Thursday, September 16th | 10 Tishri 5782

May 6, 2020 7:42 am

What Apartheid?

avatar by James Sinkinson /


An anti-Israel “apartheid wall” on display at Columbia University during Apartheid Week in 2017. Photo: Facebook.

JNS.orgAn Israeli mother recently posted on her Facebook page a photo of Muslim-Israeli and Jewish-Israeli healthcare professionals dancing together at a staff function at Jerusalem’s Hadassah Hospital, with the caption: “How dare anyone call my country an apartheid state? If Jews are so horrible to Muslims, why do they work here, send their children to Israeli schools and dance with us? These Muslims are happy and thriving in Israel.”

Indeed, a new poll by the Jewish People Policy Institute provides proof that most non-Jewish Israelis identify with Israel — not the Palestinians — and are content living there. Here are some facts:

A massive majority (85%) of non-Jews in Israel feel comfortable being themselves in Israel.

Fully 23% of non-Jews in Israel identify as Israeli (up from 5% in 2019), and 51% identify as Arab Israeli (up from 48% last year) — that’s 74% who have a positive Israeli identity.

A paltry 7% of non-Jews in Israel identify as “Palestinian,” down from 18% just last year.

Some 91% of non-Jews disagree that to be a “real Israeli” one must be Jewish.

If Israel’s Arabs are increasingly assuming an Israeli identity, how can proponents of BDS accuse Israel of being an apartheid state?

First, the Israel-haters don’t say that Arab Israelis are second-class citizens — because that’s indisputably false. Rather, it’s because, strangely, instead of supporting the right (and responsibility) of the Palestinian people to determine their own destiny, the BDS crowd holds Israel responsible for Palestinian destiny.

The BDSers argue that Israel and the Trump peace proposal seek to isolate the Palestinians into small areas, either disconnected from one another or linked only by narrow land bridges. This argument is absurd, of course.

The United Nations, Israel, and the United States have proposed a completely integrated Palestinian state in 97% of Judea and Samaria (the West Bank), plus Gaza — with a capital in Jerusalem — numerous times. However, the Palestinians have rejected this opportunity for sovereignty every single time.

As geopolitics have changed dramatically since Israel’s last peace proposal in 2008 — with the growth of the Islamic State, Hamas’ seizure of Gaza, the Syrian civil war, and Iran’s takeover of the Lebanese terror group Hezbollah and increased imperialism in the Middle East — Israel’s willingness to risk allowing yet another avowed enemy to be created on its borders has understandably vanished.

But that is precisely the threatening option Israel faces. Both the Palestinian Authority in Judea and Samaria and Hamas in the Gaza Strip obstinately refuse to recognize the Jewish state, and both have continued their incitement to terrorist violence against Israeli civilians for decades.

In the meantime, in recent years Israelis have increasingly expanded or established new communities in Judea and Samaria, their ancient Jewish homeland. Today some half a million Israelis live in these disputed territories. Remember, these are not “Palestinian territories” — the Palestinians have never had sovereignty over an inch of the Holy Land.

Jewish communities in Judea and Samaria help create more living space for Israel’s rapidly growing population, now over nine million. They also increase Israel’s security, which has always been precarious. Current borders leave Israel with a narrow geographical “waist” of just nine miles in width between the Mediterranean and Jerusalem’s eastern city limits — making it virtually indefensible.

In short, the arc of recent Middle East history, coupled with Palestinian recalcitrance, has simply forced previous offers of a Palestinian state — in all of Judea and Samaria, connected with Gaza — to be taken off the table. Past offers will not be repeated.

At the same time, Arabs living within Israel have grown comfortable with the equality, liberty, professional opportunities, and prosperity they enjoy as Israeli citizens. Who would not? Israel has become one of the most successful nations on earth, let alone among those only 72 (or even 100) years old. For most Arabs living in Israel, it’s a dream come true — with advantages unattainable anywhere in the Middle East or in most other parts of the world.

Israel’s two million-plus Arab citizens are simply the most economically successful and politically free Arabs on earth. As they further embrace their Israeli identity, their lot only continues to improve. On the other hand, Israel’s neighboring states (Egypt, Syria, Lebanon, Iraq, Yemen, Turkey), and non-state entities such as Hamas and the Palestinian Authority, have either disintegrated or become increasingly belligerent, or both.

In short, Israel does not owe the Palestinian Arabs a state, especially when over decades and after billions of dollars of international aid, they have failed to build a political and economic infrastructure capable of supporting one. Especially when they have rejected every offer from Israel and the United States of land for peace. Especially when they continue to promote Israel’s destruction.

If the Palestinians are left with ever-diminishing territory — or discrete enclaves — in Judea and Samaria, this is not apartheid. Rather, it’s the natural result of shrinking possibilities due to one fact only: The failure of Palestinian leaders to seize the many generous opportunities history has presented to them.

James Sinkinson is President of Facts and Logic About the Middle East (FLAME), which publishes educational messages to correct lies and misperceptions about Israel and its relationship to the United States.

The opinions presented by Algemeiner bloggers are solely theirs and do not represent those of The Algemeiner, its publishers or editors. If you would like to share your views with a blog post on The Algemeiner, please be in touch through our Contact page.

Share this Story: Share On Facebook Share On Twitter

Let your voice be heard!

Join the Algemeiner

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.