Amid a Spate of Antisemitic Attacks, Orange County Muslim Leader Incites More Hatred
A Southern California imam called Israelis “child killers” and urged Muslims to “sacrifice whatever resources we can in defense of that land,” in a talk live-streamed last Thursday on YouTube.
Ata is a Foundation board member. He also serves on the Islamic Shura Council of Southern California‘s board. The Council includes 74 Southern California mosques and Islamist organizations, including local chapters of the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR), Muslim Students Association (MSA) and the Muslim Public Affairs Council (MPAC).
“And so we see our brothers and sisters in Jerusalem defending [the Al Aqsa Mosque],” he said in the live-stream. “…They’re putting their life on the line, men and women. Standing, shielding [the Al Aqsa Mosque] from that apartheid regime. The Israeli soldiers. The IDF. The child killers. And they’re willing to sacrifice their blood.”
Ata claimed he was “not calling people to go and sacrifice themselves, spill their blood to attack anyone,” but he repeatedly demonized Israelis and their supporters, while offering some absurd fantasy talk painting Muslims as the only people who treat Jews well.
Ata never mentioned Hamas, nor uttered anything about the terrorist group and its cohorts firing 4,000 rockets at Israeli civilian communities. Most of those rockets, as well as the launchers and other components of the Hamas arsenal, are stored or launched in neighborhoods, apartment buildings, schools, office buildings — including those where journalists work — placing every civilian in Gaza, including children, directly in harm’s way.
Israel’s choice is either to retaliate and risk civilian casualties, or let the rocket fire continue, placing its own civilians in danger.
Using civilians as human shields is a war crime under the Geneva Conventions.
He also made no mention of the estimated 20 percent of Hamas rockets that fell short of their targets, causing an unknown number of the child casualties in Gaza.
Instead, he incited more hatred by referring to “this Nazi-like apartheid, racist, aggressive, tyrannical, vicious, child-killing Zionist entity.”
His language mirrors what attackers shouted when hunting down Jewish diners in Los Angeles last week.
“At one point before the attack, which later escalated to kicking and punching, a person can be heard yelling, ‘Israel kills children!'”, The Los Angeles Times reported. A witness said the attackers also shouted “Death to Jews” and “Free Palestine.”
In a separate incident on Monday night, a man walking home from his synagogue was chased by men in two cars waving Palestinian flags and shouting Allahu Akhbar, Fox News reported.
Ata’s vision leaves little room for peaceful co-existence.
“And so we as Muslims see that land as an Islamic land,” he said, “as a land that is integral to our Islamic identity. And so, regardless of what your languages, what your ethnicity is, what your background is, what your culture is, what your heritage is — if you identify as a Muslim, then Jerusalem must be part of your hearts. There’s no way around it. And this is why we we’ll never give it up. This is why we will never forget about it. This is why we will sacrifice whatever resources we can in defense of that land.”
He also painted a patently false image of Jews finding protectors among Muslims, both historically and today.
“There’s only when the Muslims entered that land did you find Muslims, Jews and Christians with equal populations, populations equal in size,” Ata said. “Living there peacefully, each religion. Each member of that religion will go to their holy sites, worship in peace and tranquility without worry of oppression and aggression from a tyrannical force. Only Muslims have done this.”
This is manifestly false. Israel has also agreed to allow the Al-Aqsa mosque to remain in the hands of the Islamic Waqf, an Islamic trust, run by Palestinian and Jordanian clerics. While there have been tensions and clashes there, it has remained open for prayer.
The Western Wall, revered by Jews worldwide as the only remaining part of the second Temple, was barred to Jews from 1948-67, when Jordan controlled eastern Jerusalem. The area in front of the Western Wall was used as a garbage dump to humiliate Jews.
Jews were treated relatively well for some major periods under Muslim rule. But they were officially designated as second-class citizens, subject to a dhimmi tax.
But Ata’s false history continued.
“Because again, history shows, history speaks,” he said. “Muslims, never oppressed Jews. Muslims never attacked Jews. Muslims were never uncomfortable with Jews. And it’s not just history that speaks. Current time speak. You know, there are Jews in Morocco, Jews in Yemen, Jews in Iraq. and Jews in Iran. Do you ever hear about Muslims oppressing them? You ever hear about Muslims attacking them? Not at all.”
This is pure historical fiction. According to a World Jewish Congress study, Jews living in Muslim countries were subject to murderous pogroms during the 20th century, along with massive wholesale confiscation of their properties, arbitrary arrests, and expulsion.
The Jewish population in Muslim-majority states like Iraq, Iran and Yemen dwindled from more than 1 million people in 1948 to less than 5,000 by 2012 because of massive Islamist antisemitism.
It is so safe for Jews in Yemen that the Israeli government launched a secret operation in 2016 to sneak some of the few remaining Jews out of the country. A CNN report described Yemen as, “increasingly hostile to the small Jewish population.”
“Hundreds of Jews were cut down by sword and rifle, some decapitated. Babies were sliced in half and thrown into the Tigris river,” Black writes. “Girls were raped in front of their parents. Parents were mercilessly killed in front of their children. Hundreds of Jewish homes and businesses were looted, then burned.”
Ata, therefore, is ignorant of history, or is purposely spreading false information.
“This isn’t an issue between Islam and Judaism,” he said. “It’s an issue between Muslims and this Zionist apartheid state, the child killers.”
Ata’s emphasis on “child killers” not only disregards the role Hamas plays in placing children at risk, but also ignores the extraordinary effort the IDF makes to avoid civilian casualties in the first place. Before a building is targeted, warning shots are fired to give people time to get out. Often, building owners and managers are called directly to give them a chance to get everyone inside to safety.
It doesn’t always work, as this video shown by Australia’s Sky News shows.
“We want to die,” said a Palestinian after being warned about an impending bombing. “If the children need to die, then they’ll die. This is how we reveal your cruelty.”
It sure would be good if some religious leader spoke to that guy about the value of children’s lives.
Research Analyst Teri Blumenfeld contributed to this report.
Steven Emerson is Executive Director of the Investigative Project on Terrorism (www.investigativeproject.org)