Judges Altman (left) and Scola (right). Photo: Ayelet Raymond.

During a recent discussion in Florida, two judges delved into International Humanitarian Law and the laws of war from an Israeli perspective, focusing specifically on the October 7 Hamas massacre.

Judge Roy Altman, the youngest District Court judge ever appointed in the Southern District of Florida, and Senior Judge Robert Scola of the Florida Southern District Court, reflected on an educational trip to Israel that included 14 Federal judges. They also discussed the personal impact of witnessing the aftermath of the October 7th massacre, focusing on the historical significance and the power of human resilience.

Judge Altman shared his personal experiences witnessing the tragedy at Kibbutz Be’eri, located three kilometers from the Gaza border. Over 120 homes were damaged or destroyed, resulting in approximately 100 lives lost, and 40 hostages taken from their homes into Gaza. The community had been known for its progressive beliefs in fostering peace by aiding Palestinians through initiatives like offering employment opportunities and medical assistance.

During their visit to Israel, the judges also honored the victims of the Nova festival massacre, and saw the devastation of the attack firsthand. Judge Altman shared a poignant moment when a grieving mother, overwhelmed by inconsolable sorrow for her lost son, was gently guided away from a memorial mound by her family members.

Amid the sorrow and grief, the judges were uplifted by a group of 50 women who were singing Hatikvah arm in arm. They invited them to join.

Judge Altman said, “In the spot where more Jews were butchered than at any other place on Earth since the Holocaust, these women had left whatever they were doing that day and driven two hours on a bus to the South to sing not of vengeance or vindictiveness or hatred, but of hope — hope for each other, hope for the country, hope for the land for which they and their ancestors had fought for thousands of years. A people who are deserving of our love, our admiration, and our support.”

Judge Scola, who is not Jewish, expressed his gratitude for his first visit to Israel, highlighting the warm reception from Israelis towards US government officials. He was also impressed by the unity and resilience of the Jewish people.

“Whether in the Diaspora or in Israel, when faced with an existential external threat, Israelis from all political persuasions — left, right, and center — understand the importance of setting aside their political divisions and focusing on their survival,” Scola shared.

Judge Scola viewed a 47-minute video of the Hamas massacre that left him deeply traumatized. He said that it “was the longest 47 minutes of my life.” The horror of inhumanity and the evident joy displayed by the terrorists while mercilessly slaughtering innocent civilians left a lasting impression on him.

Reflecting on their trip honoring the memory of all the October 7 victims, survivors, and their families, the judges said that it served as a testament to recognizing the resilience and spirit of the Israeli people in the face of adversity, and that they were proud to stand with the Israeli people.

Ayelet Raymond is an Israel activist, and the creative force behind the @Kosher Barbie character and social media personality.