Sunday, October 25th | 7 Heshvan 5781

September 7, 2016 6:28 am

Petty Orthodoxy

avatar by Jeremy Rosen

A group of Orthodox Jews. Photo: Wiki Commons.

A group of Orthodox Jews. Photo: Wiki Commons. is a website that analyzes the weekly reading of the Torah for people who do not take every word in the Torah literally. In addition to valuing traditional commentators and interpretations, it caters to those who are interested in seeing how academics — scholars of different disciplines and backgrounds — understand the Torah. It is not for the fainthearted, fundamentalists or those who are unable or unwilling to take a rational point of view.

I consider it to be extremely important in bridging the gap between rationality and faith, belief and acceptance. But more than that, I think it is crucial in reaching out to those who feel that traditional interpretations alone no longer meet their intellectual needs. This is so important in preventing open minds from rejecting the Torah as being too doctrinaire.

The biggest challenge today in Jewish life is no longer preserving Orthodoxy. The Orthodox world is thriving. It retains most of its alumni. Those who leave get a lot of publicity but they are few overall. On the other hand, we are losing far more through apathy, ignorance, and assimilation. It may well be too late to reach those who have absolutely no knowledge of Jewish spirituality or of Jewish learning. But I think the greatest challenge is to reach out to those with a background, from Jewish schools or observant families, who are turning their backs and minds on a simplistic way of looking at our traditional texts.

We live in a world where people like to think for themselves, to make up their own minds. For better or for worse, ours is an era of individuality. How should religion relate to it? By shutting up the mental gates, closing minds, and peddling the conformity of ideas? Or by opening up, tolerating, and allowing freedom of thought?

Related coverage

July 22, 2016 3:28 am

CUFI Promotes Supporting Israel as a Core Christian Value - While much of the media focused on the recent terror attack in Nice, the failed coup in Turkey and...

Yeshivat Chovevei Torah (YCT) in New York started out to meet these goals. It was a reaction against the creeping influence of non-rationalist rabbis over Yeshivah University. Amongst its alumni is Rabbi Dr. Zev Farber, who is the editor of Recently some YCT students issued a declaration dissociating themselves from Rabbi Farber on the grounds that his exploration of other ways of looking at Torah texts have taken him beyond the pale of Orthodoxy, and that they, as students of YCT, did not want to be tarred by his brush and regarded as heterodox. It was just another example of the petty name-calling, rivalry, and dissent within the “broad church” of Orthodoxy. Furthermore, it negates thousands of years of alternative interpretations from impeccable rabbinic authorities.

Trying to impose any auto-da-fé on Orthodox Jews is offensive to me as a rationalist precisely because, although there are indeed accepted ideas and fundamental concepts in Judaism, there has always been a powerful rational voice that has avoided the rigid constraints of fundamentalism. Although certain concepts are regarded as core components of Jewish identity, the right to use one’s mind — to be able to think for oneself — is a measure of a healthy society and a healthy human being. One may disagree and express disagreement, but to imply that others are not “kosher” is to fall into the very trap that makes extremism so unpalatable. One should be emphasizing the positive, rather than trying to sift out those one disagrees with. To be derogatory is just as much a breach of Torah values as the sins the accusers are laying at Rabbi Farber’s feet.

What is more, the prime mover of is a Kollel rabbi of impeccable credentials and a member of the haredi community. If YCT students want to dissociate themselves from men like these, who look beyond traditional sources for answers to serious questions, then I wonder what they are doing in YCT. If thinking Orthodoxy has no room for questions, it will wither on the vine of obscurantism. I am proud to be associated with and Rabbi Farber, and I urge every thinking, committed Jew to rally to its support.

I worry that orthodoxies tend towards pettiness. Whenever any group seeks to define itself by distancing itself from and negating others, it inevitably risks becoming a witch-hunting travesty of its own ideals. In time, it falls prey to internal division and sectarianism. That was why we needed prophets, to keep us reminded of our ideals and goals.

Some issues are indeed incredibly complex. Does “Torah from Sinai” mean all of it, part of it, most of it or none of it? Was it spoken, transmitted, dictated, inspired, influenced, deduced at a specific moment some 4,000 years ago, over 40 days or 40 years? And in what language and what script? Or was it invented or edited, or complied, or adopted, or adapted, or reconstructed, or deconstructed, or created, or evolved out of something, nothing, or everything? If many rabbis in the Talmudic era could argue about the details then, why not now? And what really matters? Theological slogans or living a life of Torah and genuine morality?

Communities can have their own ideas and can choose to be either open or closed. They can refuse to accept anyone who thinks or behaves differently. Or to tolerate those who may or may not completely, partially, occasionally, formally, or informally agree, or not quite, or sort of, or it depends. That’s why many of us prefer living in free societies that do not insist that we all believe the same thing. The last thing we need is a “belief test” as well as a “means test” as well as “sniff test” or a “look into my eyes and swear test.”

You want to wear a black coat in summer? Be my guest! But don’t rubbish those who prefer not to. You want to believe the world is 5,000 years old? Gezunt! But why insult those who think it is older. You want to study Torah only? Of course, why shouldn’t you. But don’t prevent those who want to earn a living from being able to educate themselves. You don’t want to serve in the Israeli army? It’s your decision, but stop bullying those religious people who do. And now to cap it of, they want to hound people who think for themselves.

Am I to understand that the God of Micah who said, “Be kind, love justice, and walk humbly with your God,” really wants people to snub or insult others just because they disagree about how to understand texts or history? Let’s focus on the positive, on the good.

I’d rather see energy expended purging haredi Orthodoxy of its culture of corruption, illegality, materialism and brushing everything under the carpet than trying to sort out who is on the Lord’s side and who on the devil’s.

Share this Story: Share On Facebook Share On Twitter

Let your voice be heard!

Join the Algemeiner

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.