Thursday, July 19th | 7 Av 5778

July 3, 2017 1:25 pm

Top ACLU Official: Israel ‘Exploiting’ Antisemitism to ‘Encourage’ Jewish Immigration

avatar by Ben Cohen

Email a copy of "Top ACLU Official: Israel ‘Exploiting’ Antisemitism to ‘Encourage’ Jewish Immigration" to a friend

Mehdi Hasan’s video “explaining” antisemitism on the Qatari-funded Al Jazeera network. Photo: Screenshot

A high-level official at the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) has accused the Israeli government of exploiting antisemitism so as to secure greater Jewish immigration to Israel – leading one senior Jewish human rights advocate to counter that the veteran civil rights organization is actively compromising the fight against anti-Jewish prejudice.

“He has an important position within the ACLU and one would hope he would use that platform to fight antisemitism, rather than making it harder for those of us who are trying to do so,” antisemitism expert Kenneth Marcus told The Algemeiner on Monday, following a tweet on Sunday from Jamal Dakwar – the director of the ACLU’s Human Rights Program – that “Israeli leaders exploit horrible acts of anti-Semitism to encourage Jews to move to Israel.”

Dakwar added, “Judaism ≠ [does not equal] Zionism, Anti-Zionism ≠ [does not equal] Anti-Semitism.”

The tweet was a comment attached to a short video on the nature of antisemitism by the British pundit, Mehdi Hasan, that was broadcast by the Qatari-funded Al Jazeera network. Acknowledging that antisemitism is a form of racism – “no ifs, no buts” – Hasan then presented the problem as largely concerned with the far right, tying it heavily to the election of US President Donald Trump last November. Antisemitism on the left was mentioned in passing, while antisemitism among European Muslims was not discussed at all, with Hasan describing the terror attack on the Hypercacher supermarket in January 2015 as “the attack on a Jewish supermarket in Paris,” without mentioning that the perpetrators were Islamist terrorists.

Hasan’s fundamental point – which recycles a favored theme of past Soviet and Arab anti-Zionist propaganda – is that Israel’s “cynical” leaders welcome eruptions of antisemitism as an opportunity to urge Jews to immigrate en masse to the State of Israel.

When it came to those engaged in “conflating” the Jewish people with Zionism and Israel, Hasan concluded, “maybe let’s not forget to include as well some of the irresponsible, and yes, cynical leaders of the State of Israel.”

Marcus – President and General Counsel of the Louis D. Brandeis Center for Human Rights Under Law, and the author of “The Definition of Antisemitism,” published by Oxford University Press in 2015 – expressed amazement that, in sharing Hasan’s video, Dakwar was buying into a definition of antisemitism coined by Al Jazeera.

“He is not wrong to distinguish between Judaism and Zionism, nor is he incorrect that anti-Zionism and antisemitism are different conceptually,” Marcus explained. “But he has borrowed from Al Jazeera a simplistic and distorted understanding of the relationship between them.”

Marcus continued: “It’s extraordinary that he relies on Al Jazeera‘s conception of antisemitism and then criticizes (Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin) Netanyahu for failing to follow it. It is as if he assumed that anti-black racism is entirely what white supremacists define it to be, and then castigated black leaders for holding a different view.”

Marcus also pointed out that the ACLU – founded in 1920 – “has been leading the battle against the Antisemitism Awareness Act, which is one of the most important current legislative efforts to fight antisemitism in colleges and universities.”

The Act – passed by the Senate in December 2016, but still to be considered by the House of Representatives – uses the definition of antisemitism approved by the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA), which provides guidance on how to determine whether anti-Zionism has crossed into antisemitism, as is frequently the case. But the ACLU believes that Act will clamp down on First Amendment free speech rights for pro-Palestinians and anti-Zionist groups on campus such as Students for Justice in Palestine (SJP), which supports the elimination of the Jewish state of Israel through the creation of a single Palestinian state.

“The ACLU should be leading this battle,” Marcus argued. “But they’ve gotten on the wrong side of it.”

Share this Story: Share On Facebook Share On Twitter Email This Article

Let your voice be heard!

Join the Algemeiner
  • They all did before Islam invaded…. and they lived in North Africa and the Arabian territories…. Persia… etc. Muslims destroyed their culture with jihad in 7th century….read some history fool. Date November 636 – April 637 AD
    Location Jerusalem
    Result Rashidun victory
    changes Jerusalem captured by Rashidun Caliphate

  • Salomon

    How did you arrive at that number? From my own poll of my acquaintance and friends Jews 90% are strongly Zionists (support to Likud and Bayit Yehudi parties), while about 7% are weak Zionists (Labor party), about 3% are anti-zionist, I include here the Hard Left and the religious sects as Satmar. The Naturei Karta sect count few hundred individuals.

  • Kris Kristian

    Sure. Thank heaven for the Jewish state of Israel, protecting Jews from rubbish like you

  • Henry Chmielnicki

    And you, sir, are an uninformed ignoramus. Maybe you should get some education before compromising yourself in writing.

  • Kris Kristian

    prove it.
    Show it/

  • Kris Kristian

    Where did you get the rubbish you print?

  • Pearl Belkowitz

    Matt that is a sad truth. There are also antiSemitic Jews. That’s an even greater sin!!

  • Pearl Belkowitz

    This is is the face of an antisemite! Remember it well, because he speaks for many like him who believe in the lies spewed over the centuries. Antisemitism is alive and well in America. Because of our first amendment he can regurgitate these lies to anyone who will listen.

  • watsa46

    The weird left unable to deal with its own insanity! Very sad.
    The mass media in turmoil following 6 or 7 decades of arrogance & abuse of their power!


    Where was the ACLU when six million Jews were exterminated?
    Sucking their thumbs or marching for the Nazi’s right to end the lives of Jews?

    • Kris Kristian

      well written.
      That sums them up

  • Nina

    More leftist stupidity

  • garry pollack

    But as usual the Algae miner stifles the conversation!!!

  • Commenter

    Jamil Dakwar is one face of anti-Semitism, wreaking of ignorance and prejudice and blackheartedness. Beyond this, his statements have no utility. He is a disgrace to the ACLU.