Sunday, July 22nd | 10 Av 5778

March 13, 2017 1:35 pm

My Search for a Safe College for Jews

avatar by Sruli Fruchter

Email a copy of "My Search for a Safe College for Jews" to a friend
The NYU campus. Photo: Wikimedia Commons.

The NYU campus. Photo: Wikimedia Commons.

As I began my research into choosing a college, I was repeatedly told that colleges are tolerant and accepting environments for every individual, regardless of his or her identity and beliefs. My meetings with high school guidance counselors and my experiences on campus tours, so far, have only seemed to affirm this impression. I was thus quite excited by the idea that, when I got to college, to a diverse community where freedom of speech is paramount, I could openly practice my religion and advocate for my beliefs without fear of intimidation or backlash from my fellow students.

Unfortunately, what I have been reading about lately suggests otherwise.

Since the beginning of 2016, the number of antisemitic incidents on college campuses has surged, increasing by 45 percent compared to 2015, according to a study by AMCHA Initiative, a non-profit organization dedicated to combating campus antisemitism. The AMCHA report includes every type of incident, from swastikas being engraved in bathrooms or on dorm doors to students being verbally and physically harassed. I was astonished at just how ubiquitous antisemitism has become, occurring at so many universities.

Even a school as prominent and prestigious as New York University did not escape the scourge: Last November, four NYU students awoke to find large, dark swastikas scrawled on their doors. When I saw the online photos, my heart tightened and my stomach constricted. Questions and concerns raced through my head: What if that were my door? How would I cope with the realization that my identity, my religion, made me a target of abuse? How could a diverse and tolerant campus such as NYU be home to such hostility, and in the dorms in particular? Can the school remain a viable college choice for me?

These questions circled through my mind without any answers. And of course it wasn’t just NYU.

In recent months, many other prominent colleges — such as the University of Maryland, Hunter College, Georgetown University, Swarthmore College — have been the sites of similar heinous attacks. At Northwestern University in November, a Jewish Studies lecturer was asked if he was Jewish by a man in a vehicle. When the professor said yes, the unidentified man raised his arm in a Nazi salute and yelled “Heil Hitler.” Shockingly, the mainstream media barely covered the story.

In fact, AMCHA reported over 600 hate crimes against Jews on college campuses in 2016, yet there was, and has been, no national outrage. Except for news outlets that focus on Jewish matters, such as The Algemeiner, most of these episodes received only minimal local coverage at best.

If the assailants at NYU had scrawled anti-Muslim threats on the doors of NYU students, the story would have received national attention. If that lecturer were a man of Muslim faith who was attacked with hateful, religion-based slurs, there would have been universal outrage — including on the relevant campus itself. When it comes to Jews, however, these offenses are largely tolerated. The university president may utter general words of condemnation, but the bottom line is this: the general public, and the campus community, do not truly stand with the Jews among them. Jewish students are more or less defenseless in the face of hate.

The fact that colleges have evolved into arenas where antisemitism doesn’t merely occur but seems actively tolerated, shakes me to my core. Becoming a victim of antisemitism on campus has become a serious fear for me, a worry that haunts me as I continue my research into schools, trying to find an institution that could offer me not merely a good education, but safety and security. What awaits me, when I begin college? Swastikas on my door? Racial slurs from other students? Physical assaults?

Can this truly be how things are — in the United States, in the year 2017?

The opinions presented by Algemeiner bloggers are solely theirs and do not represent those of The Algemeiner, its publishers or editors. If you would like to share your views with a blog post on The Algemeiner, please be in touch through our Contact page.

Share this Story: Share On Facebook Share On Twitter Email This Article

Let your voice be heard!

Join the Algemeiner
  • Curious Mayhem

    Absolutely. The role that these departments and organizations have played in this trend is long-standing, going back to the 1970s. The new, amplifying factor is BDS/SJP.

  • Curious Mayhem

    It has nothing to do with Trump. Antisemitism has been slowly climbing back to respectability on US campuses since the early 2000s and trended sharply upward between 2010 and 2014. I’m not sure it has anything to do with Obama particularly, although I agree that his malevolence and general incompetence and arrogance in foreign policy didn’t help.

    The one consistent common factor is almost all cases is the presence of an active BDS/SJP movement on a campus. If that’s absent, the problem is much smaller or non-existent. Since 2014, there have also been a few campuses with neo-Nazi incidents. But these are far smaller in number than the incidents connected with BDS, SJP, and Muslim students. You wouldn’t know that from listening to the news media.

  • oceanstater

    Obama was a great friend to Jews and had many many highly placed Jewish advisors and appointees including the US Supreme Court.. Attacks on him are not only misplaced, but politically stupid as it a only possible effect is to antagonize liberals, people of color, and decent people of all almost all political stripes, people pro-Israel forces need as allies, not needlessly and foolishly made into opponents.

  • Blankety-Blank

    Brandeis is hardly philo-Semitic. But at least there is some education going on there, in between the antisemitic proselytizing. They encourage students from “all backgrounds” which certainly guarantees diversity. But diversity is not necessarily intellectually useful, nor rigorously academic. It’s just diverse. I heard a student from Brandeis at a public lecture a few years ago provide his credentials and then rave against Israel, mis-stating facts and selectively emphasizing elements of reality while suppressing context to ensure that his tendentious point was made. But at least Brandeis doesn’t encourage open antisemitism. Except when it drives out speakers who would tell the truth about radical Islam.

  • robert Davis

    Absolutely right. Anyway some solace can be found in the fact that today’s Young antisemites being SCUM will end up as unemployed, thieves or killers and will be an example of what is vile for others.

  • Elliot Bache

    Obama Built This.

  • Elliot Bache

    tell that to your 18 year old daughter……..Are you able to walk while you chew gum?

  • Mitchell Rapoport

    Obama is gone. It will get better. But this is not a time for pearl clutching. Be like Israelis. Fight back hard!

  • Sharon Raanan

    We look forward to seeing you at any of the fine colleges and universities in Israel. IDT has a program where you could study entirely in English, if that were your preference. In short, I would never recommend that a committed Jew subject him or herself to the toxic environment of American universities today. Come to Israel! We welcome you with open arms.

    • Elliot Bache

      IDC, NOT IDT.

  • Howard Schaerf

    ”Man up” join an activist Zionist group …….BE a proud & unafraid.

    • Elliot Bache

      You sound like a Special Kind of Stupid………or can you be that Naive?