Saturday, April 1st | 10 Nisan 5783

February 10, 2023 11:57 am

Is Israel Becoming a ‘Theocracy’? Hardly.

× [contact-form-7 404 "Not Found"]

avatar by Jeremy Rosen


A general view shows the plenum at the Knesset, Israel’s parliament, in Jerusalem. Photo: REUTERS/Ronen Zvulun

In the political polemic of our times, language is often a victim, as people use words loosely, inaccurately, and without thinking of their significance or meaning. The most obvious is how the term Nazi is applied to anyone or any idea that one does not like.

There is a lot of talk about Israel becoming a theocracy. But what exactly do we mean by a theocracy? If a theocracy means that religions influence the affairs of the state, this happens in many countries.

In Britain, the monarch is still the Head of the Church of England, which has certain privileges such as bishops sitting in the House of Lords, and state funding for the church and religious schools. The United States talks far more than Britain does about being “One Nation Under God.” Despite the separation of state and religion on paper, religions get preferential tax treatment and other benefits. States make laws based on the influence of different religious minorities within them. Does that make the United States a theocracy?

Afghanistan and Iran are examples of complete theocracies. But have we reached a stage in Israel where the religious parties have or are likely to have an absolute say on what goes on in every area of national life? Israel indeed describes itself as a Jewish state. But this is no worse than those countries whose populations are mainly Christian, Muslim, Hindu, Buddhist, or Shinto and recognize those faiths’ significance.

Related coverage

March 31, 2023 11:29 am

Why Our Thoughts Can Change Reality

In a 2014 interview for the Huffington Post, the late Rabbi Lord Jonathan Sacks said something incredibly profound: “Our thoughts...

In the ancient world, kings were the representatives of the gods and worked together (most of the time) with priests. Many of the Biblical Judges were not religious leaders. Some were gangsters. The Judean kings were subject to the “constitution” of the Torah in theory. But most of them were perfectly happy worshiping other gods and abandoning their own. And we won’t even mention the kings of Israel.

The emperor Constantine made Christianity the state religion of the Roman empire. And that was how it remained, except for a brief interlude when the emperor Julian tried to return the empire to sanity and freedom of religious practice. And the blessed Goths, Vandals, and Visigoths returned to the good old pagan days for a while.

The Holy Roman Empire was an example of the Pope controlling the monarchs. You might have heard of the famous humiliation of the emperor Henry the 4th, whom Pope Gregory 4th in 1077 threatened to excommunicate unless he submitted to his authority. In practice, the church was often in control until the time of Napoleon. And even he made a concordat with the Catholic Church to keep it quiet. Was he a theocrat?

Judaism lost its independence and Jews lived under other rulers for 2,000 years. The most significant example of Jewish self-rule under Christianity the Council of the Four Lands in Poland and Lithuania during the 16th and 17th centuries. Each community sent three representatives to their meetings, a rabbi and two leaders. Decisions were taken by majority vote. Was that a theocracy?

As for those who fear a religious takeover, just look at the religious world in Israel — so fractious, competitive, and argumentative. Each Chassidic dynasty is either divided or in competition with the other. The Lithuanians do not get on with the mystics or the Sephardim with the Ashkenazim. The religious nationalists don’t get on with Satmar, who doesn’t even deign to participate in political life. The so-called religious parties always split and often will not work with each other. Do you really think they will all come together to rule as a theocracy? They wouldn’t be able to choose a Sanhedrin.

I would like to see the separation of religion and state. But even if religion has a say in the life of the country, there is still plenty of freedom and ways around restrictions. Most of the present Knesset is not orthodox. Haifa and Tel Aviv now probably have as many non-kosher restaurants as kosher ones, and local municipalities make their own rules on many religious issues.

Don’t panic. And even if the Messiah does come, most Israelis won’t recognize him (or her)!

The author is a writer and rabbi, currently based in New York.

The opinions presented by Algemeiner bloggers are solely theirs and do not represent those of The Algemeiner, its publishers or editors. If you would like to share your views with a blog post on The Algemeiner, please be in touch through our Contact page.

Share this Story: Share On Facebook Share On Twitter

Let your voice be heard!

Join the Algemeiner

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.