Tuesday, May 22nd | 8 Sivan 5778


Be in the know!

Get our exclusive daily news briefing.

February 19, 2017 9:15 am

Trump Is Right: The Palestinians Must Earn a Two-State Solution

avatar by Alan Dershowitz

Email a copy of "Trump Is Right: The Palestinians Must Earn a Two-State Solution" to a friend
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and US President Donald Trump at the White House on Feb. 16, 2017. Photo: Twitter/Netanyahu.

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and US President Donald Trump at the White House on Feb. 16, 2017. Photo: Twitter/Netanyahu.

President Trump raised eyebrows when he mentioned the possibility of a one-state solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The context was ambiguous, and no one can know for sure what message he was intending to convey. One possibility is that he was telling Palestinian leader that if they want a two-state solution, they have to do something; they have to come to the negotiating table with the Israelis, and make the kinds of painful sacrifices that will be required from both sides for a peaceful resolution to be achieved.  

Put most directly, the Palestinians must earn the right to a state. They are not simply entitled to statehood, especially since their leaders missed so many opportunities over the years to secure one. As Abba Eban once put it: “The Palestinians never miss an opportunity to miss an opportunity.”

It began back in the 1930s, when Great Britain established the Peale Commission, which was tasked to recommend a solution to the conflict between Arabs and Jews in mandatory Palestine. The commission recommended a two-state solution, with a tiny non-contiguous Jewish state being created alongside a large Arab state. The Jewish leadership reluctantly accepted this sliver of a state; the Palestinian leadership rejected the deal; for them, it was more important that no Jewish state existed.

In 1947, the United Nations partitioned mandatory Palestine into two areas: one for a Jewish state, the other for an Arab state. The Jews declared statehood in 1948; all the surrounding Arab countries joined the local Arab population in attacking the new state of Israel, and killing one percent of its citizens — but Israel survived.

In 1967, Egypt and Syria were planning to attack and destroy Israel, but Israel preempted them and won a decisive victory, capturing the West Bank, the Gaza Strip and the Sinai. Israel offered to return the captured areas in exchange for peace, but the Arabs met with Palestinian leaders in Khartoum and issued their three infamous “no’s”: no peace, no recognition and no negotiation.

In 2000-2001 and again in 2008, Israel made generous peace offers that would have established a demilitarized Palestinian state, but these offers were not accepted. And for the past several years, the current Israeli government has offered to sit down and negotiate a two state solution with no pre-conditions — not even advance recognition of Israel as the nation state of the Jewish people. Still, the Palestinian leadership has refused to negotiate.

President Trump may be telling the Palestinians that if they want a state, they have to show up at the negotiating table and bargain for it. No one is going to hand it to them on a silver platter in the way that former Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon handed over the Gaza Strip in 2005, only to see it turned into a launching pad for terror rockets and terror tunnels. Israel must get something in return: namely real peace, and a permanent end to the conflict.

The Palestinian leadership’s unwillingness to come to the negotiating table reminds me of my mother’s favorite Jewish joke about Sam, a 79-year-old man who prayed every day for God to let him win the New York lottery before he turned 80. On the eve of his 80th birthday, he railed against God: “All these years I’ve prayed to you every day asking to win the lottery. You couldn’t give me that one little thing.”  God responded: “Sam, you have to help me out here — buy a ticket.”  

The Palestinians haven’t bought a ticket. They haven’t negotiated in good faith. They haven’t accepted generous offers. They haven’t made realistic counter proposals. They haven’t offered sacrifices to match those offered by the Israelis.

Now President Trump is telling them that they have to buy a ticket. They won’t get a state by going to the United Nations, the European Union or the International Criminal Court. They won’t get a state as a result of the BDS effort or other anti-Israel movements. They will only get a state if they sit down and negotiate in good faith with the Israelis.

The Obama administration applied pressures only to the Israeli side, not to the Palestinians. The time has come — indeed it is long past due — for the United States to tell the Palestinians in no uncertain terms that they must give something up for a Palestinian state, and that they must agree to end the conflict, permanently and unequivocally. Otherwise, the status quo will continue, and there will be only one state — and that state will be Israel.

The Palestinians are not going to win the lottery without buying a ticket. 

A version of this article was originally published by The Gatestone Institute. 

The opinions presented by Algemeiner bloggers are solely theirs and do not represent those of The Algemeiner, its publishers or editors. If you would like to share your views with a blog post on The Algemeiner, please be in touch through our Contact page.

Share this Story: Share On Facebook Share On Twitter Email This Article

Let your voice be heard!

Join the Algemeiner
  • J Leland Kupferberg

    If I were the PA legal counsel, I would advise them to sign on the dotted line to agree to end the conflict. One can always find a pretext later on to fight over, claiming some sort of Israeli breach, and then resuming hostilities, but this time with the added political, legal, and military tools that come with state sovereignty.

    If Dershowitz hasn’t given thought to that prospect, he should move aside and stop offering negligent advice by continually pushing for a Palestinian state in the Judean hills, right on top of Israel’s nine-mile wide central waistline.

    A Palestinian state under any terms would be a long-term disaster for Israel on way too many levels. First off, Israel is already in the midst of a real estate crunch, with the scarcely populated Area C serving as a prime foundation for the expansion of the Jewish population over the next 50 years.

    It’s a matter of national security, and Dershowitz is far too dense and short-sighted to understand such demographic concerns. If Israeli Jews cannot find affordable housing anywhere in the Land of Israel, aliyah will tighten up, and Israeli Jews will seek housing elsewhere.

    Combine that with the explosive situation of a contiguous Palestinian state overlooking Israel’s narrow underbelly, and you have an inevitable recipe for disaster.

    The EU and the UN would be perfectly happy – or at least indifferent – if the State of Israel turned into a Palestinian Zimbabwe, with the Jewish population fleeing en masse.

    This is the end game of the two-state solution. It’s time that committed Jews woke up and started getting some sense in their heads. Stop taking “advice” from the Flavians among you.

  • Esther Noodelman

    Y Draiman.Youre right on the money! The Arabs cant always get what they want!