President Bush just turn the other cheek and take it? Does he not realize that it’s not only he who is being attacked, but his principles?

Related coverage

November 29, 2022 11:47 am

What a New Middle East Scholars Survey Says About the Campus Climate for Jews

On January 25, 2016, Giulio Regeni, a 28-year-old Italian graduate student conducting dissertation fieldwork on Egypt’s trade unions, was snatched...

President Obama has used President Bush’s legacy to excuse doing nothing as the world goes to hell in a hand basket. “Don’t do stupid stuff,” is the essential foreign policy creed President Obama articulated at last year’s West Point commencement – by which he meant: Don’t do the kinds of things President Bush did. Don’t attack other countries, even if, as in Syria, 200,000 people have been murdered by a dictator. Don’t promote democracy, even if exporting freedom is a core American value.

Through all this President Bush has been silent. But his silence has come at a price, that price being his reputation and the ideals he believes in, many of which are ideals I believe in.

President Bush said at the RJC that it does not much matter, seeing as history, rather than political spin, will determine a President’s true legacy. That’s probably true. But only in the long term. But right now, when the world needs a far more engaged America in order that it not become a jungle, it’s inaccurate. Rather, President Bush should be defending an activist foreign-policy agenda that does not allow Iran to remain nuclear and does not allow Islamist terror to run roughshod over the Middle East.

Such defense need not be articulated as a criticism of President Obama. President Bush need not trash his successor. I agree that doing so would be in appropriate. But would it really be so intrusive if President Bush condemned the wholesale slaughter of innocent Arabs at the hands of Bashar Assad? Would it be seen as criticism of 44 if 43 spoke of the need to utterly destroy ISIS? Would it be a betrayal of his successor if President Bush praised Prime Minister Netanyahu’s efforts to rally the world against Iran obtaining nuclear weapons?

I can only speak for myself.

I thoroughly enjoyed hearing President Bush. And I missed him. He was funny, direct, candid, and utterly relaxed. He spoke with eloquence about the need for America to assert itself in world affairs lest really bad people fill the void.

Perhaps he was so relaxed because he knew he was speaking to a closed-door event, although he acknowledged that these days there is no such thing. And indeed, his comments appeared the very next day in The New York Times. Or perhaps he spoke so convincingly because he knew he was among friends, people who admired him – especially his unshakable attachment to Israel, which was another point he discussed.

Asked by his former Press Secretary Ari Fleischer why he was so attached to Israel, he said people were mistaken if they surmised the reason was only religious. Yes, he was a born-again Christian. Yes, he read the Hebrew Bible daily and therefore felt knowledgeable of, and attached to, ancient Jewish history. All that of course accounted in part for his closeness to Israel. But it was only a small part of it. The larger part of it, he said, was American values. Israel is a democracy. The world cannot be made safe for peace unless it is democratic. Israel and the United States shared core values. Israel’s neighbors do not.

Perhaps most interesting was President Bush’s comments about Vladimir Putin. Yes, he acknowledged, he had once said that he had peered into President Putin’s eyes and had seen his soul. He explained that he had made the comment directly after speaking to Putin about his mother and her religious faith. He said that Putin had touched him deeply with the affectionate way he described his mother.

But all that was undone by an incident that displayed Putin’s deep male insecurities and his I-win-you-lose mentality.

After Putin had met the President’s dog Barney, he had commented how small and weak the dog appeared. Later, when President Bush visited the Russian President at his Dacha in Russia, Putin showed off an enormous and powerful dog. “He’s much bigger and more powerful than Barney.”

Any man who had to show off his dog was bigger and better had serious issues of insecurity, the President said. Good thing, President Bush continued, we were talking about dogs and not something else.

Shmuley Boteach, “America’s Rabbi,” whom the Washington Post calls “the most famous Rabbi in America,” is founder of The World Values Network and is the international best-selling author of 30 books, including The Fed-up Man of Faith: Challenging God in the Face of Tragedy and Suffering. Follow him on Twitter @RabbiShmuley.

The opinions presented by Algemeiner bloggers are solely theirs and do not represent those of The Algemeiner, its publishers or editors. If you would like to share your views with a blog post on The Algemeiner, please be in touch through our Contact page.

Share this Story: Share On Facebook Share On Twitter

Let your voice be heard!

Join the Algemeiner


This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.