Making Beautiful Food and Music: The Philadelphia Orchestra’s Trip to Israel
JNS.org – A delegation of 60 donors from the Philadelphia Jewish Federation traveled to Israel this month with the Philadelphia Orchestra, which played three concerts there from June 1 to June 7. Wildly popular Israeli-American chef Michael Solomonov, best known for his award-winning cookbooks and acclaimed restaurants in Philadelphia, also accompanied the tour.
David Gold, a member of the Jewish Federation of Greater Philadelphia’s Board of Trustees, told JNS the trip was an example “of how Philadelphia has become a center of extraordinary Jewish communal life in America.”
Gold maintained that what distinguishes the Philadelphia Federation from other Jewish federations in North America is its success in simultaneously building and funding its Jewish community, co-branding itself with the likes of the local symphony, building cultural ties with non-Jews, combating BDS, and finding creative ways to support Israel.
This creativity, said Melissa Greenberg, Chief Development Officer of the Jewish Federation of Greater Philadelphia, led to the idea of this multifaceted trip that included Solomonov, Federation philanthropists, and musicians who had never been to Israel. “Both music and food reflect humanity; [they] tie people back to the essence of Israel and its people,” she said.
Similarly, said Gold, “The Jewish Federation of Greater Philadelphia … has enabled the orchestra to visit Israel for the first time in almost 30 years.”
A different kind of diplomacy
Ryan Fleur, interim president of the Philadelphia Orchestra, told JNS that the goals of performing in Israel were “returning to a country that has a deep history with and connection to classical music — from Toscanini leading the first performance of what was to become the Israel Philharmonic to Leonard Bernstein’s 40-year relationship with the country, fulfilling our purpose of people-to-people exchange, letting music speak across cultural divides and language barriers to promote mutual understanding, strengthening the bonds between Philadelphia’s Jewish community and Israel,” and more.
According to Fleur, the musicians found the country to be “welcoming” and “beautiful,” with the people “extraordinarily appreciative” — a different perspective than the BDS movement seeks to portray.
Gold reported that the orchestra had seen BDS activists on the streets of Philadelphia, where two people desecrated an Israeli flag on Benjamin Franklin Parkway in the city’s center. They also saw BDS activists in Europe during the lead-up to the Israel leg of their trip and experienced a disruption of their concert in Brussels.
Solomonov too experienced anti-Israel confrontations, such as when some people argued with him that Israeli cuisine does not exist and the country culturally appropriates other nations’ food traditions. In April, Solomonov experienced criticism for hosting a dinner with Reem Kassis, author of The Palestinian Table, in which Palestinian dishes were highlighted at his restaurant Zahav in celebration of Kassis’ new cookbook.
“While I am proud to work in an industry where there is a focus on change, when you start putting limitations on food, that’s ridiculous. To say there is no Israeli cuisine is an argument to say that Israel doesn’t have the right to exist,” he told JNS.
Solomonov explained that Israeli cuisine is defined by the embodiment of what it means to be local, and like Israel itself is a gathering of the exiles in which the Diaspora is continually introducing new foods to the Israel palate. “It’s something that’s happening in real time,” he said, adding that new immigrants to Israel, such as Ethiopians and Georgians, are influencing the way that people cook.
“To simply say Israel is 70 years old is half of the story,” emphasized the chef. “We have the ancient holidays and laws of kashrut that have influenced our cooking. We have microclimates all over the country that influences the cuisine. Years ago, Jews were pushed out of countries like Yemen, Morocco, Bulgaria, Spain, and Turkey, and each Jewish community has its own cuisine that has transformed over the years and come together to create Israeli cuisine.”
Such food is especially unique, he said, because of this connectivity of cultures. “A course of salatim [small salads and dishes that are shared together] includes so many countries of the world on one little table. In a moment where there’s conflict, the food is OK to be together, and it’s even celebrated together, which is a hopeful message.”
Still, Solomonov noted that his choice to join the trip was not a response to anti-Israel criticism, but rather a new form of diplomacy. “The Israel that I appreciate is pro-progress, pro-inclusion, and pro-celebration of many cultures — and that culture makes Israeli cuisine what it is.”
Fleur said that music fosters a comparable sentiment.
“Cultural diplomacy occurs when we are making music through the three full orchestra performances in Israel, master classes, chamber performances, and other residency activities,” he said. “The orchestra connected with citizens of diverse backgrounds. At the Oasis of Peace, we engaged with Jewish and Palestinian Arab citizens. Other events and concerts had diverse audiences from North Africa, the former Soviet Union, and Ethiopia. And the US State Department subsidized concert tickets for students from Lod, Jerusalem, Beersheva, and Kfar Saba.”
Like music, Solomonov maintains that food is a great tool for bringing people together and facilitating cultural diplomacy.