New York Times Issues Correction to Front-Page Attack on Netanyahu
Error: Contact form not found.
by Ira Stoll

The New York Times logo. Photo: Wikimedia Commons.
The New York Times has already issued a correction to its latest front-page attack on Israel’s prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu.
“An earlier version of this article misidentified Moshe Kahlon, a member of Benjamin Netanyahu’s government. He is the finance minister, not the foreign minister,” the correction says.
If the Times is candid with its readers — a big “if” — it’ll be the first of several corrections eventually appended to the article.
The Times writes, “The pact between Mr. Netanyahu and the Kahanists set off a predictable eruption from liberal Jewish groups like J Street and Americans for Peace, as well as the Union of Reform Judaism, which normally stays out of Israeli politics.”
The correct name of the group the Times is referring to is not “Americans for Peace” but “Americans for Peace Now.”
The Times also writes, “In Israel’s chaotic parliamentary system, small parties like the ultra-Orthodox Shas can be make or break when it comes to forming a majority coalition after an election, and Mr. Netanyahu has routinely struck deals giving them outsize influence.”
Shas has declined in recent years, but for the purpose of general historical context such as the Times is attempting to provide, it is not a “small” party. In 2013 it won 8.75 percent of the vote, enough for 11 seats in Israel’s parliament. In 1999 it was the third largest political party in Israel, winning 13 percent of the vote and 17 seats in the 120-member Knesset, drawing not only “ultra-Orthodox” voters. In 1999, the politician who struck a coalition deal with Shas wasn’t Netanyahu but rather Ehud Barak of the Labor Party. This may seem like a minor detail, but it undermines the point of the Times article, which is that Netanyahu caters to extremists or fringe elements in Israeli politics. It’s not a characteristic unique to Netanyahu; rather, it’s a standard feature of coalition politics in Israel regardless of the individual or party forming the coalition.
All these errors erode the credibility of the Times coverage. If the newspaper can’t get basic factual points right in a front-page news article, why should readers believe the rest of the newspaper’s narrative?
What’s more, such factual errors aren’t rare exceptions, but are typical of Times coverage of Israel and Jewish matters. Some previous examples include what the Israeli consul general in New York, Dani Dayan, called the “correction of the year,” about Palestinian payments to families of terrorists; confusing Orthodox and Conservative Judaism; and a seven-sentence, “epic” correction of a hatchet-job profile of a prominent critic of the Iran nuclear deal.
Ira Stoll was managing editor of The Forward and North American editor of The Jerusalem Post. More of his media critique, a regular Algemeiner feature, can be found here.
Qatar Expands Strategic Footprint in Syria, Lebanon as Regional Ambitions Grow
El-Sayed Attempts to Mend Fences With Jewish Voters at Fundraiser, Announces Hire of Jewish Liaison
Academics Who Supported BDS Before Oct. 7 Attack More Likely to Accuse Israel of Genocide Now, New Study Finds
Israel, Greece Sign $3.5 Billion Air Defense Deal as Tensions With Turkey Continue to Rise
Trump Vows to Hit Iran Hard After First Exchanges of Fire in a Month
Saudi Arabia, Turkey, Pakistan Agree to Establish Secretariat Under Joint Defense Pact
Spanish PM Blames Russia, Israel for Disinformation in Ceuta Migrant Crisis
On Antisemitism, Many Democrats Mask Damaging Policies With Empty Rhetoric
Israel’s Democracy Does Not Need Foreign Supervisors
E1 Explained: The Small Zoning Tender That Triggered a Global Uproar





Israel, Greece Sign $3.5 Billion Air Defense Deal as Tensions With Turkey Continue to Rise
El-Sayed Attempts to Mend Fences With Jewish Voters at Fundraiser, Announces Hire of Jewish Liaison
Metropolitan Museum of Art Cancels Met Gala Exhibit on John Galliano Following Backlash Over Antisemitic Comments
Murderer of 37, Including 12 Children, Is a Role Model for Palestinian Women at University
Thousands of Israeli Expats Book Flights Home for High-Stakes Election



