Friday, February 26th | 14 Adar 5781

May 15, 2019 5:18 pm

German Government and Police Criticized Again for Downplaying Islamist Involvement in Antisemitic Offenses

avatar by Ben Cohen

German Federal Interior Minister Horst Seehofer and Holger Muench, Chief Commissioner of Germany’s Bundeskriminalamt (BKA) Federal Crime Office, attend a news conference on politically motivated crimes in Berlin, Germany, May 14, 2019. Photo: REUTERS/Hannibal Hanschke.

Official German government statistics on rising antisemitism came under criticism on Wednesday, as several observers charged that the data was based on the incorrect assumption that far right activists are to blame for the vast bulk of anti-Jewish incidents in the country — despite evidence from Jewish victims indicating that Muslims influenced by Islamist and antisemitic beliefs are behind an increasing number of these outrages.

Interior Minister Horst Seehofer revealed at a press conference on Tuesday that antisemitic crimes in Germany rose by 20 percent in 2018. “This is a development that we have to confront, especially in this country,” Seehofer said, in a reference to Germany’s Nazi past.

But some reporters questioned the claim of both Seehofer and German federal police chief Holger Münch that far right activists were behind 90 percent of the antisemitic offenses.

In response, both men insisted that the police practice of automatically categorizing as “far right” those antisemitic crimes where the motives were unclear made practical sense — “otherwise there we would be the accusation that we are blind to the right,” Seehofer explained.

Related coverage

February 26, 2021 2:56 pm

Man Arrested for Shouting Antisemitic Abuse at Soldier Guarding French Synagogue

A man has been sentenced by a French court for verbally abusing soldiers standing on guard outside a synagogue in...

According the German news outlet Welt on Wednesday, “critics of the current registration method suspect that antisemitic offenses are too often classified as right-wing when no suspect is known  to the police — but the crime is actually committed by a Muslim, for example.”

Mounting evidence suggests that antisemitic acts by radical Muslims have a greater profile than the German authorities seem prepared to concede. Only last week, Marcel Luthe — a member of Berlin’s state parliament for the liberal FDP Party — disclosed that up to 60 percent of antisemitic offenses in the German capital had been incorrectly blamed by police on the far right, thereby diminishing the role played by Muslim extremists and militant anti-Zionists in attacking Jewish targets.

Previous studies in recent years have reinforced the anxiety about the methods used by the German police in classifying and combating antisemitism.

An April 2017 study by a commission of independent experts reported 80 percent of the victims surveyed as saying that their assailant had been of Muslim background. A more recent survey by the EU’s Fundamental Rights Agency, issued last December, reported that more than half of the victims of antisemitic attacks said they were targeted by groups other than the far right — 41 percent identified Muslims as their attackers, with a further 16 percent saying that far left activists were the perpetrators.


Share this Story: Share On Facebook Share On Twitter

Let your voice be heard!

Join the Algemeiner

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.