Wednesday, February 21st | 6 Adar 5778


Be in the know!

Get our exclusive daily news briefing.

September 27, 2017 4:00 pm

Jewish Human Rights Group Slams Massachusetts School District for Disciplining Teacher Who Educated Students About Antisemitism

avatar by Shiri Moshe

Email a copy of "Jewish Human Rights Group Slams Massachusetts School District for Disciplining Teacher Who Educated Students About Antisemitism" to a friend

Stoughton High School in Massachusetts. (Photo: Courtesy.)

A prominent human rights group has urged a school district in Massachusetts to cease disciplinary action against a teacher who talked to her students about antisemitism after a swastika was posted at their high school.

In a letter sent on Monday to Stoughton Public Schools Superintendent Marguerite Rizzi, the Louis D. Brandeis Center for Human Right Under Law (LDB) called on the school council not to proceed with an arbitration hearing against Stoughton High School teacher Stella Martin, which took place late Tuesday night.

LDB Senior Staff Attorney Jennie Gross told The Algemeiner on Wednesday that the center has not yet heard back from any of the recipients of the letter. “The hearing did not finish yesterday, and so there is no outcome yet,” she added.

Martin, who teaches Honors English, was reprimanded for talking to her class of eight seniors about antisemitism after a student at the school posted a swastika on the Senior “Spirit Wall” last November 22. When another student asked him to take down the inflammatory symbol, the instigator spoke about removing and burning the swastika, “the way they burned the Jews.” The incident was reported to the administration, and the student was suspended for six days.

Related coverage

February 20, 2018 1:54 pm

At Security Council, Haley Tells Abbas: I Will Not Shut Up, US Recognition of Jerusalem as Israel’s Capital Will Not Change

US Ambassador to the UN Nikki Haley upbraided Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas at the UN Security Council on Tuesday,...

In response, Martin spent “ten to fifteen minutes engaging the students in a discussion about anti-Semitic symbolism, the Holocaust, and hate speech,” according to LDB. “She did not mention the name of the offending student, which she did not know, and she made no statements about him.”

Despite this, the mother of the student who posted the swastika argued that her son was bullied by Martin during the classroom discussion, a charge the school district dismissed. Martin, however, was reprimanded for engaging in conduct “unbecoming of a teacher.”

Two other teachers at the school — Jamie Regan and Hilary Moll — were disciplined for related reasons, and are scheduled to face arbitration hearings in November and December, respectively.

“It is disgraceful that the Stoughton Public Schools are disciplining a teacher who did the right thing by responding firmly to anti-Semitism,” LDB President Kenneth L. Marcus said of Martin in a statement on Monday. “By mistreating Ms. Martin and her colleagues in this manner, Superintendent Rizzi is sending an awful message that the Stoughton Public Schools will tolerate anti-Semitism but punish teachers who speak out against it.”

Gross told The Algemeiner that while LDB was still reviewing Regan and Moll’s cases, “to the extent that they are punished for discussing the incident, the same First Amendment standards apply.”

“Ms. Moll is punished for describing the incident as hate speech, when the school district claims that it was ‘neither hate speech nor a hate crime,'” Gross added. “First, we think the school district has conflated ‘hate speech’ and ‘hate crime.’ The two terms describe different things, and hate speech that does not involve conduct is generally not a crime, and is often protected by the First Amendment.”

“But, while it may not have been criminal, the swastika and the reference to ‘the way they burned the Jews’ is clearly hate speech, in our view,” she added. “And if Ms. Moll expressed that view when asked about the incident, we not only agree with her position, but we also stand behind her right to express it. The First Amendment certainly guarantees the right to speak out against anti-Semitism and other forms of bigotry — including hate speech.”

Representatives for Stoughton Public Schools did not respond to requests for comment by press time.

Share this Story: Share On Facebook Share On Twitter Email This Article

Let your voice be heard!

Join the Algemeiner
  • Lin Olson

    The people running this school and going after these teachers, for doing the right thing, need to be fired. They are part of the problem, not the solution.

  • Reb_Yaakov

    The treatment of teachers in the U.S. is deplorable. We are seeing the same thing in teaching as we’ve seen in the healthcare system with regard to doctors and nurses: you have an environment in which no one decent would want to participate, so the decent ones have all left. The machines seem to go on whirring and buzzing and cranking and moving, so the hoi polloi think everything is fine, but the reality is that they’re about as productive as Rube Goldberg machines. The difference, though, is that, with Rube Goldberg machines, what’s not to love? With these other machines, what’s not to hate?

  • cbusa

    Not the first time this school and administrator have done this. They were involved in two prior swastika incidents this year. In both cases, the teachers were disciplined for speaking to their students or other teachers about anti-Semitism. One teacher was suspended for 20 days for rescinding a college recommendation letter for one of the offending students. Further, Rizzi brought in a civil rights attorney – not to address the acts of hatred against Jewish students – but to protect the perpetrator from “hostile actions” by the faculty!