Wednesday, August 23rd | 1 Elul 5777

Close

Be in the know!

Get our exclusive daily news briefing.

Subscribe
January 13, 2012 12:28 pm

The Scientific Foreknowledge of the Jewish Sages

avatar by Adam Jacobs

Email a copy of "The Scientific Foreknowledge of the Jewish Sages" to a friend

Brightt Nebula. Photo: European Southern Observatory.

There is something tantalizing in the notion that contrary to popular belief, ancient people may have been in possession of a far greater level of insight about the nature of reality than they have generally been given credit for. Though there is the danger for this exploration to rapidly veer off into the loony bin of UFO encounters, Atlantis theories and the like, there are some serious thinkers who have noted that some cultures seem to have been aware of aspects of the natural world that, all things being equal, they should not have been. The Israeli professor of engineering at Ben Gurion University, Haim Shore, is one of those people and he has recorded his findings in a fascinating work called “Coincidences in the Bible and in Biblical Hebrew.”

Though at no point does Professor Shore describe these data points as explicit proofs of anything, one is left wondering: if his examples are indeed true, what does it mean? How could human beings living hundreds or thousands of years ago have known about matters which they could not have verified through experimentation or that would have required knowledge of parts of the world that had not yet been discovered or phenomena that are fully invisible to the naked eye? One possibility is that they didn’t know anything about these matters and that it’s just wishful thinking or reverse engineering of facts that make it seem as though it were true. Another is that they speculated so often about so many matters that occasionally they just got lucky about a few random facts and supporters just cherry-pick the ones that work and have discarded the more embarrassing ones.

As it happens, in the cases described by professor Shore (and others), the Jewish People have been familiar with the quoted sources for an extremely long time – the Talmud, the Zohar and other ancient texts were well known and widely dispersed so it’s not as if the examples have been culled from some wholly esoteric source and then spun at some later date to sound like a more recent scientific discovery. The examples are also quite clear and specific – there is no convenient ambiguity that can be interpreted in a variety of ways. And while it is true that the sages discussed and believed much of the scientific wisdom of their day that is now known to be incorrect, (such as a belief in the spontaneous generation of lice or the advice that pregnant women should drink wine), they never claimed to have a lock on the totality of knowledge – scientific or otherwise. They only claimed that they were given the keys to certain aspects of life that in general would help them with their spiritual practice. It is interesting to note that in many examples they give which do appear to be correct they claim to know through tradition and not through any particular inquiry. If true, what would be logical to posit as the source of their knowledge? Here are three examples:

Number of Stars

Related coverage

September 16, 2016 2:04 am
1

Were God Merely to ‘Exist,’ Our Prayers Would Be Meaningless

“God is a circle whose center is everywhere and circumference nowhere,” said Voltaire. Indeed, trying to describe God is like trying to...

The Naked eye is able to perceive about 4000 stars in the night sky. Though the ancients might have wondered if there were any others beyond our perception there is no logical reason to assume that the number that they would imagine would be in the quintillions. There is even less reason to imagine that they would have suggested a number that is close (on a galactic scale) to the number that cosmology currently posits. This is what the Talmud had to say about it almost 2000 years ago:
“I created 12 constellations in the firmament, and for each constellation I created 30 hosts (clusters of stars), and for each host I created 30 legions (30 legions of stars for each host), and for each legion I created 30 divisions, and for each division I created 30 battalions, and for each battalion I created 30 camps, and to each camp I have attached 365,000 tens of thousands of stars, corresponding to the days of the solar year, and all of them I have created only for your sake.” (Brachot 32B)
Doing the calculations we see that:
– each camp has 3,650,000,000 (1000 x 10,000)
– 30 camps x 30 battalions x 30 divisions x 30 legions x 30 hosts x 12 constellations = 291,600,000 camps
– 3,650,000,000 x 291,600,000 = 1,064,340,000,000,000,000.
It is interesting to note that in 1997 NASA concluded there were 10 to the power of 21. Other sources suggest both smaller and larger numbers. The Jewish sages said it was 10 to the power of 18. Whatever the actual number may be, what would have prompted them to speculate on such a massive scale?

Continental Drift

Genesis 1:19 says “Let the waters under the heaven be gathered together unto one place and let the dry land appear. And it was so.” Again, around 2000 years ago the Zohar Chadash (12:1) explained that “one single continent came out of the water, and from it seven continents were formed.” (There is a dispute between academics and religious scholars on the issue of the Zohar’s age, but either way, the texts are, by any standard, pre-scientific revolution). There are manuscripts and references to the Zohar that go back as early as the 14th century, yet the first scientist to talk about continental drift was Alfred Lothar Wegener in his book “The Origin of Continents and Oceans” in 1915. By what means would these sages have acquired the notion a) of a single land mass that broke apart, and b) the correct number of continents before they were even discovered? Why would they even discuss it?

The Law of Conservation of Mass and Energy

250 years ago Anton Lavoisier, (the father of modern chemistry), proved that matter that appears to have been destroyed continues to exist in a different form. It was a striking discovery due especially to the non-intuitive nature of the reality – when you burn a piece of paper it really does appear to be gone. 2800 years ago, King Solomon wrote the following in the book of Ecclesiastes “I know that whatever God does, it shall be forever; nothing can be added to it or taken away.” 1500 years later Rabbi Saadiah Gaon in his book of Beliefs and Opinions explained this verse to mean that “…a created object can never annihilate another object in any way. Even if it is burnt with fire, it can never be annihilated; because it is impossible to destroy something to the point that it becomes nothing; for only God [can do this], who himself created it from nothing.”

Other examples that strangely parallel with our modern, scientific understanding:

– The origin of the universe
– The exact length of the lunar cycle
– The existence of the outer layer of the sun
– Water in space
– Meteorites as a source of water on planet Earth
– The effects of sound waves on matter
– The weight of air
– How the conception of twins occurs
– The day when blood coagulation begins

Each one of these examples may be coincidental and there may be a variety of alternative methods of explaining them. But what if they are (as these sages claimed) the revealed wisdom of a transcendental power – one for whom this foreknowledge would be rather intuitive as it was the designer of the system in toto? Would that not be a simple and elegant solution to the question? At the very least, it’s intriguing.

Share this Story: Share On Facebook Share On Twitter Email This Article

Let your voice be heard!

Join the Algemeiner
  • salvage

    And yet the Bible Torah whatever still got Pi wrong, made no mention of anything microscopic from cells to bacteria and insists that the universe was made in six days a little over 6,000 years ago by an angry god that later demanded foreskins be removed.

    Myths.

    The Egyptian versions that predate the Jewish ones by a said much of the same things by the way. Do you think that a coincidence?

    And the fact that they sorta kinda got some things right doesn’t change all the stuff they got comically wrong.

    • yuri

      @sakvage
      Let’s get this straight statement buy statement.
      1. Show me the mentioning of Pi in Torah or other books, please. I have to see it yet and to read commentaries on it if there are any Then we can discuss the subject
      2. Sages did discuss bacterias and made stern warning in Schulhan Aruch not to drink from other person’s cup for example. They went as far as telling that such person might appear in a good health, but he being a host can pass bacterias that might be dangerous to others. This is just one of many examples. They knew about microbes, what danger they present and how to deal with that.
      3. If you don’t understand a concept of 6 days of creation, of divine years vs human years, of 6,000 vs 15 bil

    • yuri

      @sakvage
      Let’s get this straight statement buy statement.
      1. Show me the mentioning of Pi in Torah or other books, please. I have to see it yet and to read commentaries on it if there are any Then we can discuss the subject
      2. Sages did discuss bacterias and made stern warning in Schulhan Aruch not to drink from other person’s cup for example. They went as far as telling that such person might appear in a good health, but he being a host can pass bacterias that might be dangerous to others. This is just one of many examples. They knew about microbes, what danger they present and how to deal with that.
      3. If you don’t understand a concept of 6 days of creation, of divine years vs human years, of 6,000 vs 15 bil years – then ask. Don’t portray ourself as an ignorant person. Ditto about “angry” G-d.
      4. Egyptians worshiped goats, crocodiles, scarabs, Nile, Pharos worshiped themselves…. Should I continue with the primitivism and paganism of their spiritual level? And you are saying that Jews said the same?? How’s comical now?

      Let me know if you’d like to check the sources for #2 specifically

      P. S. or call it a bonus, lol. Do you know that 13th century rabbi Yitzhak of Acco, a colleague of Nachmanidis estimated the age of our Universe being… 15.3 bil years.

    • dovi

      Egyptian versions predate the Jewish flood story? Whaat?

      Also about the no mentioning of cells and bacteria, that’s wrong. The Torah says about the manna that first came the worms and then the smell. This seems contradictory, doesnt the smell come before the worms? the answer is that these worms were microscopic worms which appeared on the manna before the smell.

  • gerry mac

    When people spend most of their time thinking, studying and meditating why is it shocking that they discover great truths,and are these not the same sages that gave us the concept of One Universal G*D upon which most of the world’s religions are based.

Algemeiner.com