Crossing the Line: When Criticism of Israel Becomes Antisemitic
In the wake of a protest against a reception featuring an Israeli community group at a recent LGBTQ conference, there has been widespread controversy. We have read blog posts and articles, watched videos of the protest and heard from friends and allies who were present at the demonstration.
Yet, what was perhaps most painful for many of us is that we value and embrace much of the good work of these activists and organizers. They are some of our nation’s leading advocates, working to secure justice and fair treatment to all. Often they stand as allies in our work for justice and equality.
Unfortunately, though, this fissure is not a new experience. Since starting as the CEO of ADL last summer, I personally have heard from many college students that their Jewish faith renders them pariahs on their campuses – unless and until they affirmatively denounce Israel.
Campus Hillels and other Jewish organizations that have long worked with LGBTQ campus groups, student-of-color organizations and other progressive clubs on campus to host film festivals, panels and other events increasingly are being shut out, rejected from participating, even when Israel is not on the agenda. Where other students are not being subjected to a litmus test on their views on Israel, Jewish students have been singled out and questioned about their objectivity and position on the issue.
As racial tensions flared across the country over the past few years, we heard anecdotes from Jewish racial-justice advocates that they were called “kikes” or targeted with other anti-Jewish slurs. When they tried to address the epithets, they were told they need to understand that “it’s because of Israel.”
Here’s the thing, though. It’s not. It’s antisemitism.
Let’s be clear. No government is immune from criticism. Surely neither the US government nor the government of Israel nor any other. Indeed, we have criticized policies and practices of Israeli leadership when we felt appropriate to do so.
We recognize that anti-Israel and pro-Palestinian activists will condemn Israel. That is a reality. That is their right. We disagree — vigorously — with their accusations of pinkwashing, with claims that Israel is an apartheid state and with other efforts to demonize Israel. And we will speak out, challenge their mischaracterizations and dismantle their indictments with facts and truths, as is our right.
But when that criticism of Israel crosses the line into antisemitism, we will condemn it. It is unacceptable and cannot be tolerated anywhere, especially not in social-justice circles.
To be specific, when a person conflates Jews, Israelis and the Israeli government, it is antisemitic. When all Jews and all Israelis are held responsible for the actions of the Israeli government, it is antisemitic. When Jews would be denied the right to self-determination accorded to all other peoples, it is antisemitic.
And when protesters chant “Palestine will be free from the river to the sea,” it is appropriately interpreted by most people as a call for the erasure of Israel – and it is antisemitic. Giving protesters the benefit of the doubt, it is unlikely that most intend their message to be antisemitic. However, regardless of the intent of the protest, the impact matters.
Yet, too often when students, individuals or organizations raise the specter of antisemitism, it is quickly rejected, disregarded or written off. Israel’s critics literally have written best-selling books decrying their so-called inability to criticize Israel.
But President Obama himself noted that antisemitism is on the rise. And, as he eloquently reminded, “When any Jews anywhere are targeted just for being Jewish, we all have to respond.. ‘We are all Jews.'”
Indeed, we know that women are best positioned to define sexism, people of color to define racism and LGBTQ people to define homophobia, transphobia and heterosexism. But, does this mean that all women must reach consensus on what offends them? All people of color? Everyone in LGBTQ communities? Hardly.
So, too, we Jews are best situated to define antisemitism, even if all of us may not likely reach consensus on the definition. Our millennial experience with intolerance demands the same acknowledgement as other forms of bigotry. Indeed, it is the collective responsibility of activists and organizers across the ideological spectrum to stop and listen when someone says, “You’ve crossed the line.”
Standing up for rights of disempowered people is a job for us all. ADL has been doing it for more than 100 years. But marginalizing and wounding others in the process helps no one. Rather, it divides us and impedes our ability to find common ground in places where our collective strength could do so much good.
This article was originally published by The Huffington Post.