Latest Cohen Column in New York Times Carries Two Blatant Errors
Error: Contact form not found.
by Ira Stoll
In an opinion column in the New York Times, Roger Cohen praises Bernie Sanders’ positions on Israel. Mr. Cohen is entitled to his opinion, but not to his own facts, and at least two of the “facts” he marshals in his piece are clearly incorrect.
Mr. Cohen writes, “A suicide bombing in Jerusalem on Monday was a further escalation in the simmering violence of the Israeli-Palestinian impasse.”
When the Times column was published, no fatalities had been reported in the bus bombing. Can it be a “suicide bomber” if the bomber isn’t killed? The Times news article about the attack does not describe it as a “suicide bombing”; to the contrary, it quotes a police official as saying, “The police were still investigating the circumstances surrounding the blast, including whether one of the people who was wounded had brought the bomb onto the bus.”
As far as I can tell, it isn’t yet clear whether it was even an attempted suicide bombing; the bomber may have been hoping to survive the attack. The column would be more accurate if it referred simply to a “bombing” or to a “bus bombing,” rather than to a “suicide bombing.”
Second, Mr. Cohen writes that the Iran nuclear deal “won congressional approval.” That’s not accurate, either. Opponents of the deal failed to muster the supermajority of votes in both houses of Congress that were needed to block it. The key vote in the Senate was 56 to 42, with 42 senators siding with the deal and 56 opposed. In the House, the vote was 162 in favor of the Iran deal and 269 against it. The New York Times itself reported the vote at the time in its news columns under the accurate and truthful headline, “House Rejects Iran Nuclear Deal.” For Mr. Cohen, less than a year later, miraculously to transform that rejection into “approval” is an inaccuracy that demands a correction, just as the suicide-bombing reference does.
No one is perfect, and everyone makes mistakes. The test of the Times in this case will be whether it forthrightly and promptly corrects the errors in this column, or whether it enters its more usual defensive crouch, pretending to perfection and refusing to acknowledge its mistakes. We shall see.
More of Ira Stoll’s media critique, a regular Algemeiner feature, can be found here.
Israeli Exports Hit Historic $164 Billion Record as Economy Defies War, Boycott Efforts, and Global Uncertainty
UK Music Festival Urged to Cancel Set by Irish Rap Group Kneecap Tied to Antisemitic, Anti-Israel Rhetoric
Boy George Pulls Out of ‘Jesus Christ Superstar’ London Production After Backlash From Pro-Israel Song
Israel, Spain Clash as Ceuta Migration Crisis Deepens Diplomatic Rift
Parshat Eikev: Why Moses’ Message Still Matters Today
The Merger That Never Was: How a Defense Bill Became an Israel Conspiracy Overnight
PA Official Tells Students That Martyrdom Is a Greater Achievement Than Graduating
The Board of Peace’s New Gaza Initiative Is Bold — And It Just Might Work
Bret Stephens Warns Jewish Extremist Violence Poses ‘Direct Threat’ to Israel
UK Anti-Israel Group Palestine Action Wins Supreme Court Appeal Bid Over Terrorism Ban






Bret Stephens Warns Jewish Extremist Violence Poses ‘Direct Threat’ to Israel
Parshat Eikev: Why Moses’ Message Still Matters Today
The Board of Peace’s New Gaza Initiative Is Bold — And It Just Might Work
The Merger That Never Was: How a Defense Bill Became an Israel Conspiracy Overnight
PA Official Tells Students That Martyrdom Is a Greater Achievement Than Graduating



