Should Egypt’s Morsi Stay or Go?
Error: Contact form not found.
by Daniel Pipes

One television station called itself the "Voice of Tahrir Square" and simultaneously showed scenes from there and seven other cities.
I was not present in Egypt yesterday, June 30, but I watched some of the wall-to-wall broadcasts on Egyptian television of packed squares and streets across the country, of gesticulating orators, defensive government spokesmen, and articulate commentators. The demonstrations across the country were, by consensus estimates, 7 to 10 times larger than the biggest anti-Mubarak crowds in early 2011. They dwarfed street rebellions such other those in Iran in 1979 or Peking in 1989. Simply put, they were probably the largest political demonstration in human history.
I was moved by the humanity of the crowds and (sometimes despite myself) thrilled by their centrism and constructive outlook. Who could have imagined a mere year ago, when Mohamed Morsi supposedly won the presidential election, that this massive Rebellion would be served up as his anniversary present, as he cowered behind walls in a distant palace?
The day also raised two policy thoughts:
The American role: Time and again, commentators brought up the vital importance of the U.S. government in the drama of the day. One person, for example, counted four main actors: the demonstrators, the president, the military, and Washington. Crowds expressed anti-Obama feelings; at least one much-photographed bi-lingual sign provided an English translation: “OBAMA SUPPORTS TERRORISM.” (Morsi’s critics routinely call him a terrorist.)
The message from Egypt was crystal clear: It’s time for the administration to stop coddling Morsi and to get behind the millions of protestors. But will the geniuses in the White House, the State Department, and Embassy Cairo hear? Obama’s initial response today was tepid but at least mildly in the right direction: “Our commitment to Egypt has never been around any particular individual or party. Our commitment has been to a process.”
Whither Morsi: Awesome and satisfying as the June 30 rejection of Muslim Brotherhood rule was, what should come next is not obvious. Emotionally, I want Morsi and his foul crew gone as soon as possible from the corridors of power. Tactically, however, I fear that, once they are dispatched, the politically obtuse military leadership will likely muck things up and the opposition will be unable to unify or to handle the looming economic disaster. If Egypt’s pain is to have benefit, it would be by discrediting Islamism. For that to happen, it’s probably better that Morsi linger in office and be ascribed responsibility for the hunger and other disasters ahead.
I write this with trepidation, as always when the heart and mind disagree.
This article was originally published by the National Review.
Iran’s Nuclear Debate Erupts Into Political Storm as Top Officials Question Cost of Enrichment
J.D. Vance Addresses Republican Jewish Coalition Amid Tense Relations With Jewish Community, Draws Mixed Reviews
Belgian Airline Workers Threaten Strike Over Mandatory Tel Aviv Flights, Citing Security and ‘Ethical’ Concerns
California Legislature Passes Bill to Become First US State to Recognize Jewish Identity as an Ethnicity
Gal Gadot Explains Why She Wouldn’t Do a Third ‘Wonder Woman’ Movie
Israeli-Ukrainian Dancer Adele Zaikman Becomes Newest Professional on ‘Dancing With the Stars’ Season 35
Deni Avdija Explains Why He Couldn’t Compete in FIBA World Cup Qualifiers for Team Israel
Iran Defiant as Bessent Says US Likely to Announce Bank Sanctions This Week
Israel Captures Head of Hamas’ Internal Security Service in Gaza Raid
The Iraqi Disarmament Scam: How Baghdad Launders Iran’s Proxy Empire






Once Again, Palestinian Authority Refuses to Condemn Terrorist Attacks Against Civilians
The New York Times’ Islamic Republic of Economics
California Legislature Passes Bill to Become First US State to Recognize Jewish Identity as an Ethnicity
Deni Avdija Explains Why He Couldn’t Compete in FIBA World Cup Qualifiers for Team Israel
Israel Captures Head of Hamas’ Internal Security Service in Gaza Raid



