Tuesday, April 24th | 9 Iyyar 5778

Close

Be in the know!

Get our exclusive daily news briefing.

Subscribe
December 13, 2017 11:53 am

Jewish Organizations’ Disgraceful Rejection of Trump’s Jerusalem Recognition

avatar by Shmuley Boteach

Email a copy of "Jewish Organizations’ Disgraceful Rejection of Trump’s Jerusalem Recognition" to a friend

The Israeli flag at Jerusalem’s Western Wall. Photo: Hynek Moravec via Wikimedia Commons.

President Donald Trump’s decision to recognize Jerusalem as the capital of Israel, and begin the process of moving our embassy there, was positively courageous. Given the cowardice of his predecessors on this subject, that is perhaps the correct adjective; however, the president simply corrected a longstanding injustice and recognized both historical and political reality. Most Jewish organizations understandably applauded Trump’s action, but a surprising many condemned him — and thereby revealed their true level of support for the homeland of the Jewish people.

Given the antipathy of many Jews for this president, perhaps it is not surprising that groups from the left would criticize Trump. Still, I thought that Jerusalem was one issue on which there was near universal Jewish agreement in America — as there is in Israel, where the president’s announcement was welcomed by politicians from across the political spectrum, with perhaps the exception of the far-left and Arab parties.

The Jewish Democratic Council of America supported the president’s decision. But, in an unnecessary potshot asserted that the administration “has neglected efforts to meaningfully support peace between Palestinians and Israelis.” Couldn’t they hold their fire for just a few days and savor the moment on Jerusalem?

“Israel’s capital is in Jerusalem and it should be internationally recognized as such in the context of an agreed two-state solution that also establishes a Palestinian capital in East Jerusalem,” according to J Street.

Related coverage

April 23, 2018 3:04 pm
0

How Not to Beat BDS

JNS.org – The BDS movement hasn’t won many victories in the United States in recent years, but Israel’s opponents had...

The New Israel Fund, a group that funds organizations calling for the boycott of Israel, called the president’s decision “dangerous, reckless, and irresponsible.”

Americans for Peace Now, another far-left group that supports the antisemitic boycott, divestment and sanctions (BDS) campaign, said: “Trump is causing severe damage to the prospects of Middle East peace, imperiling lives, and degrading U.S. leadership.”

Perhaps the most disappointing response came from Rabbi Rick Jacobs, president of the Union for Reform Judaism, who agreed in principle with the president — but said the group could not support moving the embassy “absent a comprehensive plan for a peace process.”

How absurd. Why should locating our embassy in Israel’s capital, the only capital in the world where we do not have an embassy, be tied to the peace process? For those who have been asleep for the last eight years, there is no peace process. Mahmoud Abbas has refused to speak to his Israeli counterpart since 2008.

And who is supposed to come up with this comprehensive plan? The State Department has been trying unsuccessfully for decades. Are we really supposed to hold our embassy hostage in the hope that Rex Tillerson or anyone else in the administration, the EU, or the UN will come up with the magic formula that has eluded everyone else?

There is no shortage of peace plans, many of which seem reasonable. The problem is not the plans; it is the Palestinians’ refusal to contemplate any compromise that accepts the existence of a Jewish state in the Middle East. Never was this clearer than in 2000, when Ehud Barak offered to withdraw from the entire Gaza Strip (before Israel did so unilaterally in 2005) and 97 percent of the West Bank, evacuate most settlements and give the Palestinians sovereignty over some parts of Jerusalem. Yasser Arafat vetoed the deal, and Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas rejected a similar offer in 2008.

The dispute is not about land: it is historical, geographic, political, psychological and, perhaps most importantly, religious. It is unacceptable to the Palestinians that Jews should rule over Muslims, or have a state on what they consider Islamic territory. Look at their maps and their symbols, which show “Palestine” replacing Israel. I defy anyone to show me an official Palestinian map that depicts a Palestinian state beside Israel — with or without East Jerusalem as its capital.

And, incidentally, what right does J Street have to speak for the people of Israel in offering to divide the capital of the Jewish people? Talk about chutzpah.

Until the proponents of more peace plans accept the reality of the Palestinians’ agenda, they are wasting everyone’s time and creating the perpetual conditions for denying recognition of Israel’s capital. It is also hypocritical for countries to demand that America delay moving our embassy when they did not wait for the conflict to be resolved before opening consulates in Jerusalem to serve the Palestinians.

If anything, Trump’s critics have the situation exactly backwards. Now is precisely the time to recognize Jerusalem and move the embassy — because that may finally convince the Palestinians that time is not on their side. They cannot put off making concessions if they hope to remain credible in any discussions. Israel is not going to stop building settlements in land where 80 percent of Hebrew Biblical events transpired, and which form the very cradle of ancient Jewish history.

When the Palestinians rejected Menachem Begin’s autonomy offer in the late 1970s, there were less than 10,000 Jews in the West Bank. Today, the number is nearly 400,000.

Israel has shown that it is willing to make tough, even irresponsible sacrifices, as it did when giving up the Sinai to Egypt and withdrawing from Gaza. These proved to be serious strategic errors, as the Sinai has now largely become an ISIS state, and Gaza is controlled by genocidal Hamas. The Palestinians have also demonstrated nothing but obstinacy and squandered opportunities for statehood — in 1937, 1947, during Jordan’s occupation, in 1979, 1993, 2000 and 2008.

I pray for peace, but it will not be the result of a peace plan concocted by outsiders. Peace will come when Palestinians sit down opposite Israelis, accept Israel’s existence and demonstrate to the Israeli people — not the UN, the EU or anyone else — that they are prepared to coexist beside a strongly defined Jewish state. If they do, they will find Israelis willing to reach out to them as brothers. And that is the only peace formula that has any chance of success.

Rabbi Shmuley Boteach, “America’s Rabbi,” whom The Washington Post and Newsweek call “the most famous Rabbi in America,” is the international bestselling author of 30 books, including his most recent, “The Israel Warrior.” Follow him on Twitter @RabbiShmuley.

The opinions presented by Algemeiner bloggers are solely theirs and do not represent those of The Algemeiner, its publishers or editors. If you would like to share your views with a blog post on The Algemeiner, please be in touch through our Contact page.

Share this Story: Share On Facebook Share On Twitter Email This Article

Let your voice be heard!

Join the Algemeiner
  • Beer Baron

    You are full of crap. The Reform movement opposed the foundation of the State of Israel also opposed recognizing Jerusalem as Israel’s capital.

  • Ethan P

    The overt hate (Trump derangement syndrome) is so great it can not allow compromise! I honestly believe that Progressive Jews, most of whom share a similar hate for Israels PM, would see Israel destroyed if it damages President Trump!

  • robert Davis

    leftwing are totally void of brain they are fools on all issues, economic, political and the word peace does not have concrete meaning for them it’s just a word and they don’t even understand this word. Palestinians are Jews not arabs and therefore calling arabs palestinians is a mistake on which nothing can be buildt even less …peace. Most absurd is to think they can force the kind of peace they want ie based on weakening Israel is peace : it would only be the spark of a large war which is the contrary of peace. Everything the idiot lefters want is contrary to reason.

  • nutella59

    “Jewish” organizations?…
    THERE NOT MUCH “JEWISH” LEFT IN THE REFORM CONGREGATIONS AND THEIR ORGANIZATIONS…

  • Yitzhakhazak

    There is always a dissident minority in every society, in spite of what is necessarily true. We have our own schlemiels.

  • Adela Pisarevsky

    THANK YOU WITH ALL MY HEART Rabbi Shmuley Boteach for telling it like it is about certain “Jewish” groups who erroneously or maliciously (or both) are always against every positive step toward firming up the righteous position of Israel and Jews all over the world.

    I wish you and yours a Very Happy Hanukkah!

    AM ISRAEL CHAI!!!

  • Menachem Ben-Yair

    President Trump did the right thing. G-d bless him. And may HaShem smite those who condemn the decision and call themselves Jews.

  • graylens

    As much as some want to blame Trump for the lack of a peace agreement one should remember that the “peace process” has seen Pres. Carter,Bush,Clinton,Bush,Obama, and Trump all unable to get a peace. Similarly Israel has been led by Rabin,Perez,Netanyahu Barak, with members of the far left like Meretz in power. Maybe just maybe the fault lies with the PA

  • Bishadi

    Moving the embassy just not mean ‘zion’ is israel.

    • Dvirah Talbi

      Explain, please.

  • Beer Baron

    The same Reform Movement that opposed the very foundation of the State of Israel also opposed recognizing Jerusalem as Israel’s capital.

    That should pretty much tell you all that you need to know about the Reform Movement.

Algemeiner.com