Thursday, September 21st | 1 Tishri 5778

Close

Be in the know!

Get our exclusive daily news briefing.

Subscribe
October 28, 2014 2:48 pm

In Wake of Ottawa Attack, Senior Canadian Jewish MP Irwin Cotler Calls for ‘Comprehensive’ Anti-Terrorism Strategy (INTERVIEW)

avatar by Ben Cohen

Email a copy of "In Wake of Ottawa Attack, Senior Canadian Jewish MP Irwin Cotler Calls for ‘Comprehensive’ Anti-Terrorism Strategy (INTERVIEW)" to a friend

Canadian MP and former Justice Minister Irwin Cotler.

Few politicians in North America can boast Irwin Cotler’s pedigree as a human rights advocate. A former Canadian Minister of Justice and Attorney-General, Cotler, who represents the Mount Royal riding of Montreal in the Canadian parliament, has spoken out on behalf of dissidents and democracy activists on almost every continent in the world. Among those to have benefited from his counsel are Natan Sharansky, the famed Soviet Jewish refusenik who now heads up the Jewish Agency, the late South African president, Nelson Mandela, and Saad Eddin Ibrahim, the Egyptian democrat who ran afoul of former leader Hosni Mubarak, in the process becoming  one of Egypt’s most well-known political prisoners.

After several decades immersed in the worlds of parliamentary politics and international law, Cotler is set to retire from parliament in 2015, though he says he’ll remain active in public life. And he remains a thorn in the side of the world’s authoritarian regimes; in March of this year, Cotler was one of thirteen Canadian officials banned from entering Russia by Vladimir Putin’s regime, something he dubbed as a “badge of honor.”

When I spoke to Cotler yesterday, his mind was very much focused on last week’s terrorist attack on the Canadian parliament in Ottawa. “I was walking towards our Liberal Party caucus meeting on Wednesday morning when I was stopped by a guard who said, ‘you’ve got to turn back,'” Cotler related. “The shooting had already begun. I came back to my Department of Justice office, which is adjacent to the parliament building, where I was in a lockdown for the next ten hours.”

Together with his legislative assistant, Michael Milech, Cotler monitored the various news broadcasts, trying to figure out if one or more assailants was involved in the attack. He and his parliamentary colleagues, Cotler observed, were fortunate to have avoided a massacre. “If the shooter had turned right or left off the corridor where the caucus meetings were taking place and started shooting, that could have been a bloodbath,” Cotler said. “So we were fortunate to be saved from what could have been a much worse tragedy.”

Related coverage

August 29, 2017 5:47 pm
0

US Jewish Groups Praise Tillerson’s Renewal of State Department Antisemitism Envoy

US Jewish groups reacted with praise and relief on Tuesday to the news that Secretary of State Rex Tillerson is...

Cotler pointed to the critical role played by Kevin Vickers, the parliament’s Sergeant-at-Arms, who shot the attacker, Michael Zehaf-Bibeau, soon after he arrived at the parliament building from the National War Memorial, where he murdered the soldier on guard, Cpl. Nathan Cirillo. “He’s a person of imposing stature,” said Cotler of the 6ft4 Vickers, “and clearly one of great physical and moral courage.”

While he was stuck in his office waiting for the all-clear, Cotler received a call from his Israeli-born wife, Ariela, who was anxious to learn whether her husband was safe. “After speaking to her for about five minutes, I asked her, ‘Ariela, was there a terrorist attack in Jerusalem today? Didn’t a three month-old baby die?’ And she said, ‘yes, but there it’s a way of life. In Canada, this is an exceptional occurrence,'” Cotler said.

As the dust settled on the Ottawa attack, Cotler told several of his colleagues about his conversation with his wife. “I alerted them to those two things, one that there had been this terrorist attack in Israel, and two, as my wife expressed it, the existential situation that Israel lives with all the time,” Cotler said. Among those he spoke to was Prime Minister Stephen Harper, who told Cotler that he had earlier conversed with his Israeli counterpart, Benjamin Netanyahu. Israel’s constant, daily struggle with terrorism was, said Harper, a theme that had also been emphasized by Netanyahu.

Cotler was frank that the coincidence of two terrorist assaults on the same day, one in Ottawa and one in Jerusalem, did not result in deeper sympathy for Israel’s predicament among many of his colleagues, in part because they were understandably preoccupied with the drama unfolding in the parliament building. “In Israel, it’s a matter of ongoing attacks, so people aren’t always paying attention,” Cotler explained. “Then the narrative coming out of Operation Protective Edge was one in which Israel was doing the attacking, and the Palestinians were the victims, which ignored the Hamas war of attrition and the stated aims of the Hamas Charter.” As a result, Cotler said, there is a greater focus on Israeli settlement activities rather than upon the human cost to the Jewish state of constant terror attacks, while the Palestinians are regarded more as the “victims of Israeli bombing, rather than those who started the terrorist assault on Israel itself.”

Turning to the future of Canada’s anti-terror policies in the wake of the Ottawa attack, Cotler stressed that a “rare solidarity” had taken hold. “Prime Minister Harper is not given to emotion,” Cotler said. “But the day after the attack in parliament, he made a very moving gesture. After he finished his own remarks, he walked over and hugged the leader of our party, Justin Trudeau, as well as the leader of the opposition, Thomas Mulcair. I don’t think I’ve seen that in the nine years he’s been Prime Minister.”

Even before the attack, Cotler said, there were plans afoot to enhance Canada’s anti-terrorism laws “with respect to investigation, detection, monitoring – we have some 90 Canadians who are under surveillance because they might seek to travel abroad to fight. So the question is, do the security services need greater surveillance powers? That’s going to be one part of the government’s anti-terrorism initiative. The person who carried out the attack on parliament was known to the authorities, in fact his passport was taken away, but he wasn’t arrested. So the feeling is that maybe the security services need greater powers of arrest and detention. And in another initiative, because social media is playing a role in radicalization, we’re looking at what we can do to counter the radicalization on social media. This is what’s being mooted at this point, and the legislation will be introduced probably before the end of this week.”

As a former Minister of Justice, Cotler believes that Zahaf-Bibeau could have been subjected to preventative detention. But, he added, the police officers he’d consulted with didn’t think that there was sufficient evidence to suggest that Zehaf-Bibeau was about to carry out an attack. The issue, Cotler said, is whether they are going to change the “evidence threshold” to make it easier to detain terror suspects.

I asked Cotler why he’d abstained, earlier this month, from a House of Commons vote on Canada’s joining U.S.-led airstrikes against Islamic State in Iraq. “My party voted against it,” he answered. “I would have supported it, but the government limited it to Iraq. I think they should have gone further, and gone into Syria. But I abstained because the prime minister made a very surprising statement in which he said we would only go into Syria if Assad agrees. For three and a half years now, I’ve been saying that we need to protect the innocent Syrian civilians and opposition under the ‘Responsibility to Protect’ doctrine. I’ve been calling for leadership to hold Assad accountable long before the jihadis came on the scene. Assad gave birth to the jihadis. When the prime minister made Canada’s involvement contingent on Assad’s permission, I said, ‘sorry, I can’t go along with that.'”

Ultimately, Cotler insists, what is needed is a more coherent strategy that casts its net much wider than IS. There remains, as he points out, the threat from groups like Al Qaeda, the Nusra Front, Hamas and Hezbollah and, of course, “their patron,” Iran. “I’m saying, ‘look guys, IS is getting a lot of attention because of the depravity of its killings.’ But it’s only one – admittedly important – terrorist grouping. We have to have a comprehensive appreciation of the nature of this radical evil. I don’t think we have that yet. We need an integrated approach of diplomatic, military, economic and legal measures that target all the actors, whether its those who are involved in finance, like Qatar, or those who are providing other forms of backing, as Iran is doing with Hamas and Hezbollah.”

Share this Story: Share On Facebook Share On Twitter Email This Article

Let your voice be heard!

Join the Algemeiner
  • stevieb

    Does this idiot really think he’s fooling anybody? As a unrepentanf zionist, the entire world know Colter supports terrorism. And as a Jew we know human rights for non-jews means nothing to him. How often has this charlatan spoke out against Israeli atricities or Soviet gemocide of Christians? I’ll tell you…never. And yet this moron thinks articles like this will convince decent people. They don’t.

  • KENNETH C WILLIAMS

    YES!!! 🙂

  • . As a child of holocaust survivors and one who lost most of his family, I beg you to speak out. Women are being raped, men and women and children are dying every second. They ask some to go to the right and some to the left. It is the concentration camps all over again.

    ISIS is the devil, Hitler reincarnated. Speak out now before it is too late. Share this you tube today with the media and all your contacts. As a child of holocaust survivors and one who lost most of his family, I beg you to speak out. Women are being raped, men and women and children are dying every second.

    : MR. PRESIDENT. Why did you not mention Iran in your speech at the U.N. Open your eyes and see that without boots on the ground Isis is winning. You were never in the military and do not understand combat. I am a Rabbi of a small congregation and do not have rich congregants. I ask that this you tube go viral. SO FAR THERE ARE . over..6000 HITS. THIS IS THE ONLY WAY I HAVE OF SPEAKING OUT.

    . “It is time for the world – especially Muslim communities – to explicitly,
    forcefully, and consistently reject the ideology of al Qaeda and ISIL.”
    President Barack Obama, Address to the United Nations General Assembly
    September 24, 2014

    120 Muslim scholars, including the Grand Mufti of Egypt, the dean of Sharia
    and Law at al-Azhar University, director of the Fiqh Council in the US, and
    the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem published an open letter to IS leader Abu Bakr
    al-Baghdadi decrying his state’s un-Islamic behavior in three languages:
    Arabic, English and German.

    Video of Rabbi Dr. Bernhard Rosenberg SAYS: President Obama, You Have Some Nerve:.

    Video is on http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ig8c795KymA

    Another holocaust is possible. If it happened once it can happen again. Thank G-d we have Israel. We need to do everything possible to keep Israel militarily strong. Jews get out of Europe. There can be no compromise regarding Israel nor can we depend on the good will of others. This unfortunately is a lesson that many Jews have never learned. Never forget, never forgive never again. Rabbi Dr. Bernhard Rosenberg
    MR. PRESIDENT.

    ISIS is a diversion. Iran is our major threat. Throughout history horrible atrocities including cutting off heads has been committed. This is not something we have never seen. Remember the NAZIS and never forget.

    We can beat ISIS but America Israel and the free world cannot survive a Nuclear Armed Iran .A Nuclear Holocaust is the ultimate nightmare, the ultimate threat to our survival, Iran is constructing the ultimate killing machine.Rabbi Dr. Bernhard Rosenberg

  • Kris Kristian

    I AM GLAD THAT COTLER USED THE WORD “TERRORIST” AND NOT “MILITANT”
    UNFORTUNATELY, IT SEEMS AS THOUGH THE WORLD IS AFRAID TO CALL ISLAMIC TERRORISTS, BECAUSE IT WOULD “UPSET” THE MUSLIMS.
    TIME FOR THE MEDIA TO WAKE UP. A TERRRORIST IS NOT A MILITANT.
    READING NEWS PAPERS, OR WATCHING TV, IF ONE IS CONCERNED, THE NEWS ALWAYS BLAMES ISRAEL FOR PROTECTING ITSELF AGAINST ISLAMIC TERROR. BUT THEN THEY REFUSE TO USE THE WORD TERRORISTS.

    THANK GOD FOR PM HARPER AND MR COTLER WHO SUPPORT ISRAEL AGAINST ISLAMIC TERRORISM.

    IF PEOPLE BELIEVE IN GOD AND HEAVEN, THOSE GREAT POLITICIANS WILL BE REWARDED ONE DAY TO MEET GOD.
    MAY THEY LIVE TO A RIPE OLD AGE BEFORE THEY MEET GOD.

  • A good and decent man of rare courage. Who is now telling the world that leaders must see through the fog of disbelief and focus on the reality that is now besetting and assailing the world, resulting from Islamism’s growing strength.

  • Tzvi Jacobs

    In today’s National Public Radio’s 4-minute, 36-minute report about the murder of Cpl. Nathan Cirillo, of blessed memory, NPR talked at length about added security or lack of added security at government offices in Canada but didn’t mention that this terrorist could have arrested before the act was committed. They neglected to mention that authorities had been aware of the murderer and his connection to Islamic terrorists, and that his passport had been revoked, as mentioned in your thoughtful and in-depth article. Perhaps NPR should use the Algemeiner as their source for information. Or perhaps the heads of NPR should be removed and replaced with true journalists.

  • Tzvi Jacobs

    In today’s National Public Radio’s 4-minute, 36-minute report the murder of Cpl. Nathan Cirillo, of blessed memory, they talked on length about added security or lack of added security at government offices in Canada but didn’t mention that this terrorist could have arrested before the act was committed, that authorities had been aware of the murderer and his connection to Islamic terrorists, and had even revoked his passport, as mentioned in your thoughtful and in-depth article. Perhaps NPR should use the Algemeiner as their source for information. Or perhaps the heads of NPR should be removed and replaced with true journalists.

  • myra vero

    Now Canada got an experience, how terrible are the terrorist attacks, Israel got it every day and nobody takes any notice. Everybody blames Israel only for everything.

  • HE’S A GOOD JEWISH BOY..MR. SCUMBAY PUTIN IS FEARFUL OF HIM

Algemeiner.com