Tuesday, October 17th | 27 Tishri 5778

Close

Be in the know!

Get our exclusive daily news briefing.

Subscribe
April 30, 2017 11:25 am

Intersectionality’s Demonization of Jews

avatar by Joshua Sharf / JNS.org

Email a copy of "Intersectionality’s Demonization of Jews" to a friend

Linda Sarsour. Photo: Screenshot.

JNS.org – In the Venn diagram of intersectionality, one group doesn’t intersect with the others.

“Intersectionality” is the left-wing word of the day. Academically, it means that various identity-based “oppressions” overlap and interact to reinforce each other. Practically, it means various “oppressed” groups must stick together. Having graduated from the academy to the street, it has become the social justice warrior version of the early labor movement’s One Big Industrial Union.

Skeptics argue that a coalition organized around identity-group power will eventually come to tears over conflicting grievances. After all, there are only so many redistributed taxes, political appointments and endowed chairs to go around.

So far, though, it’s mostly Jews who are getting shut out by progressives and their anti-Israel supporters who post fake eviction notices and decry “Jewish privilege.” Beginning with the Ferguson riots, the Black Lives Matter movement has been infiltrated by militant anti-Zionists, who have now used Black History Month as a platform for their hate. Linda Sarsour, a lead organizer of the Women’s March, seeks to isolate Jews from feminism, calling it incompatible with Zionism.

Related coverage

October 17, 2017 12:07 pm
0

Alan Dershowitz: Trump Did the Right Thing by Walking Away From UNESCO — for Now

This article was first published by Gatestone Institute. The State Department announced on Thursday that the United States would be withdrawing...

Unsurprisingly, liberal Jews have responded with weakness and confusion. Days before the Women’s March, The Forward published an op-ed literally titled, “Why Jewish Feminism Should Embrace, Not Fear, Intersectionality.” The Anti-Defamation League, having written glowingly of intersectionality and the Women’s March on its official blog, appears not to have any response at all. Benjamin Gladstone, like any true believer, argued in Tablet magazine that the fault lies not with intersectionality, but with flawed intersectionalists.

Intersectionality, however, isn’t about fairness or rights. It’s about group power. Intersectionality promotes group rights based on group grievances. It’s a tool for dividing our country by focusing on our differences rather than on our commonalities. It inevitably turns politics into a hate-fueled group shoving match, and we’re always the smallest group in the room.

History shows that we lose when societies fragment into warring tribes. In a country where Jews have thrived, and in a world where Israel is an economic, technological and military marvel, it’s no wonder we don’t fit in.

Gladstone’s argument that the intersectionality movement should deal with anti-Zionism and antisemitism falls flat. His appeal is to fairness, not to interest. Most other groups don’t really care about fairness, and the Palestinian activists detest Jews.

Some on the Left have attempted to circumvent the problem through traditional liberal means. They propose to continue looking for allies among other identity groups, as Jews always have, but to do so outside of intersectionality. They aim to recreate the old civil rights alliance with new Asian, Hispanic and Muslim membership. Both Mark Yudof, president emeritus of the University of California system, and David Bernstein, CEO of the Jewish Council for Public Affairs, champion this approach.

Though superficially more politically astute, they offer nothing more than Gladstone. Practical intersectionality is about power, and neither Yudof nor Bernstein offer any compelling incentives for these other groups to abandon their Muslim and anti-Israel allies. Neither do they offer any mechanism aside from “education.” Instead of recapturing their movement from antisemites, they merely put Jews in a bidding war for friends.

The right answer isn’t to beg for scraps from such a movement. It’s to walk away from it entirely.

The genius of America is to recognize only individual rights while promoting voluntary communities. The genius of Israel is to take that to the national level. Our post-Holocaust history validates those ideas, and repudiates everything intersectionality stands for.

Intersectionality is a step backwards for Jews. In Making It, his professional memoir of Jewish intellectual life in the 1950s and ’60s, Norman Podhoretz contrasts the more radical first generation of the 1930s and ’40s with the generation that followed. The buzzword of the first generation was “alienation” — alienation from and hostility to America. The second generation, liberal but not radical, sought acceptance of Jewish culture as a legitimate American construct.

Walking away from intersectionality doesn’t mean walking away from allies and friends who are in trouble. It means inviting them to succeed on the same terms that we have — the way Americans have always succeeded — and helping them to do so.

It may even mean finding new allies, like the white working class described in J.D. Vance’s Hillbilly Elegy — a demographic that comprised a substantial portion of President Donald Trump’s voting bloc. Such an alliance isn’t as bizarre as it might seem at first blush; Podhoretz notes that during his US Army service, his best friends were hillbilly southerners.

Among activist groups and on hostile college campuses, this formula may be a tough sell. But they aren’t our friends, anyway. The best way to rob intersectionalists of their power is to demonstrate just how little they have to offer the communities they ostensibly represent.

Joshua Sharf is a fellow with the Haym Salomon Center and head of the PERA project at the Independence Institute. Follow him on Twitter @joshuasharf.

The opinions presented by Algemeiner bloggers are solely theirs and do not represent those of The Algemeiner, its publishers or editors. If you would like to share your views with a blog post on The Algemeiner, please be in touch through our Contact page.

Share this Story: Share On Facebook Share On Twitter Email This Article

Let your voice be heard!

Join the Algemeiner
  • djrpok

    It’s time to recognize that President Trump is the best ally Jews have had in a long time. Stop trying to kiss Muslim backsides. They hate us and always will. Stand up proud !

  • Sammy Eppel

    When intersectionality showed its true colors many of us that saw it were not welcomed anymore by main Jewish institutions madly in love with “progressives” now they realize what a great mistake they made and instead of admitting and mending, they just try to justify. Antisemitism is like an incurable social disease and you don’t defeat it by “embracing” your enemies, enemies are to be confronted and defeated by all legal means. Never again!!

Algemeiner.com