New Hebrew University Study Probes How Israelis and Germans Perceive Each Other
JNS.org – The Hebrew University of Jerusalem on Wednesday released the results of a recent study on how Israelis and Germans perceive each other.
According to the survey’s designers, the results reveal a “complex picture,” showing attitudes varying with ethnicity, age and a number of other factors.
The survey was prepared by the HU European Forum, and was conducted in Germany by H1 Medienanalyse/Infas and in Israel by the PORI Institute. In Israel, it was conducted via face-to-face interviews in respondents’ homes from Oct. 5 to Oct. 26 of last year, and included 1,006 men and women aged 18 and older. In Germany, the survey was conducted over the same time period via telephone interviews, and included 1,011 men and women aged 18 and older.
The study’s release coincides with newly elected German Chancellor Olaf Scholz’s first official visit to Israel, where he met on Wednesday with Israeli Prime Minister Naftali Bennett at Yad Vashem.
According to the survey, in Germany, attitudes to Israel varied according to age, whether the respondent was from the former eastern or western parts of the country and whether they had a history of migration. Israeli attitudes were found to correlate with ethnicity, Jewish or Arab, and among Jews with the degree of religiosity.
• A majority in both countries expect the new government in Germany to continue former Chancellor Angela Merkel’s approach towards Israel, including her assertion that ensuring Israel’s existence is in Germany’s national interest.
• About half of Israeli respondents said that they would like to see Germany involved as a mediator between Israel and other countries in the Middle East. About the same percentage of respondents in Germany said the same, while 40.5 percent were against the country playing such a role. Younger German respondents were much more likely to want their country to be diplomatically involved with Israel.
• Only 30 percent of Israeli respondents and 13.6 percent of German respondents had visited each other’s country, and many of those who had were repeat visitors. On the German side, most of those who had visited Israel were from the western part of Germany with no history of migration and were, on average, 63 years old.
• Exposure to and knowledge of the other’s country and culture was rather limited. Moreover, German respondents had difficulties distinguishing between Israeli and Jewish culture.
• Fifty-eight percent of Germans agree that antisemitism is currently a problem in their country. Seventy-two percent see it emanating from the far right, followed by 70.1 percent as emanating from the whole population and 58 percent from a Muslim minority. Respondents from western Germany were far more likely than those from the eastern part to view antisemitism as a problem. In eastern Germany, men were the group with the lowest percentage (38.5 percent) who agreed.
• Sixty-six percent of German respondents said criticism of Israel is not necessarily connected to antisemitic attitudes. In Israel, a majority also did not see criticism of Israel necessarily as a form of antisemitism, but felt that there could be, at least sometimes, a link between the two. Almost half of the Arab respondents did not make this connection at all.
HU European Forum professor Gisela Dachs, the survey’s principal author, believes that Israel and Germany are now at a critical stage in their bilateral relationship, the university said in a statement.
“We need to look to the future. History is a strong pillar but it fades away. The challenge is to build a shared future between Israel and Germany that is not only founded on a shared past,” she said.
“The importance of this survey lies in the fact that we collected concrete data not only about what the respondents think but also what they actually do,” said Dachs.
For example, the survey included questions about the frequency of travel to each other’s country and the ways in which respondents experienced each other’s culture. Dachs noted that “once you can identify a specific lack of knowledge, then you are in a better position to address it.” The survey therefore has implications, she said, for education and public policy by both governments.
The HU European Forum comprises of research centers, graduate study programs and research funds, and focuses on teaching and research connected to “important long-term processes in Europe,” and on Europe’s interaction with Israel and the Middle East, according to the university.