South African U-19 star cricketer David Teeger. Photo: Screenshot

South African Jewish leaders on Tuesday encountered frustration after a meeting with Cricket South Africa (CSA) — the sport’s governing body in the country — failed to restore the captaincy of the U-19 national team to David Teeger, the Jewish player who was stripped of his role just one week before the commencement of the Cricket World Cup on Friday amid accusations of antisemitism.

At an online press conference, Prof. Karen Milner — the national chair of the South African Jewish Board of Deputies (SAJBD) — relayed that the group’s meeting with CSA board chair Lawson Naidoo and other members of the executive over the decision had resulted in a stalemate, with virtually no points of mutual understanding between the two sides.

Teeger’s removal from the U-19 captaincy was the consequence, according to last week’s CSA statement, of its concern “that protests related to the war in Gaza can be anticipated at the venues for the tournament.”

It added that such protests would likely focus on Teeger — an observant Jew and resident of Johannesburg who made his professional cricket debut in 2023, scoring an impressive 51 runs for the South Africa Emerging Players side against North Cape. Teeger was only appointed to the captaincy of the U-19 team last month.

The targeting of Teeger could result “in conflict or even violence between rival groups of protesters,” CSA said. Invoking its “duty to safeguard the interests and safety of all those involved in the World Cup,” it said that Teeger had been “relieved of the captaincy … in the best interests of the players, the U-19 team, and David himself.” Teeger would “remain an important and active member of the team and we wish him and the team every success in the tournament,” CSA concluded.

Teeger first became a target for the vocal pro-Hamas movement in South Africa just weeks after the Oct. 7 pogrom in southern Israel. Receiving an award at a Jewish communal ceremony that same month, Teeger dedicated it to “the State of Israel and every single soldier fighting so that we can live and thrive in the diaspora.”

Despite the opprobrium these comments generated, an independent inquiry concluded that Teeger had not violated any of CSA’s rules or regulations with his comments, clearing his way to be appointed as captain.

At Tuesday’s press conference, Zev Krengel, SAJBD’s vice-president, insisted that CSA’s invocation of security concerns was a “ruse” to cover its determination to remove Teeger as team captain despite the inquiry’s findings. He asserted that CSA’s reasoning had continually shifted, with an initial focus on Teeger’s well-being. But after Teeger made clear his desire to remain as captain, CSA then raised the welfare of the team overall, going on to argue that there was a risk of violence between police and protesters at the World Cup in the event that he led the side.

Krengel also pointed out that CSA had initially said it had received a security report. However, when the SAJBD asked for a copy, they were told that the information had in fact been delivered as a “briefing.” When asked who had provided the briefing, CSA refused to answer.

“They tried to get David to step down voluntarily, saying ‘it’ll be hard for you.’ He refused and that’s when they stripped him,” Krengel said.

Krengel added that the decision was “pure antisemitism.”

“This smells of the 1936 Olympics” in Berlin, he said, referring to when two athletes from the US team, Marty Glickman and Sam Stoller, were abruptly withdrawn from the 4×100 meter relay on the official grounds that they were not fast enough, although the consensus among  historians is that they were replaced so as not to offend Nazi leader Adolf Hitler with the sight of Jewish athletes competing.

“When asked who gave the briefing they refused to tell us. They admit there’s no security report,” Krengel said. “So there’s only two options, antisemitism at CSA or massive political interference from the ANC.”

South Africa’s ruling African National Congress (ANC) has been one of the leaders of the political charge against Israel over the last three months, bringing a case before the International Court of Justice (ICJ) accusing the Jewish state of committing “genocide” in its military response to the Oct. 7 atrocities perpetrated by Hamas.

Milner said that CSA had “found an excuse to exclude a young Jewish cricketer, to strip him of his honors in the most hurtful and humiliating way four days before the start of the tournament.” She reported that the meeting had closed with a CSA board member suggesting that they should “agree to disagree.”

“The SAJBD cannot agree to disagree when issues of antisemitism are at stake,” she stated. She added that the SAJBD would continue to demand Teeger’s reinstatement, emphasizing that there was “no way this can be resolved without that.” Separately, Krengel said that when he asked the CSA board whether they could agree that a Jew being removed from the captaincy was a “sad day” for South African cricket, his interlocutors again refused to answer.

Krengel said the SAJBD would now approach the International Cricket Council (ICC), the sport’s global governing body, to call out CSA’s act of “discrimination.”

“If the ICC does nothing about it, it will be a black mark against the ICC as the 1936 Olympics were a black mark for the International Olympic Committee,” he said.

However, the ICC on Tuesday said it was unable to step into the controversy.

“Team selection including captaincy is an issue for members and not the ICC,” a spokesperson said. “An international federation is not constituted to intervene in team selections.”