Saturday, October 21st | 1 Heshvan 5778

Close

Be in the know!

Get our exclusive daily news briefing.

Subscribe
September 20, 2017 1:57 pm

New Biography of Philanthropist Fails to Ask Key Jewish Questions

avatar by Jack Riemer / JNS.org

Email a copy of "New Biography of Philanthropist Fails to Ask Key Jewish Questions" to a friend
Review

Julius Rosenwald. Photo: Library of Congress.

JNS.org – Professor Hasia Diner has a well-earned reputation as an insightful historian. But in her new book, Julius Rosenwald: Repairing the World, she seems to be so admiring of her subject that she can see no ambiguity in his achievements — and no problem with his legacy.

There is much to admire in Julius Rosenwald’s life story. He was one of the German Jews who came to America in the middle of the 19th century, and — after amassing a fortune — turned their attention to philanthropy.

Rosenwald was remarkably modest about his achievements and his generosity, and he deserves praise for both. Starting out as a peddler, he ended up the owner of Sears Roebuck, which he developed into the largest mail-order company in the country. Yet whenever he was asked about how he made his fortune, he would say that it was all a matter of luck — being in the right place at the right time.

Though he gave to all manner of causes, Rosenwald never permitted any building that he endowed to be named for him, and he sought no credit for himself. As Diner points out, Rosenwald was one of the first philanthropists who made nearly all his donations in the form of challenge gifts, so that others would be inspired to give as well — and so that the recipients of his generosity would learn to be self-reliant.

Related coverage

October 19, 2017 1:36 pm
0

NFL Network to Air Documentary on Hall of Famers’ Trip to Israel Led by Patriots Owner

The television channel NFL Network will air on Friday night a documentary about New England Patriots owner Robert Kraft taking 18 Hall of...

Rosenwald is perhaps best remembered for his enormous support of the cause of African-American education and advancement. But he also gave to Jewish causes. Though a Reform Jew, he was sympathetic to the needs of the more traditional Eastern European Jews who were coming to America in such large numbers; he played a major role in funding schools and institutions across the Jewish spectrum. Rosenwald also gave generously to the Jews of Europe, both during and after World War I.

As Diner stresses, Rosenwald saw his philanthropy as an integral part of his Judaism. She attributes his concern for others and his desire to help build a better America to Rabbi Emil G. Hirsch, his rabbi at Sinai Temple in Chicago, whose sermons he listened to frequently.

My main reservation with the book is that Diner avoids the question that confronts contemporary liberal Jews — and that a reader can’t help but ask while contemplating Rosenwald’s own experiences: Can an approach that focuses on building a better world, but not necessarily on Jewish knowledge and observance, survive for more than a few generations?

This question is the flip side of the dilemma that faces the traditional Jewish community: Does Jewish continuity depend upon isolation from the outside world and being concerned only with one’s own, or do we have a responsibility to contribute to the welfare of the world at large?

Liberal Jews may feel that it is only right and proper to criticize their coreligionists who wish to live in isolation; at the same time, it is undeniable that almost half the children receiving a Jewish education in New York City today are registered in Orthodox day schools or yeshivas.

There are several reasons for this, but the primary one is that Orthodox Jews have more children than do liberal Jews, while second- and third-generation liberal Jews marry outside the faith in great numbers and do not identify as Jews.

In my view, the kind of Judaism exemplified by Rosenwald has not led to the growth of a literate and committed liberal Jewish community. Quite the opposite, actually. The present state of affairs can be summed up by the story of the liberal Jew whose entire Jewish education centered on the concept of tikkun olam (repairing the world) and who, upon arriving in Israel, asked, “How do you say tikkun olam in Hebrew?”

This is not to suggest that Jewish life in America has to be an either-or proposition, and that we must choose between aligning ourselves with those Jews who strive to build a better America, or with those who strive to build a literate and involved Jewish community. But if we are to survive and have a moral purpose for our survival, we need to find a way to enable both groups to learn from each other.

Diner has written a well-deserved tribute to one of the giants of American philanthropy — who also happens to be one of the heroes of American history. But, to the great detriment of her book, she left out a supremely important dimension to Rosenwald’s story — a dimension that relates to his people and their ultimate survival.

“Julius Rosenwald: Repairing the World;” by Hasia Diner; Yale University Press; Oct. 24, 2017; 256 pages; ISBN-10: 0300203217; ISBN-13: 978-0300203219.

Rabbi Jack Riemer is a frequent reviewer of books of Jewish thought in America and abroad. He is the co-editor of “Ethical Wills,” and the editor of “The World of the High Holy Days.” His two volumes of sermons will be published soon.

Share this Story: Share On Facebook Share On Twitter Email This Article

Let your voice be heard!

Join the Algemeiner
  • Brian Lang

    Hasia Dinar has done great work in defusing th anti-semitism in the Black community in New York by debunking the false narrative of Jewish racism. I don’t believe it was a coincidence that the Crown Heights pogrom began on the heels of Leonard Jeffries and Farakhan and Newman’s update of the Protocols of Zion forgery tailored for an African-American audience. Or that the waves of violence and hatred receded with her and another author whose name I forget issuing much publicized books on the how much the Jewish Community supported the Black civil rights struggle throughout the 20th century. I believe her books have saved many Jewish lives, and continue to do so with this book. That being said, I was disappointed to read of her recent attacks on Israel and Zionism. She is truly, as the minister of the African-American AME Zion Baptist Church said upon the final demise of slavery in New York in 1827, i believe, when referring obliquely to Thomas Jefferson, “that ambidexter philosopher.”

  • Nemesis

    Why not mention Hasia Diner’s virulent antiZionism and hatred of Israel?

  • mr215

    strange! a Jew built Sears into a giant business and a Jew is now destroying it.

Algemeiner.com