Israelis Pay More for Basic Necessities
CTech – Ahead of the country’s general election set for September 17, the Israeli government has been boasting lower prices of goods and services, allegedly brought on by actively encouraging competition in the free market. However, while some products — mostly those targeting higher socio-economic classes — did become cheaper in recent years, Israel is still among the most expensive countries in the OECD.
In the past few weeks, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s Likud party launched an online ad campaign targeting Israelis that have landed abroad on vacation. In the video ads, Netanyahu greets passengers, claiming the flight was cheap “thanks to the Likud’s Open Skies reform.”
What the ads fail to mention is how expensive day-to-day life in Israel really is. Calcalist examined four basic parameters to see how Israel compares to its OECD counterparts when it comes to costs of living — food, housing, education, and healthcare.
Food: prices 19 percent higher than OECD average
Unlike the price of flights, which most Israelis are affected by only once or twice a year (if at all), the high price of food has a daily impact. Despite having dropped by five percent within two years, food prices in Israel are still 19 percent higher than the OECD average, according to a report released by the organization in March 2018. The report criticized the Israeli market for being less competitive and less inviting for imports than the OECD standard, blaming these factors for high food prices.
In another report on agricultural policies released in March, the OECD also criticized governmental support of agriculture, which costs Israeli consumers NIS 5 billion (approximately $141 million) a year.
According to the report, Israelis pay 16 percent more than the OECD average on agricultural produce, while the state is charging high tariffs on imports of lamb, eggs, fruit, and certain vegetables. In some cases the situation is even worse: Israelis pay 65 percent more than the OECD average on chicken and 101 percent more on bananas.
Housing: 160 monthly salaries required to buy an apartment
In 2006, Israelis needed a sum equivalent to 100 average monthly salaries in order to buy an apartment. In 2018, they needed 160 average salaries, according to OECD data.
During a visit to Israel last year, Willem Adema, a senior economist for the OECD, presented data he collected on the local housing market. According to Ademe, people who live in a rented apartment in Israel spend 25 percent of their gross adjusted disposable income on rent while homeowners paying mortgages spend 15 percent, a gap that is among the highest in the organization.
As people who can afford a mortgage are often better off than those renting the apartments they live in, this gap means a substantial burden on those coming from lower socio-economic backgrounds. Of Israelis in the lowest quintile who rent apartments, 55 percent spend more than 40 percent of their gross adjusted disposable income on rent, compared to an OECD average of 45 percent of people in the lowest quintile, the data showed.
According to data from Israel’s Central Bureau of Statistics, since Netanyahu took office in 2009, the price of housing rose by over 90 percent while the general inflation rate only grew by approximately 12.3 percent.
Education: most expensive preschools in the OECD
Not including taxes, Israeli parents pay, out of their own pockets, 0.31 percent of the country’s gross domestic product (GDP) on preschool education for their children, making it the most expensive among OECD countries. For comparison, in France, Italy, and Ireland, parents respectively spend 0.05 percent, 0.072 percent, and 0.0 percent of their countries’ GDP on preschool education.
Private spending on schools, from first to twelfth grade, amounts to about 0.47 percent of Israel’s GDP, compared with an OECD average of 0.32 percent.
Since 2009, education prices in Israel have been on the rise: academic studies are now 17 percent more expensive, as is elementary school education; preschool education prices rose by 14 percent; informal education and summer school prices rose by 13 percent; and junior high and high school costs went up by about 10 percent; all compared to a 12.3 percent rise in the general inflation rate.
Healthcare: just eight percent of the population settles for public healthcare
As Israel’s public healthcare system continues to struggle, many Israelis find themselves supplementing the country’s mandatory universal medical insurance with out-of-pocket private policies. Private or supplementary insurance, provided by the country’s health maintenance organizations (HMOs), are acquired by 92 percent of Israelis, according to a report published in May by Jerusalem-based social research institute the Myers-JDC-Brookdale Institute. More than half of Israelis (54 percent) have both private and supplementary insurance. Among OECD countries, Israel is second only to France in the portion of the population that supplements its universal medical insurance with private services.
According to Israel’s Central Bureau of Statistics, Israelis spent NIS 11 billion (approximately $3.1 billion) on private or supplementary insurance in 2018, compared to about NIS 6 billion (approximately $1.7 billion) a decade earlier.
Of all medical expenses in Israel, 36 percent are out-of-pocket funds paid by patients in addition to taxes, including the mandatory health tax, compared to an OECD average of 26 percent. This may explain why in Israel the average annual spending per patient is relatively low: only $2,820, a large portion of which comes directly from the patient’s pocket, compared to an OECD average of $4,070.
Since Netanyahu took office in April 2009 and as of early 2019, medical insurance prices, both public and private, grew by 31.6 percent, compared to an accumulated general inflation rate of 12.3 percent.