False Apartheid Claims Follow Passage of Israel’s Nation-State Law
Anti-Israel groups in the United States are using a recently passed Israeli law to ramp up false claims of apartheid. Israel’s new “nation-state” law defines Israel as “the national home of the Jewish people” with Jerusalem as its capital.
“Israel arrogantly enshrines Jim Crow laws,” the Students for Justice in Palestine (SJP) chapter at New York’s New School blasted on Facebook.
“Apartheid is a legal term, not an insult. It’s the most suitable label to describe Israel’s treatment of millions of Palestinians over the last seven decades,” read a graphic shared on Facebook by the radical anti-Israel group Jewish Voice for Peace (JVP).
“What this law really does is it enshrines racisms and discrimination and like you said apartheid into the foundational constitutional law of the State of Israel,” JVP Executive Director Rebecca Vilkomerson said in an interview with MSNBC’s Ayman Mohyeldin. “So that means the 20 percent of Israeli citizens who are not Jewish are being told, and the state is actually now obligated with this law, to treat them unequally.”
“Formalizing de facto apartheid, the Israeli Knesset passes the racist nation-state law, which officially designates Palestinian citizens of Israel … along with all other Palestinians living in historic Palestine under Israeli sovereign power — as second-class citizens,” claimed Columbia University’s SJP chapter.
Apartheid is a term used by anti-Israel activists and groups to smear and delegitimize Israel. But in Israel — and unlike apartheid South Africa — both Jewish and non-Jewish Israelis receive full voting rights, hold elected office, serve in the military and prominently on Israeli courts, and can own and operate private businesses of all kinds.
The nation-state bill passed the Knesset in a 62-55 vote. Israel’s Druze community voiced concern over the bill. But President Reuven Rivlin assured a delegation “that is the basis of the state we founded — the Zionist movement in full partnership with all who live here in this good land, which is good for all of us and where we can exist in equality without any problem.”
Still, the bill’s passage prompted Stanford University SJP member Hamzeh Daoud, a residential assistant, to threaten to “physically fight” pro-Israel students. He later changed the wording in his Facebook post from “physically” to “intellectually,” and noted that “I edited this post because I realize intellectually beating Zionists is the only way to go. Physical fighting is never an answer to when trying to prove people wrong.”
Both Daoud’s Facebook and Twitter accounts have since been deactivated.
Most analyses conclude that the new Israeli law is more symbolic than substantial. It does nothing to change the rights of Israeli Arabs, although many are displeased at its recognition of Hebrew as the country’s official language, seeing it as downgrading Arabic.
People are free to criticize Israel and the bill. But it’s clear that groups like SJP and JVP will do anything to bash Israel and delegitimize its existence.
Ariel Behar is a writer and blogger at the Investigative Project on Terrorism.