Friday, May 25th | 11 Sivan 5778


Be in the know!

Get our exclusive daily news briefing.

February 21, 2017 8:22 am

The Impossible Deal: Establishing a Peaceful Palestinian-Arab State

avatar by Morton A. Klein

Email a copy of "The Impossible Deal: Establishing a Peaceful Palestinian-Arab State" to a friend
Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. Photo: Twitter.

Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. Photo: Twitter.

It was exhilarating to watch US President Donald Trump, at his press conference with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, refuse to parrot the tired, irrational, dangerous mantra that a Palestinian state is the only option for peace.

Instead, Trump wisely spoke about real peace; creative solutions; ending the Palestinian-Arabs’ teaching of “tremendous hate” to their children in their schools; and the essential requirement that the Palestinian-Arabs recognize the Jewish state.

The truth is, however, that irreconcilable, diametrically opposed differences between Israel and the Palestinian Authority (PA) have long made it clear that the creation of a Palestinian-Arab state is an impossibility.

For example, the PA demands control, at a minimum, of all of east Jerusalem – while Israel requires that the entire city remain united under Israeli sovereignty.

The world needs to understand that Jerusalem is not even holy to Muslims. It is never mentioned in the Quran; it is mentioned 700  times in the Jewish holy books. No Arab leader, except Jordan’s King Hussein, ever visited Jerusalem when Arabs controlled it from 1948-67. Jerusalem has never been the capital of any country except Israel.

The PA demands that every Jew must be ejected from their future state, meaning the 800,000 Jews in east Jerusalem-Judea-Samaria. That will never happen.

The PA also insists that millions of descendants of so-called Palestinian “refugees,” created by the 1948 Arab war to destroy Israel, be allowed to move to Israel (Even though there are only 40,000 actual refugees from 1948 living today). Every Israeli government, from Left to Right, unequivocally rejects this, because it means overwhelming Israel with a hostile population and ending Israel as a Jewish state.

The PA also demands a “contiguous” state that connects Gaza to Judea-Samaria, thereby cutting Israel into two separate pieces. Israel obviously cannot agree to this demand either, if Israel wishes to remain in existence.

The PA refuses to agree to Israel’s basic demand for recognition as the Jewish state.

To top off all of the above, the PA refuses to sign a peace deal that “ends all claims” against Israel.  Israel understandably cannot agree to any agreement that does not include such a clause.

Another irreconcilable PA demand is that Israel must free all Palestinian-Arab terrorists in Israeli jails. Of course, Israel won’t release thousands of unrepentant convicted murderers and attempted murderers.

Also with respect to security, Israel, at a minimum, must maintain control over the major Jewish communities in Judea-Samaria, and, as Netanyahu said during Wednesday’s joint press conference, Israel needs “overriding security control over the entire area west of the Jordan River,” because “otherwise we’ll get another radical Islamic terrorist state in the Palestinian areas exploding the peace, exploding the Middle East.”

Israel also requires that it continue the legal Gaza weapons blockade, but, the PA says it will never accept this.

Similarly, as Netanyahu explained in 2009 during his speech at Bar-Ilan University, any Palestinian-Arab state needs to be “demilitarized” – meaning that it cannot have an army, control its airspace, forge military pacts with the likes of Hezbollah and Iran, and import weapons, and must be subject to strong measures to prevent weapons smuggling. The PA opposes all of these Israeli security requirements.

Still another irreconcilable issue is that because a Palestinian state deal asks Israel to give up irreversible tangibles (i.e., land) for intangible peace promises, Israel needs partners who keep their promises. But the PA broke its repeated Oslo and other agreements to combat and stop inciting terror, collect illegal weapons, outlaw terrorist groups and preserve and provide Jews access to Jewish holy sites in PA territory.

Finally, the PA’s unrelenting goal is to destroy and replace all of Israel with a Palestinian-Arab state that no Jews can step foot in. This goal is clearly laid out in the PA ruling party Fatah Charter and in PA President Abbas’ speeches condemning the Israeli “occupation” since 1948 – and in the PA maps, stationery, official emblems, stamps, media and atlases showing all of Israel as Palestine.  The PA leadership assures its people that any concessions it obtains are “stages” towards their final goal of destroying the Jewish state. Additionally, the PA is politically aligned with Hamas, whose charter calls for Israel’s destruction and the murder of every Jew.

Israel cannot agree to commit suicide – or give the PA a stronger base for advancing the Palestinian-Arab “struggle” for Israel’s total annihilation.

Morton A. Klein is President of the Zionist Organization of America.

The opinions presented by Algemeiner bloggers are solely theirs and do not represent those of The Algemeiner, its publishers or editors. If you would like to share your views with a blog post on The Algemeiner, please be in touch through our Contact page.

Share this Story: Share On Facebook Share On Twitter Email This Article

Let your voice be heard!

Join the Algemeiner
  • Marc

    A Two Citizenships Solution vs. a Jewish-Arab State :

    A two states solution is meaningless without changing citizenship of Israeli Arabs. Israeli Arabs obtained Israeli citizenship illegally and against international law. Unfortunately, Israel long ago became a bi-national , it’s an incubator for Arab people.
    Jews will not survive in a bi-national state.
    Israel must stop to impose Israeli citizenship to the hostile nation.

    Immediately after the establishment of a new Arab state west of the Jordan River ( or return Jordanian rule ), the Arabs of Haifa, Nazareth, Lod, Galilee, Negev, Jerusalem etc. must become citizens of their new (old) state.
    If the Jews do not want to continue to live in a bi-national state, and within a generation become a minority in Israel, they must prepare for a referendum (as in Scotland) based on the UN resolution to divide Palestine for Jews and Arabs.

    Fatah-Hamas government requires land free of Jews.
    Therefore, Israeli demands are legitimate and forced:
    1. To divide National Insurance for Jews and Arabs, by forming the funds from taxes collected separately from Jews and Arabs.
    2. To employ only the Arabs, who will replace Israeli citizenship to the status of Israel’s residents.
    3. Deductions from wages ( income tax and health tax) of Arab residents to transfer to the Palestinian Authority , of course along with responsibility for health, education , jobs and pensions to all Arabs who wish to remain in Israel.

    It’s possible to separate from the Arabs by the law, as the Irish and the British, as the Czechs and the Slovaks or as the Greeks and the Turks in Cyprus .
    First to separate economically and then geographically.
    Palestinian citizenship to the Arabs, Israeli citizenship to the Jews.
    Two Nations – Two States – Two Citizenships !

  • oceanstater

    I think the author is right about Palestinian goals but giving up forever on Palestinian state (implied by relentless settlement expansion) dooms Israel to forever live under the threat of terrorism and war from increasingly well armed groups in Gaza, Lebanon etc. That is because Palestinians cannot be made to accept what they see as “occupation” any more than Israelis would submit to Arab domination. Nor as a practical matter can Palestinians be made to disappear or go away. Further, indefinite occupation will erode Israel’s standing worldwide, indeed that is already happening in the US among younger people.
    So despite the difficulties and current impasse, there is no choice but to keep a two state option open and work long term for reconciliation and compromise on all sides.

  • J Leland Kupferberg

    Unfortunately, Netanyahu is actually working to box Israel into a kind of two state solution, whether the Palestinians agree to his terms or not.

    One way of doing so is to freeze the geographical expansion of Jewish settlement building across Area C, while looking the other way as the EU funds vast tracts of illegal building of Arab units across Area C. In this way, Netanyahu helps the Arabs to effectively peel more and more land away from sparsely populated areas of Area C, shoring up the Palestinian claim to the land by getting more and more Arabs to settle there.

    The only Area C land that Netanyahu is interested in keeping is the 6% of the West Bank that comprises the settlement blocs; all the rest is being reserved by Netanyahu for an eventual giveaway to the Palestinians for the right “price.”

    Meanwhile, everyone in the Likud and Jewish Home pretend that Netanyahu is just tactically “appeasing” the international community with these moves.

    By no means. There is a reason why Netanyahu publicly announces – i.e. red-flags – every Jewish building unit approval, but then quietly rolls it back. The fact is, he appeases his right flank with the announcement, but then quietly reneges so that he can pursue his real goal, which is to bargain the best terms for giving away the bulk of Area C.