Friday, March 23rd | 7 Nisan 5778


Be in the know!

Get our exclusive daily news briefing.

July 12, 2015 11:42 am

Israeli Kids in Detroit Detained for Refusing to Dine With Father Released (VIDEO)

avatar by Alina Dain Sharon /

Email a copy of "Israeli Kids in Detroit Detained for Refusing to Dine With Father Released (VIDEO)" to a friend
Friends and community members protest the jailing of the three Tsimhoni children by a Detroit judge. Photo: Screenshot from YouTube.

Friends and community members protest the jailing of the three Tsimhoni children by a Detroit judge. Photo: Screenshot from YouTube. – A recent ruling in a divorce case between two Israeli parents living in Detroit has escalated into national news. On June 24, a judge sentenced three children to juvenile detention for violating an order to have lunch with their father. In theory, the children, who are between the ages of 9 and 14, could have remained at the “Children’s Village” juvenile detention facility until they turn 18. For the youngest daughter, this would have meant almost a decade in detention. On Friday, however, the judge released the three children and sent them to a summer camp instead.

Details of the entire original episode remain someone sketchy. Omer Tsimhoni works as an engineer for General Motors and his ex-wife is a physician. The couple has been engaged in a custody dispute over their three children since deciding to get a divorce shortly after the father wanted his family to move back to Israel.

According to the Detroit Free Press, “Eibschitz-Tsimhoni first filed for divorce after plans to relocate to Israel when her husband, a former Israeli Air Force pilot, accepted a job offer there in late 2008, federal court documents in Detroit show.”

On June 24, the children refused to honor a court-ordered lunch meeting with their father, with the eldest son, Liam, stating that the father is “violent and… I saw him hit my mom and I’m not going to talk to him.”

The father has denied this allegation in an interview with the New York Observer, in which he also accused his ex-wife of sabotaging his relationship with his children.

The court hearing then took a strange turn. Judge Lisa Gorcyca took the father’s side by calling Liam a “defiant, contemptuous young man,” for failing to heed her order to have a relationship with his father, whom she called “a good man.”

“You’re supposed to have a high IQ, which I’m doubting right now,” Gorcyca told the boy. “You have no manners.”

Court transcripts also show Gorcyca threatening the three children with juvenile detention.

“God gave you a brain. He expects you to use it. You are not your big, defiant brother who’s living in jail. Do you want to live in jail?” she told his 9-year-old sister.

“You want to have your birthdays in Children’s Village? Do you like going to the bathroom in front of people? Is your bed soft and comfortable at home? I’ll tell you this, if you two don’t have a nice lunch with your dad and make this up to your dad, you’re going to come back here (after lunch) and I’m going to have the deputies take you to Children’s Village,” added the judge.

Gorcyca also claimed that the mother had brainwashed her children against the father by comparing her behavior to Charles Manson. Shortly afterward, the judge made good on her threat by sentencing all three children to be sent to the juvenile detention center, where she ordered them to be “kept away from each other as much as possible” and banned their mother from visiting.

Since the original ruling, some people have come out to clarify that it may not be as outlandish as it seems. Public relations executive Ronn Torossian, a friend of Tsimhoni’s current wife, said that “this is not a case of, ‘These kids would not have a meal with their father so they were sent away. That’s ignoring five years in court. … There’s been a lot of inappropriate conduct by the mother throughout the years,” the Huffington Post reported.

Nevertheless, public outrage over the case has been steadily growing in the national media, with one blogger writing that the judge went too far by punishing the children for their parents’ mistakes.

“The court transcript reads like a five page tantrum being thrown by a family court judge,” the blogger wrote, according to Haaretz.

“There are adults who commit felonies who aren’t sentenced to three or four years incarceration,” said Mark Honeyman, a friend of the Israeli family, Fox News reported.

Stating her reasoning for the decision ultimately to release the children on Friday, Gorcyca said “the court agrees with the children’s guardian’s recommendation as to the best interests of the children. The court finds that is in the children’s best interests to grant the father’s and the guardian ad litem’s motion to allow the children to attend summer camp. Children’s Village is to facilitate the transportation.”

It remains unclear what will happen to the children at the end of the summer and whether the custody battle moves forward.

Share this Story: Share On Facebook Share On Twitter Email This Article

Let your voice be heard!

Join the Algemeiner
  • Vanessa

    This case just gets scarier when you read the transcripts. Everything about the judge screams dysfunctional. It’s almost as if she knows the father or maybe someone on his legal team outside of court. I have never seen a judge so corrupted add to say either party is right all the time and that any party is “in charge” of the case. That shows a lack of impartiality on her part. The children said no and we need to see a judge that respects that, not theirs kids in jail and insults them. She’s obviously not in this for the best interest of the children.

  • Karla

    Sounds like the judge is the one with the issues. She seems to be infatuated with the father. I went through a divorce and all the women involved gravitated toward my ex. He was a very seductive man, and that is where the problem lay. He was sexually attractive to women who where in the market. He had many affairs and flaunted it. He even forced himself on some young women in our employ who did not want it. I got my divorce and am very happy. He has been married five times and was not faithful to any of them. This judge is probably looking at the husband as a love interest. He probably has that same beast dwelling in him. It is a demon of lust. Poor children are being abused by the court and their father in the process.

  • Grace

    The book of Malachi says that the “Jehovah” hates divorce or separation, cos in creation, he created for man and woman to live together and bring up a godly seed. whenever there is a separation/divorce, you can see the results. mostly where there are children, the effects are much more felt, as children are used as bargaining chips to get the maximum or inflict maximum pain on one of the parties. it is terrible and should be avoided at all costs and everyone should work towards helping the family come together.

  • Lauren Goldman

    That should read; . . . should NOT be allowed . . .

  • Lauren Goldman

    The children witnessed their father hitting their mother. My stepfather regularly hit my mother (6’3″ vs. 5’4″). Life with him was 15 1/2 years of hell for my mother and me. Yet, everyone thought of good old John as a solid family man. If my mother had divorced him when I was young, I would not have had lunch with him. So, the presumption of this judge to tell the children how they should behave toward their abusive father is the epitome of arrogance. Apparently, she has some personal axe to grind and should be allowed to preside over family issues.

  • This judge sounds peculiar to me: ‘took the father’s side’? Is that allowed or are judges supposed to be impartial? So they were not supposed to see either father or mother or one another in children’s village? Or did the judge provide for father but not for mother to visit them? Why were the children not allowed to elaborate on what they’d experienced between their parents? And when the holidays are over, is this judge still going to try and force them to have respect & love for their father? Those are things to be earned, not compelled. Does she realise that she might be influencing them into hating instead of merely disliking (& wanting to ignore) their father?

  • Enufizenuf

    About 20% of the Judges in the US are totally unfit to sit on the bench.