Friday, June 22nd | 9 Tammuz 5778


Be in the know!

Get our exclusive daily news briefing.

March 7, 2018 3:32 pm

Despite Security Assurances, Polish Concerns that Holocaust Law Will Damage Ties With US Linger

avatar by Ben Cohen

Email a copy of "Despite Security Assurances, Polish Concerns that Holocaust Law Will Damage Ties With US Linger" to a friend

Polish President Andrzej Duda (r) welcomes US President Donald Trump to Poland in July 2017. Photo: Reuters / Carlos Barria.

Poland’s widely-condemned legislation on the commemoration of the Nazi Holocaust will not impact vital security relations with the United States, American officials confirmed on Tuesday — but those reassurances have not allayed concerns in Warsaw that the Institute of National Remembrance (IPN) Act, which criminalizes public discussion of Polish collusion with the Nazi authorities during World War II, is placing an uncomfortable strain on the alliance with the US.

In an article on Wednesday for Rzeczpospolita, one of Poland’s leading newspapers, commentator Michał Szułdrzyński charged that Poland’s conservative government had placed the country in its “most serious diplomatic crisis for 27 years” as a result of the new law.

Arguing that Poland’s very existence depended on its alliance with the US, Szułdrzyński asked: “Is the IPN law…worth the price of our security?”

At Tuesday’s State Department briefing, spokesperson Heather Nauert confirmed that media reports “that allege any kind of a suspension in security cooperation or high-level dialogue” because of the legislation were “simply false.”

Related coverage

June 21, 2018 7:36 pm

Pulitzer-Winning Conservative Jewish Commentator Charles Krauthammer Dies at 68

Pulitzer Prize winner Charles Krauthammer, who gave up a psychiatric career to become one of the leading conservative political commentators...

“Poland is a close NATO ally, that hasn’t changed,” Nauert said. “People are trying to find distance or space between our longstanding relationship, and there is no space there.”

However, Nauert stressed that US objections to the Holocaust legislation remained intact. “We’ve made our disagreements, our disappointment with that legislation clear,” she said.

Szułdrzyński argued in his article that the legislation could yet compromise diplomatic ties with the US. He said that Polish diplomats had falsely assured their American counterparts that the more radical measures of the IPN Act would be amended by the country’s Senate, and that he now feared that Poland’s image in the eyes of the US Congress would be damaged.

“How can we expect serious treatment from a partner whom we do not ourselves treat seriously?” he asked.

Claims of a freeze in US-Polish ties originated on the website, which cited a memo from the Polish Embassy in Washington as the source of its report. One senior Polish official, Jacek Sasin, said on Wednesday that the report was evidence that an “informational war is being waged at the moment against the Polish government.”

Share this Story: Share On Facebook Share On Twitter Email This Article

Let your voice be heard!

Join the Algemeiner
  • Zev Sero

    This article’s premise is a lie. The law does not “criminalize public discussion of Polish collusion with the Nazi authorities during World War II”. It criminalizes falsely attributing such collusion to the Polish nation or to Poles as a whole. It requires treating it the same way as Jewish or Dutch collusion, which certainly existed but which is never attributed to the nation as a whole.

    • Dafydd

      It is still a false equivalence, I think, to compare Jewish and Dutch collusion with that of the Poles. Of course Holland had collaborators, but the level of anti semitism in Holland is nowhere near as visceral and violent as that of so many Poles. Besides the anti semitic rhetoric of the Polish media and Government makes historical debate superfluous. It is what Poland currently IS that is disturbing