Why Doesn’t Anyone Compare Baltimore to Hamas Police?
Now that police beatings are in the headlines again, it is fashionable for so-called progressives to equate the police with Israeli soldiers – as if Israeli police and soldiers are the quintessential example of police brutality.
From The Guardian:
David Simon, the creator of The Wire, has again weighed in on unrest in his adopted city of Baltimore, turning his frustration from the protesters to the “army of occupation” of the city’s police.
They were collecting bodies, treating corner folk and citizens alike as an Israeli patrol would treat Gaza, or as the Afrikaners would have treated Soweto back in the day. They’re an army of occupation. And once it’s that, then everybody’s the enemy.
Related coverageSeptember 20, 2017 4:35 pm
I will bet anything that the lowest private in the IDF in Gaza last summer would act with more restraint towards those trying to kill him than David Simon would. I would also bet that the same private knows more about international law and the laws of armed conflict in protecting civilians than David Simon does.
To use Israel as the standard of brutality is not only an obscene slander, but it shows how successful anti-Israel propaganda is, and how open and susceptible otherwise intelligent people are to being manipulated by the haters.
Even more absurd is that the standard for treating Gazan civilians like subhumans comes not from Israel –but from those Israel was fighting..
This AFP report from yesterday will get about 1/10th of one percent of the coverage that stories about Israel do:
Police in the Hamas-run Gaza Strip beat and arrested protesters on Wednesday at a youth rally in the north of the besieged coastal territory, an AFP correspondent said.
More than 400 demonstrators gathered in Shujaiyeh, a neighborhood in eastern Gaza City that was razed during a July-August war between Hamas and Israel, urging reconstruction and calling for an end to intra-Palestinian division.
This undated video shows how much restraint Hamas shows towards civilians in Gaza.
It is not easy to find videos like this on YouTube in English. And coverage of daily Hamas brutality is minuscule compared to the much exaggerated, out of context and often fictional stories of Israeli law enforcement brutality.
Meanwhile, videos showing Israeli police helping Arabs – videos that completely destroy the lazy assumptions that journalists and writers like Simon make – are even more rare: This is not a coincidence. Journalists are lazy in accepting the fiction of widespread Israeli brutality, and anything that shows that to be false is naturally going to be buried because it is too hard to explain the reality to readers compared to reporting-by-meme.
This video shows an army patrol reviving an Arab in Hebron whose heart stopped after he was electrocuted.
Clearly, these soldiers are frantically trying to save the life of someone that David Simon thinks they passionately loathe.
People like Simon are well meaning – and are literally clueless that they are being brainwashed every day by an army of anti-Israel activists and a complicit media that discards even the appearance of objectivity while willing to accept and repeat the narrative of hate without question.
But when David Simon writes his own analysis for the public, he has the same responsibility as any journalist to get his facts right. His being exposed to lies for decades is not an excuse to skip fact-checking.
The irony is that much of the audience for these lazy reporters want to know the truth, even if Simon doesn’t. There is a reason that the most popular video I’ve ever uploaded, with 400,000 views, shows IDF soldiers acting kindly towards Arab children.
UPDATE: Simon changed the text in his original article from Gaza to the West Bank. I suppose I could link to more videos of Israeli patrols playing soccer with Palestinian youths, but clearly he stands by his account of how Israel treats Arabs like dirt, and that turns him from someone who one could assume was duped by the media into someone who is doing the duping.